[Please note: I decided to upload this because I finished my editing pass through the whole article. Expect changes to be made to this article over the next week or two as I take more photos to fill in the many gaps in the articles’ photo selection. I may edit some text while I am at it as well, though most of that is done now. Adding video links would also be great but VERY time-consuming.]
Introduction
As a warning, this article is long, the longest of this series by a good margin. I thought about breaking this up into parts, but as it is much easier to search a single document than one broken into pieces, I kept the whole thing together. I hope that is okay.
In the first two parts of this series, I discussed the reasons why 1998 is gaming’s greatest year ever, discussed the gaming platforms available in ’98, and covered some of the year’s best games, while also mentioning some important things that gamers today may consider drawbacks of ’98’s game library.
In this article I will go more in depth into 1998’s game library, genre by genre. This time, instead of only discussing the peak games that give 1998 its reputation, I will cover a great many of the games of 1998. In some genres I will cover most of the games even maybe of note, while in others I will leave some games out, but either way this will be a long list and will not only contain all-timer greats. This is a very ‘me’ kind of article, considering how often I buy games of less than stellar quality while passing on the greats… heh. To be fair to the games in this article, though, most of them are at least average to great. I hope the readers enjoy, and learn something about many of the interesting games of 1998. In order to make it easier to learn about the games, I will make the first mention of many games be a link to a video of gameplay of that title. I will give preference to videos without someone talking over the gameplay where they are available. Additionally, the platform and, for titles not from 1998 or with some releases not in 1998, are in parenthesis after the name of the game.
A Reprise of the Main Points of the Previous Parts
Electronic gaming history can be divided into periods of time, and during each one different types of gaming dominated in different regions. In this series I have proposed breaking gaming into five eras; see parts one and two for more on that. 1998 was, in retrospect, the cumulation of about fifteen years of gaming history, what I call the second era of gaming. That year several things happened at the same time which combined to make it gaming’s greatest year ever, a special moment in time probably impossible to repeat considering the advancement of technology.
First, in 1998 developers showed that they had improved their knowledge of how to make 3d games enough that finally we started to get definitive titles which showed what games can do in 3d in a way very rarely seen before. 3d gaming had not reached the point of feeling “good enough” for games to hold up as-is indefinitely, that would come in the next decade, but things were significantly closer to “good enough” than they ever had been before. Again, time in reality passes in a linear manner, but as we perceive it in gaming it does not; instead, the passage of time speeds up or slows down depending on how dated a game feels to play. In the ’90s, technology was improving so quickly that in just a few years that kind of change was extremely noticeable. Today in the 2020s, that is no longer the case. Graphics today are good enough for tech improvements to be much less noticeable, and game design and interfaces are modern and follow expected styles. A ten year old game today can still feel modern and current in a way unimaginable in the ’90s.
1998 may not have been fully modern, but the gamer of today will find it significantly easier to go back to the games of ’98 than 3d games of any year before. For example, The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time’s implementation of 3d lock-on targeting was hugely influential. It may not have been the first 3d game with any targeting system, but it is the definitive one. You see something similar with stealth mechanics and the trio of stealth games of ’98, Thief most importantly but also Metal Gear Solid and Tenchu, and with first-person shooter design and Half-Life, among others. As for 2d games, 1998 was not a good year for 2d games on home consoles, but on computers and arcades 2d games were still a big deal. 2d sprite art saw its near-perfection in 1998, as you see with Capcom and SNK’s arcade games particularly, along with some PC games like Starcraft. 1998 is great both because of its advancements in new gaming technology and also because of its refinement of the old.
Second, for PC and arcade games, 1998 is great because it was, business-wise, that mountaintop. Game design was at a pinnacle that sales could not sustain the costs of continuing, and the result would be a rapid decline in both categories within a few years. Yes, I’ve been thinking about this question a lot recently, but I think that a big part of why 1998 is usually the pick for gaming’s best year is because of because it was the top of that mountain. These factors, happening at the same time, combined to give us many of the best and most important games ever, all in the same year. A few genres did not see major releases in ’98, but most did.
In fact, for the North American PC market, perhaps ’98 is actually just a bit down that slope of the mountain peak. This depends on whether you judge things based on sales success, or the greatness of the games in a vacuum. In the latter category, 1998 is the pinnacle, but for the former, prior years would be. After all, the games of ’98 helped bring down PC gaming by not selling enough to continue development of PC-specific games on the same scale as the industry had been before. The projects that released before studios either shut down or moved over to consoles are titles which have remained in memory as legends to this day due to the contrast between those times and what things would become in the 2000s, days where everything seemed like it was either a console game or an MMO. Contrast, after all, is one of the keys to memorability.
But what are those games, by genre? The main purpose of this article is to provide lists of games, by genre, with descriptions of some titles, showcasing many of the best or most noteworthy titles of 1998. I have NOT played all of these games myself, but I have played many of them. The point is not to discuss only games I have played, but everything noteworthy. If your favorite game isn’t listed, I apologize; I tried to list most of the games worth discussing, but I know I left some out. There are too many to cover everything, sadly. I know that I am mentioning some games that probably aren’t as good as other games that I’ve not listed, but listing absolutely every retail title from the year would be too much; just go to Wikipedia or GameFAQs for that list. I think leaving some out is reasonable in the name of at least a shred of focus.
GAMES BY GENRE: Genre Strengths and Weaknesses of 1998, Expanded
So, we know that the top-end games of 1998 are the overall best ever. However, genre by genre, what is the years’ strength in each category, genre and subgenre? What games were released in that genre, subgenre, or category, what are the best ones, and what are other games that may be of interest?
Beyond that, the challenge I mentioned in the first article applies here: How many genres can you make a top 5 for that, if years were excluded, could be a solid all-time top five? For 1998, some genres pass that test. Others have good or great games, but the absence of certain key titles from other years gives away the game. And some genres are lacking compared to other years. Even the best year can’t be perfect. Some kinds of games that are popular today didn’t exist yet, after all, or were only barely getting off the ground. Let’s investigate, genre by genre.
I was deeply conflicted about what order to put the genres in. In the first version of this article, the genre order was somewhat random, which I am okay with. But for the second version I wanted to cover all the major subgenres instead of just the ones that came to mind or had peak games in them, and this led to a problem: if I use what I wanted to, which is the order in the ranked-by-1998 genre strength list from the first article, I would need to break genres up. After all, many genres have some subgenres much stronger in ’98 than others. Breaking up FPSes to note that the modern military shooter was in its major breakout year while other kinds were fully developed wouldn’t make sense, though, so I sadly had to abandon this approach. After thinking about it, my fallback position was the largely alphabetical order of categories in GameFAQs. I went with GameFAQs over other listing sites I use, most notably Mobygames and Wikipedia, because it has the simplest genre breakdown: every game, for better or worse, has a single genre. Both of those other sites have more complex systems that allow multiple genres to be applied to a game, which makes sense, but makes listing games by genre much harder. GameFAQs’ single-genres system works for most games and it is the site I use the most as well. Any site attempting to attach every game to a genre is going to have drawbacks, though, and all of these do. I will discuss some of these in the article below. I am sure some people don’t care about the categorization discussion portions of the article but I do, so they are staying.
Regardless of what order you put the genres in, it is important to remember that 28 years ago things were in some ways quite different from today. The genres that were considered the major, top-focus AAA genres in the ’90s are not the same ones as the industry of the past fifteen or twenty years. Times change. In the ’90s, the big genres were, in no particular order, sports games, platformers, first-person shooters, flight simulators, wargames, real-time strategy games, puzzle games, adventure games, racing games (where you race around a track of some kind, not open-world ones), fighting games, RPGs, action-adventure games, and city-building sims. These were all popular in all three main regions, North America, Japan, and Europe. Tank sims or tank action games and grand strategy or turn-based strategy games were also quite popular. These can be included in platformers or action-adventure games, but third-person action games were a growing genre in the second half of the decade but had not yet hit their peak of prominence that they would after Grand Theft Auto III (PS2, 2001). In Japan the shmup genre was also significant, though in the West its popularity dropped rapidly in the early ’90s and never recovered. If you think of the top genres today many of these are familiar gaming categories that are still popular, but others are not. Those differences do not make either that time or this time better, it is just a difference that is worth mentioning. Just know that genres not on my list above but that are popular today may not be as polished back then as ones that are.
Lastly, my big question for this article is how much time I should put in to finding decent videos to link. I put some video links in the first article, and some scattered ones in this, but many more games are in this one than that, and many readers will surely not know much about them. Video is helpful for that, but finding good ones is surprisingly time-consuming, and I’m not sure if it is worth it or not…
Table of Contents: My Version of The GameFAQs Genre List – The 10 Top-Level Genres, And Their Subgenres
This is the table of contents, which is basically GameFAQ’s genre list with a few modifications such as putting management sims into the Simulation genre where they belong instead of Strategy.
- Action
- Arcade
- Beat ’em Up
- Fighting
- Pinball
- Platformer
- Music/Rhythm
- FPS
- Flight Combat
- Car/Tank Combat
- Misc. Arcadey Action (Light Gun Shooter, Rail Shooter, Shoot ’em up (Top-down or Isometric), Run & Gun)
- Shmup
- Third Person Action or Third Person Shooter
- Action-Adventure
- General list
- General
- Linear
- Open-World
- Sandbox Third-Person Crafting
- Survival
- General list
- Adventure
- General list
- Graphic Adventure
- Visual Novel
- 3D First Person Adventure
- Text Adventure (Interactive Fiction)
- General list
- Miscellaneous
- Application
- Compilation
- Demo Disc
- Board/Card
- Edutainment
- Exercise/Fitness
- Gambling
- Party/Minigame
- Trivia/Gameshow
- Puzzle
- General list
- Stacking
- Matching
- Logic
- Hidden Object
- Puzzle-Action
- General list
- Racing
- Racing Simulation
- Arcade-style
- Arcade
- Futuristic
- Motorcycle or Snowboard
- Unrealistic modern racing (not arcade games)
- Kart or Character Racing
- Air Racing
- Topdown or Overhead-ish Racing/Combat
- Role-Playing Game (RPG)
- General [Turn-Based or Pausable Realtime]
- Action-RPG
- MMORPG
- RPG Subgenres:
- Action-RPG
- Japanese-style RPG
- Massively Multiplayer
- Roguelike
- Trainer
- Western-style
- Simulation
- Management (Building/Government or Management/Business)
- Flight (Military), Civilian Aviation, Underwater, or Tank
- Space (Combat or Civilian)
- Vehicle (Combat – Tank, Car, or Mech)
- Vehicle (Civilian)
- Vehicle (Train)
- Virtual (Career, Pet, or Virtual Life)
- Sports and Wrestling
- General List
- followed by list of all sports [Team and Individual] – see article for full list
- Strategy
- Real-Time, Turn-Based, or Wargame
- 4X Grand Strategy
- List of all subgenres – see article for full list
The List
Action

This image contains the beat ’em up, arcade action, and fighting games of mine I can find. Yes, it’s mostly fighting games. Note that many titles here are later console ports of arcade games from 1998; see below for details. Others are console ports released in ’98 of arcade games from previous years — these are the seven in the second and third rows from the bottom and Rampage. MK Gold (DC, 1999) is here to stand in for MK4 (PS1/N64), which I don’t own. The three in the bottom row are titles available elsewhere in previous years, so they won’t be mentioned in the actual article, but I put them in the photo anyway.
Action – Arcade Action
Top List: Battle Flip Shot (NEO/ARC), Prism Land Story (aka Sorcerer’s Maze) (PS1, JP release; US 2003), Dragon Dance (aka Pocket Color Block) (GB/C; JP ’98, US ’99), Spy Fox in Cheese Chase (PC)
Special Mention: Rampage World Tour (N64/GBC/PS1; home port of 1997 Arcade game).
Arcade action games are simple action games with a quick-play style. These may or may not be arcade games, and many arcade games are in other genres and not this one; this isn’t an ‘all arcade games’ category — shmups or racing games would go in their own genres, among others. Arcade Action includes things such as blockbreaking or ball and paddle games like Breakout or Pong, avoidance-based games like Pac-Man or Frogger, and such. I would consider the modern Frogger-style games to also be Arcade Action, though they do straddle the line in between this genre and Platformers.
This genre was certainly not at its peak in ’98; that peak was surely in the early ’80s. There were some of this kind of game in ’98, but nobody would believe it’s the best lineup ever, it certainly wasn’t. Still, all of these games are solidly fun at least. The most noteworthy arcade action release of the year has to be the home ports of the popular 1997 arcade game Rampage: World Tour (ARC ’97; N64/PS1/PC/GBC ’98). It’s a fun, if very repetitive, city-destroying sidescroller, very much like the original game but modernized.
These are the ball and paddle games: Sorcerer’s Maze is a ball-and-paddle game, and it’s fun. If you do play it though import the Japanese version, Prism Land Story — as with many titles, the US version was badly gutted of key features like the story, saving, and mouse support. Dragon Dance is another blockbreaking game, except on handheld. It’s fine. Battle Flip Shot is a modernized take on Pong, essentially. It was inspired by the popular classic Windjammers (NEO, 1995). I will mention it again in Sports games. Its one downside is that it has an improved sequel released a few years later, Bang Bead (NEO, 2000).
For maze games, that the last US-released SNES and Genesis games are solid, 1998-released ports of the early ’80s game Frogger is not amazing in terms of newness, but is worth mentioning. There had been a modern Frogger reboot in ’97 that sold quite well, but its sequel didn’t release until 2000. Even so, Hasbro did release a bunch of sequels to classic games in ’98, but that year they focused on board game adaptations. The only classic arcade followup they had in ’98 was Centipede (PC; PS1/DC ’99), which I will mention in the shooting games category. Hasbro’s new Q*bert (PC/PS1/DC, 1999) and Pong: The Next Level (PC/PS1, 1999) games would release in ’99, and Breakout (PC/PS1) and Frogger 2 (PC/PS1/DC/GBC, 2000) in 2000. Anyway, to get back on track, most other maze games were unknown little homebrew PC games. Occasionally one got a retail release with some kind of kid-friendly theme, such as Spy Fox in Cheese Chase (PC), a Pac-Man inspired title.
As a note, this combination of game types isn’t listed as a single genre everywhere — you won’t find these together on Mobygames for instance, but will on GameFAQs. It makes sense to me to combine these. They are different kinds of games designed with the same sensibilities.
Action – Beat ’em Up (2d or 3d)
There are two ways to look at this genre, either the classic brawler or the third person hack and slash action genre. For the former there were a handful of releases, but the genre had been in major decline for years in favor of one-on-one fighting games. For the 3d action games with beat ’em up inspired combat, there were a few interesting games but they have their issues as well, being early 3d titles. Excluding the third person shooters that may also have some melee combat, no titles in either category get a 7 or higher score on Mobygames. However this underrates game quality, for reviewers at the time were quite hard on classic beat ’em ups even if they were well made, since the genre is simple and wasn’t popular anymore.
Side or Isometric View Beat ‘Eu Ups
Top List: Dynamite Cop! (ARC; DC ’99), Legend (PS1, EU only; note this is a sequel to the first Legend (SNES, 1993)), Lucifer Ring (PS1, JP only), Ninja: Shadow of Darkness (PS1), Crisis Beat (PS1, JP/EU only).
The rest of the genre that year: The Soul (PC; South Korea only), Rèxuè Zhànjì (PC; homebrew game from China).
As I said, the beat ’em up was hugely successful from the mid ’80s to early ’90s, but crashed hard in about 1993 as one on one fighting games took over the fighting games market. They are more challenging and complicated games than the relatively simple button-mashers of the beat ’em up genre. And making things worse, beat ’em ups had a very rough time with the transition to 3d; the games got harder to control and play in 3d, emphasizing their bad traits too much. Very few polygonal 3d beat ’em ups are at all popular, then or now, and these games are all polygonal 3d.
With that said, though, the top game of the genre is one I quite like. Sega’s Dynamite Cop! is basically the sequel to Die Hard Arcade (ARC/SAT, 1996), except unlicensed. It has a similar theme as the first game, with side-view rooms you fight through, connected with occasional QTEs, something very new at the time. The game wasn’t appreciated at the time due to its simple gameplay and the Dreamcast version (released in ’99) scored poorly with a 65% critical average, but I think it’s a pretty good fun time.
I have not played any of the other games, but Lucifer Ring and Legend look at least decently interesting, with solid fantasy theming. Crisis Beat looks solid, clearly inspired by Die Hard Arcade (Arcade, 1996) as well, though it sounds like it plays worse than it looks. Their review averages are similar to Dynamite Cop, also in the 6’s, but it’s hard to say what that says about their actual quality. As PS1 console games they certainly do have worse graphics than Dynamite Cop, though.
Third Person Action Beat ’em Up (Behind the Character)
Top List: Spikeout: Digital Battle Online (Arcade), Die by the Sword (PC), Ablalaburn (PS1; JP only), Dark Vengeance (PC/Mac). I will cover most of these games again in the third person action games genre, but I should mention them here as well since their combat puts them very much as a descendant of the above genre.
While classic beat ’em ups were what they were, innovation in the beat ’em up happened in games like these, titles which take the hand to hand combat of a beat ’em up but use modern behind the character cameras. Of course many Action-Adventure games have primarily hand to hand combat as well, but games like The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (N64) or Shadow Tower (PS1) have other things going on beyond this genre, while games like these are more focused on just exploration, maybe some puzzles, and fighting. All four of these games are pretty interesting and worth a look. Spikeout is a Sega arcade game from future genre legend Toshihiro Nagoshi, who would go on to create the Yakuza franchise. It has top-tier graphics for the time and solid fighting action, but sadly never got a home release. In retrospect it is probably an important release for the genre, though, despite is obscurity. Die by the Sword is a highly experimental mess of a game with weird but innovative controls that only kind of work. More on this game later. Dark Vengeance is more open-ended; it’s got large levels with a lot of backtracking. The hack and slash combat is solid and you have a block button; it’s a bit like a predecessor to Rune (PC, 2001) or such. And Ablalaburn is a third person beat ’em up with side-view one on one fights from the developers of Battle Arena Toshinden. It looks like a simple but amusing time.
The beat ’em up genre would be revolutionized again a few years later, when Devil May Cry (PS2, 2001) reimagined the genre as one focused on simple but stylish combo attacks. Yes, I have always thought of Character Action games as beat ’em ups, albeit a subgenre of beat ’em ups that I have never liked at all. Sorry about that to its fans. These games have a core of simple hack and slash action, but also complex combo systems and QTEs. God of War (PS2, 2005) further boosted this new take on beat ’em ups to popularity, before these simpler games would fade in favor of the added complexity of Soulslikes. There has been a revitalization of retro sprite art isometric beat ’em ups in recent years, though, which is nice.
Action – Fighting
Fighting Games – Combined or 2D – Top List: The Last Blade 2 (ARC/NG), Street Fighter Alpha 3 (ARC), The King of Fighters ’98 (ARC/NG), Marvel vs. Capcom (ARC), Guilty Gear (PS1).
Honorable Mentions: JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure (ARC) (JP release; US ’99), Samurai Shodown! Pocket Fighting Series (Neo-Geo Pocket), King of Fighters R-1 (Neo-Geo Pocket). (The latter two games are JP exclusive releases which have sequels on the Neo-Geo Pocket Color that got Western releases.)
In addition to these, the first home ports of earlier arcade games Vampire Savior /DarkStalkers 3 released on PS1 & Saturn (Saturn JP only). Marvel Super Heroes vs. Street Fighter (PS1/SAT, Saturn JP only) and Pocket Fighter (PS1/SAT, SAT JP only) all also had their first home release in ’98 after ’97 arcade releases. Also the PS1 version of X-Men vs. Street Fighter was in ’98; it was a ’97 release on ARC & SAT.
This is a pretty seriously stacked lineup! It is unfortunate that Street Fighter III is one of those series which bookended 1998, but ’98 has an all time great year with some of SNK and Capcom’s best ever 2d fighters releasing that year. The Last Blade 2 is my favorite 2d fighter ever; KOF ’98 is one of the most popular games ever in that legendary franchise (KOF ’02 being the other top classic game in the series); SFA3 was Capcom’s most popular 2d fighter of the time and still is a beloved classic; Marvel vs. Capcom significantly improved over past Capcom Marvel games and set the stage for its iconic sequel (even if I’ve never been able to make any sense of how to play the games at all); and Guilty Gear was showed a new studio entering the genre, Arc System Works, one which would prove to be among the genre’s most important. The flashy action of Guilty Gear or Blazblue games is something to behold, and you see that right from the series’ beginning. And don’t forget JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure, known as JoJo’s Venture in the US, is an oddly little-remembered but beautifully animated game by some of the same staff who also worked on the Street Fighter III series. Given the games’ high sales in Japan at the time, how popular the JoJo series would later become, and the games’ high quality and stunningly animated visuals, it’s kind of surprising that it isn’t more popular today than it is.
As for those two handheld games, the two NGP games there are by far the best fighting games ever released on any handheld up to that point. There had been some decent fighting games on Game Boy and Game Gear, such as Takara’s King of Fighters games for Game Boy, but the NGP games are a level above any of them. Even better ones would release on the NGPC, in color, in 1999 and 2000, but the B&W model got off to a fantastic start with two easy but really fun to play and nice looking titles. Yes, the AI won’t be much of a challenge, but otherwise NGP/C fighters are fantastic. These titles are the first handheld fighters ever made that feel like console games in smoothness and quality.
As for 3d fighters, they weren’t anywhere near the 2d ones’ level this year. There are well over five 2d fighters from ’98 better than any 3d fighters that year. With that said some decent 3d fighters did release this year:
Fighting Games – 2.5D or 3D – There are basically two 1998s in this genre. On the one hand, home platforms got their first ports of three very important games. On the other hand though, while good, the actual fully new titles of ’98 are good but not on par with those.
The new games list: SoulCalibur (ARC) [note this is worse than the DC version], Bushido Blade 2 (PS1), Tech Romancer (ARC; DC ’99), Ehrgeiz: God Bless the Ring (PS1), Psychic Force 2012 (ARC; later PS1/DC). Honorable Mentions: probably Bloody Roar II (ARC; PS1 ’99) or Street Fighter EX2 (ARC; PS1 ’99).
The ports of earlier arcade games list: Tekken 3 (PS1; ARC ’97), Virtua Fighter 3tb (DC, JP release, elsewhere ’99; ARC ’96), Mortal Kombat 4 (N64/PS1; ARC ’97).
Here, the ports of earlier arcade games are much bigger names than the new games are. Tekken 3 is the best classic Tekken game, and was incredibly successful. Tekken 3 was apparently the highest-grossing arcade game in Japan in 1998, so the home port was of a still very relevant arcade game. I generally hate the Tekken series but even I will admit that Tekken 3 is a good game. The home release of Virtua Fighter 3tb is also noteworthy, particularly in Japan. While it never did much of anything in the US, VF3 was a very successful game in Japan in arcades. The home port isn’t as beloved as the first, second, or fourth VF games, but it’s still good. And Mortal Kombat 4… well, the game definitely wasn’t as popular as the 2d MK games that preceded it, but it still was a successful game at the time, with some very entertaining cutscenes and environmental interaction as well.
So yeah, if you count these ports, Tekken 3 in particular, 1998 was a good year for 3d fighters, but only looking at games first released anywhere in ’98, this list is underwhelming. SoulCalibur is the premiere new game, but again, for those who don’t know, the arcade SoulCalibur game runs on a PlayStation 1-based board. The graphics and gameplay were much improved for the Dreamcast release the next year. Japanese arcade magazine Gamest gave Psychic Force 2012 their GOTY award, but Western reviewers were much less kind. It’s a flying-people, somewhat shooter/fighter hybrid thing, a bit like a better version of Bio F.R.E.A.K.S. (N64/PS1), which is another fighting game of ’98, and one I didn’t mention in the list above because few like it. I actually find Bio Freaks decent fun, but Midway was unconfident enough in it to cancel the arcade version and release it only at home, so there’s that. I picked Bushido Blade 2 for second place because of these it’s the one I like playing the most by far and it has a deservedly good reputation and review average. It has an interesting anime-inspired and yet semi-realistic style. Ehrgeiz is a wrestling-inspired fighter from Square. It’s unique and has fans for sure. Tech Romancer is more forgotten, but it is a solidly decent Capcom giant robot fighter. Bloody Roar was Hudson’s fighting game series. It was clearly inspired by Tekken, but the characters all can transform into animal forms. I’ve never liked the series at all but many find them simple fun. Lastly, the Street Fighter EX series, despite using the name of Capcom’s most famous franchise, was developed by external studio Arika. They are okay but relatively unpopular games considered quite flawed compared to the main series.
So, there are solid games here, but overall this list is games that I think of as nowhere near the greatness of the wave of titles that would follow in just a year or two. I don’t think anyone would ever confuse this for a best ever list, not even close. The best games here are decent but have nothing on the greatness of the 2d fighters in the above category. 3d fighters would improve dramatically the next year, in 1999, with Dead or Alive 2 (ARC/DC, 1999) and the Dreamcast version of SoulCalibur.
Action – General
This ‘subgenre’ is used on GameFAQs for games which they can’t identify the actual genre of. Looking at the list everything there can be put in a proper genre if you try. N/A.
Action – Pinball
Real pinball tables were fading in ’98, heading towards a near-total wipeout but not quite there yet. I don’t play pinball much so I’m not sure about the order these games should go in, but that year Williams released Monster Bash; Sega released Lost in Space, Golden Cue, Godzilla, and Viper Night Drivin’; and Bally Midway released The Champion Pub and Cactus Canyon. I’m sure some of these are well known tables, but personally I’m not sure that I have heard of any of these. Maybe Monster Bash, that is known to be a great table. The next year all three of those companies left the pinball business and shut down their development teams. The form only survived because Stern Pinball bought the remains of Sega Pinball and restarted their company to replace it. For many years following Stern would be the only pinball manufacturer, though there are more small pinball companies now, as pinball machines have gained in popularity in recent years. Regardless, ’98 is right before the end that would come in ’99, and as such certainly is highly memorable.
For home platform pinball games, there are a fair number of options but one stands out far above the rest: Pro Pinball: Big Race USA (PC/PS1; EU ’98, US ’99), the third title in the Pro Pinball series of pinball simulations. Pro Pinball games tried to be as realistic as a real pinball table, and succeeded. Each Pro Pinball title has only one table that is just as good as a real pinball table. They are one screen wide by several screens high, so they scroll, but you also can zoom out to view the whole thing at once. Other, lesser pinball titles this year include 3-D Ultra Pinball: NASCAR (PC) and Addiction Pinball (PC). 3-D Ultra Pinball: NASCAR was the fourth of five games in the 3-D Ultra Pinball series. Thematically it may be the least interesting game in the series for most, except for those NASCAR fans out there, but the game’s simple but solid design shines though. Despite the “3-D” name the 3-D Ultra games were all pre-rendered 2d games, and the tables are designed to fit one screen each. There are multiple tables or table areas in each 3-D Ultra Pinball title, so everything is small, but the single screen nature is good for gameplay because it means you can see the ball’s movement without having to guess at how it will go as the screen scrolls. Addiction Pinball, from Team17, is a more realistic title, more like Pro Pinball than 3-D Ultra. It has tables based on several of their properties, including a Worms table.
Overall this was a good year for pinball both at home and in arcades. This situation would not survive 1999 at home either; the home pinball game never entirely went away and they are still popular, but as they faded out in arcades their popularity at home dropped as well. For many years after ’99 there were very few notable home pinball games apart from a few by Nintendo on their handhelds. The Pro Pinball and 3-D Ultra series would both end by 2000, for example. A developer called Zen Studios would go on to dominate home pinball. Their first pinball game released in 2007.
A photo of a bunch of the platformers I own from 1998. I apologize for not being able to find Space Station Silicon Valley (N64) and Psybadek (PS1), which I have and can’t find. I looked where they should be and they aren’t there, so yeah. Frustrating. I remember SSSV being in some random place where it isn’t supposed to be, but I have no idea where Psybadek went…

This image contains most of the platformers I have from ’98. I should retake it, my photo editing skills are abysmal as you can see. The lower GB/C cart is Turok 2, if you can’t make it out. The right side are 3d platformers, the left side 2d or 2.5d. My favorite game in this image is Goemon’s Great Adventure (N64).
Action – Platformer (2d/2.5d or 3d)
For platformers, if you are trying to convince someone this is a list of the best platformers ever, you’d need an excuse for why Mario games are not included, since there were no Mario platformers released in 1998. Just say that it’s a best platformers ever that aren’t Mario games list. I think the 3d platformers list is credible enough to convince many about its all-time legitimacy, but the 2d/2.5d list wouldn’t do so for most.
Platformers (3d)
Top List: Banjo-Kazooie (N64), Sonic Adventure (J) (DC), Space Station Silicon Valley (N64), Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped (PS1), Spyro the Dragon (PS1).
Honorable Mention: Burning Rangers (SAT).
Also Possibly Noteworthy: Gex: Enter the Gecko (PS1/N64), Tomb Raider III: Adventures of Lara Croft (PS1/PC), Tail Concerto (PS1), Montezuma’s Return! (PC, EU release; US ’99), Bomberman Hero (N64).
Lower Tier Titles: Chameleon Twist 2 (N64), Glover (N64/PC, later PS1), Pitfall: Beyond the Jungle (PS1), Ganbare Goemon: Kurunara Koi! Ayashige Ikka no Kuroi Kage (PS1, JP only release), Blasto (PS1), Starshot: Space Circus Fever (N64, EU release; US ’99. PC ’99 also).
Dishonorable Mentions for: A Bug’s Life (PS1/N64), Rascal (PS1), Psybadek (PS1)
This is a very solid list indeed loaded with beloved classics. This isn’t MY top list, I don’t think that any of these would be in my no-Mario all time top 6, but it is a very good list. All of the top group of titles are are many someones’ favorite 3d platformer ever. Sonic Adventure, Banjo-Kazooie, Crash 3, and Spyro I covered in part one. Sonic and Banjo are quite influential for the genres’ development, as Banjo typifies the collectathon style while Sonic Adventure finally started figuring out how to make a very fast-paced platformer in 3d, something nobody had succeeded at before. Both are definitely must-play games! These two are all-timers.
For the others, Space Station Silicon Valley has an interesting possession mechanic, giving you a variety of creatures to control in each of a series of Mario 64-style sandbox levels. It’s a pretty good and unique game from DMA Design of Grand Theft Auto fame; both of their N64 games released in 1998. Burning Rangers is short, but its jetpack-based gameplay is visually impressive and compelling while it lasts. The game is a third person platform/shooter where you have to put out fires. The game has perhaps the Saturn’s best 3d graphics. This is one of several jetpack games released in ’98, it seems to have been a theme of the year. And Spyro showed that the PS1 could, indeed, do a solid 3d platformer. It’s empty-feeling compared to an N64 one, and I find the constant cutscenes annoying, but it’s well made. Crash 3… it’s here for its fans. I’m not really one, but it’s fine, average stuff. I do like it best of the three PS1 Crash platformers though, and most people seem to agree — Crash 3 scored well. You can even play as Crash’s sister this time instead of only Crash himself.
For the second tier of 3d platformers this year, Gex 2 was a fairly successful game and scored the highest in this tier, but I’ve never entirely understood why. It’s a totally fine game, but the graphics are bland and the gameplay subpar. The constant humorous movie reference quotes have probably aged poorly as well. Not as popular sequel to popular classic Tomb Raider III (PC/PS1) released in ’98, if you consider Tomb Raider to be a platformer; it really is more of a third person shooter adventure. Either way on that, Tomb Raiders 1 and 2 were big deals, but I think that 3 is when the series started to feel like just more of the same to its fans, with levels too large and frustrating for many. The second game was a major event upon its release, but this one wasn’t quite on that level. Still, it is a quality title. Next, Tail Concerto is a cult classic beloved by its few fans. The US release is very expensive. It’s a short but apparently fun platform-action adventure. I’d love to own a copy someday. It would eventually get a now also expensive sequel on the Nintendo DS. Last in this group is a largely forgotten game. The PC first person 3d platformer Montezuma’s Return! is interesting stuff to look at. Making platforming work in first person is always challenging and it doesn’t entirely work here, but the effort was admirable. In each stage your goal is to avoid the traps and work your way through to the exit. The game is nowhere near the quality of those console games but I admire the attempt, and it kind of works. Oh, and yes, the game did release in Europe in ’98 before its 1999 US release. For the last game in this group I had to pick one, and I went with the solid, but not amazing, Bomberman Hero. It’s the only Bomberman game to be a full-on 3d platformer, but it’s done well enough to do. It got mediocre reviews, but would probably be in fifth on my personal top 5 3d platformers for the year list. It’s either this or Chameleon Twist 2, behind Banjo, Sonic, SSSV, and Burning Rangers, and this is the more original of the two. Supposedly it was originally concieved as a Bonk game before being switched over to Hudson’s premiere franchise. This explains a lot about the game, I think. My first reaction to Bomberman Hero was ‘A single player only Bomberman game? Why would they make that?’ but it’s actually well made.
The next tier contains two titles that could be in the next batch up; they have review scores just as good as Bomberman Hero. I just had to pick one and like that one the most. Still, Chameleon Twist 2 and Pitfall 3D are decent games with some flaws that probably are rated slightly too low. I liked Chameleon Twist 2, it’s a fun game. Very much like the first game, it is a cute and simple platformer where you have a very long tongue that can attach to things, allowing you to swing around in a circle while latched on. It uses its tongue gimmick well, and is a fun time just like the first one. Pitfall 3D is a somewhat ambitious title worth a look. The designers were really trying with this one, and it at least partially worked. It uses the classic Pitfall license for a new jungle adventure with a story. Infamously difficult Glover released in ’98. It is unique, but flawed. It’s a game where you play as a glove who has to guide a ball through challenging platforming levels. It requires a great deal of precision to succeed at. It is rated low because of the frustration factor but if you get into it you might like it. I’m not a fan but should give it another try sometime. On the other hand, I seem to be one of the only people who liked Starshot. I’m not sure why most seem to hate it, but I think it’s good. It has a circus theme and feels a bit janky in that European game way, but I at least liked it. The camera’s not great but it isn’t THAT bad! On the other hand, Goemon: Kurunarakoi is an okay but unfortunately forgettably mediocre game. I love the N64 Goemon games, but this isn’t on that level. This is the only truly 3d PS1 Goemon game, but it’s not a full open world like the previous years’ N64 game; instead, areas are linear paths and you go to the end of each section and then return back to where you started. The camera is pulled overhead as well. The controls are okay but somewhat janky. I’d call the game below average in both graphics and gameplay. The Playstation may not be able to match the best N64 3d platformers, but Spyro released this same year and is far better than this. Lastly, Blasto was a somewhat popular platform/shooter from Sony, voiced by popular actor Phil Hartman, who tragically died soon after the game released. The voice work is good but the actual gameplay is very bland and disappointingly mediocre unfortunately. You walk around platforms floating in space, struggling with poor controls to stay alive and defeat the badguys.
The bottom tier are games that are widely disliked for a reason. Rascal is a pretty bad, very young kid-focused game from Psygnosis. It’s kind of a kids’ third person shooter with platforming, but either way on that, it’s very poorly made. It might be the worst retail 3d platformer of ’98 by my book, or it might have been if A Bug’s Life didn’t exist; now THAT game is abysmal! I think that is a very VERY bad game, one of the worst. It’s more third person shooter than platformer but either way it’s a barely playable wreck. I have no idea how it got a 66% review average, but I think this is one of the worst games on the N64. At least on PS1 you get some movie clips, but the game itself is the same. Probably even worse than that is the utterly abysmal Psybadek, another “gem” from Psygnosis, a previously great developer. This is a horrible 3d platformer on hoverboards. The controls are very very slippery and make this game brutally difficult for the worst reasons. It doesn’t support analog, either, which is a crippling fault. And things just get worse from there, the level designs are bad and it can be hard to figure out what you should be doing in each stage.
But at least consoles also had plenty of great 3d platformers. The PC was not so lucky, as the PC was weak in this subgenre in ’98. After all, all the PC had for 3d platformers in ’98 were Tomb Raider III, Starshot, Glover, and Montezuma’s Return, and two of those only released in Europe in ’98, with US releases later. All four games got mixed receptions and are weaker than 3d platformers available on the PC in the years before and after — Bug! in 1996; Bug Too! and Croc in 1997; Croc 2, Tonic Trouble, and Rayman 2 in ’99… yeah. ’99 crushes ’98 in PC 3d platformers, that’s for sure, and I would put ’97 above ’98 as well; I love Croc, it’s a great game. There were some good 2d platformers on the PC in ’98, though. On that note:
Platformers (2d or 2.5d, regular or Metroidvania)
Top List: Goemon’s Great Adventure (JP release; US ’99) (N64) [7.6 Mobyrank], Wario Land II (GB) [the B&W version] [8], Wario Land II (GB/C dual mode; JP release, US/EU ’99) [colorized version of the former title] [8.1], Oddworld: Abe’s Exoddus (PS1/PC) [8.2], Montezuma’s Return (GB/C) [7], Jazz Jackrabbit 2 (PC) [7.5].
Honorable Mention: Heart of Darkness (PS1/PC) [7.7], Wild 9 (PS1) [7.6]. These two games are in the same tier as Jazz 2 in review average, it’s just a matter of opinion between them.
Also of Note: Super Tempo (JP only) (SAT) [7.2], Rockman & Forte [aka Mega Man & Bass] (SNES, JP only) [7.9], Ruruli no Rura (PC-FX; JP only) [no reviews], Iggy’s Reckin Balls (N64) [7.1], Rats! (GB/C) [6.6], Turok 2: Seeds of Evil (GB/C) [6.4].
Special Mentions: Akamajou Dracula X: Symphony of the Night [Castlevania: Symphony of the Night] (Saturn; JP only release, port of the 1997 PS1 game) [8], Klonoa (PS1) (JP ’97, US/EU ’98). Klonoa is one of the best and most popular 2.5d platformers, but it did release in Japan in late ’97, a bit like the inverse of Goemon’s Great Adventure. Between the two Klonoa is more popular I’m sure, but I like GGA the most. Any genre fan should play both. Also: Pocket Bomberman (GB/C) [6.9] released in ’98. It is the colorized version of a B&W GB game that released in Japan in late ’97.
Worst Game Candidate: Men In Black: The Series (GB/C).
In this category, if we go by Mobyrank, number one is Oddworld: Abe’s Exoddus, the second game in its series that started with Oddworld: Abe’s Oddysee (PC/PS1, 1997). The first two Abe games are side-scrolling puzzle/platformers from the highly animated sidescrollers school of games inspired by Prince of Persia, except with a lot of things you can do with Abe’s GameSpeak conversation system and a heavy focus on puzzles over action. I have never loved this subgenre, as it feels like you have less precise, instant control of your character in this kind of game, but this is one of the better games of its style. Sure, if this was a ‘how much I like the games’ list it’d be far below all other titles I’ve mentioned here, but it is a highly rated game and a classic of its genre. If you can figure out the GameSpeak system and get into the puzzles there’s a lot to like here.
If we go by Mobyrank the next two are Wario Land II and Mega Man & Bass, but I’m not just going in score average order. Instead I’d like to talk about my favorite game here, Goemon’s Great Adventure. GGA is one of my favorite platformers ever, which is why I put it in first. It’s outstanding, crazy fun, and it’s a tragedy that after this game Konami would never again put as much effort into a Goemon game as they did GGA. The game is like a crazy comedy anime crossed with a great 2.5d platformer, and the levels are as complex as you see in the genre in terms of use of 3-d space, as the paths you can take curve around eachother in quite interesting ways. Levels here are not a flat plane, and it’s fantastic. Moving on, Wario Land II is a weird game thanks to its no-die mechanic and puzzle-heavy focus, but while it can be quite frustrating it is pretty good. I’ve 100%ed it twice, once on SGB and once GBC.
Montezuma’s Return for Game Boy is a somewhat obscure game, but it shouldn’t be, it’s really good! It is remake of a classic title from the early ’80s. It is a flip-screen platform adventure where you jump around, get items, and figure out where to use them to work your way through the pyramid you are exploring. The items aren’t permanent upgrades but instead are keys or one-time-use items, so this probably isn’t a Metroidvania, though it certainly has the exploration of one within each level. This game is a nice improvement over the original, adding features such as password save once you finish each pyramid, or temple, or whatever. Also you start out in simpler levels, working up to larger, more complex ones as you go. This game is an A-grade game in my book, it’s highly under-rated. I know most would put Heart of Darkness or Rockman & Forte in their top five and not Montezuma’s Return or Jazz Jackrabbit 2, but I’d guess most of them have never given Montezuma’s Return a chance. You’d have a much better chance of convincing me to remove Jazz 2 than Montezuma’s Revenge. On that note…
There are three games in the next tier. I picked Jazz Jackrabbit 2 for the top five, but that’s just opinion. It is the least well known game here, but it probably should be more well known than it is. Epic deserves credit for releasing a 2d platformer on PC in 1998 alongside their FPS Unreal, the genre was mostly dead on PC or TV consoles by that point. The game is short, but it’s fun while it lasts. It has pretty small graphics, but that means that now you can see where you are going, unlike the first one from years prior. It’s still a classic western shooter/platformer. Heart of Darkness is another highly animated game of the Prince of Persia vein, except it is much simpler; this one is a straight platformer with some action. It is well made, I’d call it one of the best games in its subgenre along with Blackthorne (PC/SNES/etc, 1994). I usually don’t like this kind of game but Heart of Darkness is quite fun. It has a classic cartoon style story, you are a boy stuck in a scary land of evil shadows. Wild 9 (PS1), however, had a lot to live up to and didn’t quite manage it. From popular studio Shiny of Earthworm Jim (GEN/etc, 1994) and MDK (PC/PS1, 1997) fame, Wild 9 is a 2.5d sidescrolling platform/action game with a lot of shooting. Coming off of MDK people had very high hopes, but Wild 9 just isn’t on that level, and not only because it is “merely” a sidescroller instead of 3d. The gameplay just isn’t memorable. It is just fine, but not something with an enduring legacy.
I should discuss why Mega Man & Bass isn’t in my top five; I deeply love the 8-bit Mega Man games for NES and GB, after all, and quite like Mega Man X (SNES/PC, 1993/1995). MM&B was the last original-series Mega Man game on TV consoles before the series would be rebooted with NES-style graphics a decade later in Mega Man 9 (WiiWare, etc, 2008). It may be a late SNES game, but clearly Capcom put a lot into this one, with gameplay that is an evolution of that seen in Mega Man 8 (SAT/PS1, 1996). However, despite its high quality, this last SNES Megaman game is a brutally hard game with some serious design issues. I don’t like ranking a game down only because it’s hard, but this game feels unbalanced, not just hard. You can play as Mega Man (Rock) or Bass (Forte), and Mega Man feels very underpowered. This game is so brutally hard as Megaman that I’ve just never been able to force myself to keep going past the first few levels. Bass is better equipped for the stages at hand here, but it’s still overly frustratingly hard even with him. It’s kind of ironic that this was probably thought of as a title for the surely younger audience still on the last-gen SNES, because it’s the hardest Mega Man game of its generation by far! It may be too hard to be fun, but it is a pretty good game despite that.
Of the other Japan-only titles, infamously expensive Super Tempo is a much more approachable game. I get why it wasn’t released here considering its 2d nature and late release, and it’s an average game that is nothing special, but it’s a solidly fun title, much like its 32X predecessor but better. It has very nice sprite art graphics as well that show off the Saturn’s 2d capabilities. The last of the Japan-only games I’m mentioning here is Ruruli ra Rura, which I will cover in the next category down, as it is a Metroidvania.
Iggy’s Reckin Balls for N64 is a somewhat unique 2.5d platformer/racing game hybrid. The game plays like a platformer as you move through a stage, but each level is a loop and your goal is to finish first in the race, as you try to finish before the other competitors. It’s ultimately an average experience but it’s amusing fun, particularly in multiplayer. Returning to the Game Boy, Turok 2 is a decent platform/action game. It has some mission-based parts that are kind of interesting, such as a stealth-style early level, but doesn’t stay as unique after that. Still, of the four Game Boy or GBC Turok games this one is probably my favorite. Rats! is a decent, and challenging, platform game with puzzle elements. It may not look like much visually, but it has a lot of levels and is an above average, fun title as you find your way through each small stage. And last and most certainly least, Men In Black: The Series was absolutely savaged by reviewers for a whole host of reasons, most notably its very poor gameplay.
Also, it doesn’t really count, but Pocket Bomberman would go in the above paragraph as well. The game released in B&W in Japan and Europe in late ’97, and in color worldwide in late ’98. It’s an okay but short and easy platformer, but its original 1997 release date should rule it out; the color version is identical to the original except for the added color. Still, as I have nostalgia for it as Pocket Bomberman was the game I got with my Game Boy Color for Chirstmas in 1998. It was fun for the short time it lasted but it’s average stuff at best. Jump mode, where you play through three stages where you auto-jump all the time, is fun. However, as much as I understand why Hudson was trying to make Bomberman into a single player platformer character, it’s the classic multiplayer Bomberman games that I like the most. Still, Pocket and Hero are at least decent.
Overall, nobody is going to believe this is a ‘best non-Mario 2d platformers ever’ list, but yes, 1998 did have good 2d platformers. Goemon’s Great Adventure particularly is a favorite of mine. It’s my pick for best 2.5d platformer of its era. The top two on this list are ‘best ever non-Mario’ tier games; Wario Land II may be weird but it is a memorable and high-quality kind of weird.
Platformers (Metroidvania) – I included the Metroidvanias of ’98 in the above category, but this eventually became its own subgenre. In 1998 it was an obscure subgenre, however. Ruruli Ra Rura (PC-FX) is really the only Metroidvania platform-action game first released in ’98 that I can think of, and I spent quite a while looking. While decent, the game is very basic looking and simple. A real copy is quite expensive now. Otherwise, the only other thing I can think of released this year was the Japan-only Saturn port of 1997’s defining genre hit, Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (PS1, 1997). This genre took time to reach popularity, and there weren’t many games trying to play like SotN for years. Western games, in particular, largely ignored Metroid and Symphony of the Night’s design influence at this point, which makes sense considering that the Metroid games never were hits and SotN wasn’t given much attention here when it released due to it being a 2d game at a time when console gamers wanted polygons. The modern Metroidvania boom wouldn’t really get going until many years later, following on some Game Boy Advance games from the early 2000s. Meanwhile in Japan there were a couple of titles, but as you can see, very few. 1998’s Saturn version of SotN does add playable Maria, and she has great controls with a triple jump and magic, but the longer load times to get to the map screen make it a worse experience than its PS1 predecessor. Lastly, the aforementioned Montezuma’s Return! (GB, GB/C) has a strong Metroidvania-ish puzzle component as you search each huge level for items and figure out where to use them. The items are not permanent upgrades, though, so I don’t think it counts as one. Still, in terms of game design the GB/C Montezuma game is much more complex and ambitious than its fairly linear 3d PC counterpart.
Overall, here’s my attempt at my personal favorite Platformers of 1998 (Overall) list: Goemon’s Great Adventure, Banjo-Kazooie, Sonic Adventure, Wario Land II, Montezuma’s Return (GB/C). I wish MM&B was on this list but I just can’t. The honorable mentions are: Bomberman Hero, Chameleon Twist 2, Spyro the Dragon, and Heart of Darkness. For 10th it’s close but I’ll give the edge to Jazz Jackrabbit 2 over Starshot.
Action- Music / Rhythm
The Top Titles: Dance Dance Revolution (Arcade), Pop’n Music (Arcade). GameFAQs separates music games into two subgenres, Music or Dancing. The first significant title in that latter subgenre released in ’98. The concept of pushing buttons to music dates back to the ’80s, or further if you consider Simon a music game, but the genre hit its modern form in 1996 with Beatmania and Parappa the Rapper. However, while those games were successful, they were just about pushing regular buttons in time with the music. The genre diversified in 1998. This year, one of the two biggest hits the genre would ever see released. Yes, the first arcade release of DDR happened in Japan in, you guessed it, 1998! While this game is still about pushing buttons in time with music, this time the buttons are on a dance pad you stand on and push with your feet, making for a very different experience from anything before other than perhaps the NES Power Pad, but much more advanced than that. The Western release would not be until ’99, but still, it’s Japan where it was the biggest hit. So yeah, there was a hugely important moment for this genre as well. DDR changed music games more than maybe any other; only Guitar Hero compares. DDR has challenging gameplay and a great dance music soundtrack. As for the other title here, Pop’n Music is less well known, but it is another game from the same studio with similar gameplay, except with a row of buttons instead of a dance pad, so it is more like the aforementioned titles of ’96. The genre’s next step would come in 1999, when the first game with a plastic guitar released, Guitar Freaks (Arcade, 1999). It’s basically Pop’n Music but with a guitar with buttons on it. This game would be the inspiration for Guitar Hero in 2005.
Special Mention – Beatmania (PS1, JP only release) had its first console port of the earlier arcade game happen in ’98. Beatmania mimics a DJ’s setup, you move around a ‘record’ and also have a row of buttons to push as well.

FPSes and 3DOF shooters. Note that Jedi Knight is pictured for the expansion (disc below), not the base game from ’97. As for Turok 2 I decided to show the cart alongside the box to show its black cart color. I apologize for not having more FPSes, I’m just not enough of a genre fan. Note that the Unreal collection is pictured here only for the base game.
Action – First Person Shooter or FPS-hybrid
Top List: Half-Life (PC), Thief: The Dark Project (PC), Star Wars: Jedi Knight – Mysteries of the Sith (PC, expansion pack for 1997’s Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II), Starsiege: Tribes (PC), Unreal (PC/Mac).
Honorable Mentions: Shogo: Mobile Armor Division (PC), Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six (PC ver.; PS1/N64 later).
Top console FPS: Turok 2: Seeds of Evil (N64/PC).
3DOF Greats: Forsaken (PC/PS1), Forsaken 64 (N64). These will be mentioned again in the flight combat genre along with other similar titles.
Also Noteworthy: Delta Force (PC), SiN (PC), Aliens Online (PC), Jurassic Park: Trespasser (PC).
Of Lesser Note: Redneck Rampage Rides Again (PC), Blood 2: The Chosen (PC), South Park (N64/PC).
Worst Game Ever Made Award Top Tier Nominee: Extreme Paintbrawl (PC)
FPS (Tactical)
GameFAQs separates FPSes into two subgenres, Arcade or Tactical. The Arcade category goes back to the early days of the genre, but the Tactical subgenre of realistic modern military shooters came into existence in 1998 with two games, Delta Force and Rainbow Six. The only 3d game before somewhat similar was Seal Team (PC, 1993), but that is a slower paced game with the first person mode as a side option. In comparison, for the first time ever, in ’98 there were two different takes on realistic modern combat in first person. Both are tremendously important for the genre’s development; newer games like ARMA, Sniper Elite, or Tom Clancy’s Rainbow Six Siege would not exist without these. Today the idea of having regular modern human enemies, not aliens, demons, robots, or Nazis, and of having a game be an at least semi-realistic military simulation, seem like a given a lot of the time. Of course you can only take one or two hits before dying, naturally you may be working with a team of AI companions in huge, expansive maps, and more… except, in 1998, those things were all brand new. Delta Force uses NovaLogic’s voxel terrain engine from their flight simulators of years past well to make the environment, and adds scattered polygonal buildings and characters on top of that. The combination is brilliant stuff, and it makes for surely the largest levels in any FPS so far as of ’98. This leads to sniping being very powerful. Rainbow Six has a smaller scale, with small stages focused on managing your team to rescue the hostages in each place without anyone other than the terrorists being killed, but it was similarly hugely influential. The core concept is a lot like another 1998 game, Sierra’s SWAT 2, but that is an overhead strategy game. Making it first person totally changes the experience. I know neither of these made my top five, but they are more important to the genre than anything on it other than Half-Life. In the ’00s, modern military shooters would dominate the genre.
FPS (Arcade)
I mentioned Half-Life, Thief, and Unreal in the first article. This is certainly one of the best first-person game lineups of any year ever. To reprise my thoughts on those three, Thief is the definitive stealth game, the title that pretty much invented serious stealth gaming and still one of the genres’ best. Half-Life took Jedi Knight’s cinematic style and made it more mainstream by making the game a lot more linear and approachable, and was at the time regarded as maybe the greatest PC game ever. Its multiplayer modding scene would create some of the most popular games ever made, as well. Unreal had some of the best graphics of any PC game that year and would turn out to be a very popular and well-designed game, you have heard of the Unreal Engine in part because of this game that was the first to use it.
But to move on to games I haven’t discussed yet, that was only the beginning of how stacked 1998’s FPS lineup is! My number one in this genre is Star Wars: Jedi Knight – Mysteries of the Sith, my favorite FPS campaign ever, if the base Dark Forces II isn’t. I absolutely love the highly complex and confusing and yet linear level designs, there’s nothing else quite like it. The final planet of this game, on a Force-rich planet where you cannot use any guns, is my favorite section of any FPS I have ever played. Moving on, Starsiege: Tribes 1 was an innovative multiplayer team-focused shooter with dozens of players in each game in huge open arenas, zooming around on jetpacks shooting each other with guns such as the iconic Spinfusor. It is a fantastic, high-skill game. And last, Turok 2 was a crazy-huge and ambitious title for the N64, with a huge world and a lot to look for and do. It’s kind of an open world game in a way, and keeps track of every enemy you kill. The framerate on N64 is terrible, but no console FPS of the time aimed as high. Compared to the years’ PC library I don’t think it quite matches up, as its PC version review scores at the time show — at that time PC FPSes were more advanced than console ones — but it still is a very noteworthy release. It is by easily the best console FPSs of the year; number two is probably Forsaken 64 (N64), if you count it in this genre. I put it in vehicular action so look there for that game. If you don’t want to count that, number two has to be Quake 64 (N64), a port of the 1996 PC great.
SiN was somewhat unlucky. While it is a well made sci-fi FPS loved by a small fanbase, it was overshadowed by Half-Life and Unreal, and it didn’t sell all that well. It would get a sequel many years later that was supposed to be the start of an episodic series, but it also failed to sell and the series ended there. Shogo, on the other hand, is a fantastic game, with a Western-made anime giant robot anime theme and great controls, gameplay, and level designs. You play as a guy on foot some of the time, and pilot a giant robot in other sections. Developer Monolith would go on to greater success with 1999’s No One Lives Forever (PC, 1999), but their premiere ’98 FPS is also fantastic. They also had a second FPS that year, Blood 2: The Chosen (PC), but it isn’t as good. Lastly, Redneck Rampage Rides Again is a late Build engine title with a humorous, but somewhat questionable, Southern rednecks theme. While this FPS engine was very successful for a while, particularly thanks to Duke Nukem 3D (PC, 1996), by ’98 it was looking dated due to its DOS-based nature and Doom-like sprites and pseudo-3d design. Yes, a two year old engine was already looking outdated. It was the ’90s. As a result, Rides Again is a perfectly decent game but got a lot less attention than its predecessor had the previous year. It is certainly much better than the other Build engine games of ’98, which include the quite bad Nam (PC) and the infamous Extreme Paintbrawl (PC), a solid pick for worst game ever made.
Starsiege: Tribes particularly shows another path gaming could have taken. Aliens Online looks like a tense, well-made game, it’s a tragedy it doesn’t have a modern fan server, but that kind of slow horror shooter in constrained spaces is a style of game still created. Tribes, however, really isn’t. Tribes and third person shooter Outwars (PC) both are shooters where you have a jetpack that released in ’98, but while both are good Tribes is the better of the two. It is a high skill ceiling game with absurdly massive outdoor levels. It’s fascinating stuff. Tribes is a spinoff from Sierra’s mech, or HERC as they called them, franchise known as EarthSiege or Starsiege. By dropping the mechs for fast little people with jetpacks Sierra was changing with the times, and making something that could not have been done as well earlier on. There would be one last giant robots game from Sierra in ’99, Starsiege, before their mech franchise ended in favor of just Tribes. This is not the last time a mech game would be replaced by an on-foot one set in that universe… Titanfall 1 and 2 (2014 & 2016) to Apex Legends (2019), anyone? People still play Tribes online, which is unsurprising given how unique and challenging it is. Given that level of challenge, though, I understand why the concept never became a mass-market hit.
As for South Park, well, it was the first game using the license from that still-relevant animated comedy series. Unfortunately, the game is a third-rate shooter. It was made by Acclaim using their Turok engine, but clearly the good developers were working on Turok 2, because this one is a very simple and basic game: just follow the path, going from point to point, defeating the hordes of identical enemies along the way. Almost every enemy in the first level, for instance, is a turkey. Or, better yet, skip it and play something better instead.
Before I move on to the next genre… the ‘Well, Its Ideas Mattered A Lot In the Future!’ Award: Jurassic Park: Trespasser (PC). Trespasser is an infamously bad game, but it is also an infamously innovative one. Its physics-based puzzles were something never seen before. Half-Life 2 would build off of ideas Trespasser first got off the ground. The game has large, open levels to explore, and when run on a newer, post-1998 computer that can actually run it well, is something some people find they enjoy a lot more than they were expecting.
As for Extreme Paintbrawl, it really is one of the worst, least finished games ever sold in a box. This game is competition with Big Rigs (PC, 2003) for incompetence and incompletion, though it is less amusing to play than that one; you can’t go infinite speed in reverse, just observe the utterly broken AI in this part of a game the devs had mere weeks to throw together before it was shipped. And if you want to avoid the largely nonexistent AI and play against a human, bad news, the multiplayer was mostly broken as well. The music is a musicians’ demo tape, too. And last, if for some bizarre reason you wish to play it today you will need an old computer or good virtual machine, for the game switches between Windows 9x and DOS between the menus and matches.
Genre Analysis: Compared to other years, 1998’s FPS entries are interesting. It shows the genre in the throes of major change, as the rapid rise of the internet was reshaping computer gaming. In 1998 console gamers who wanted to play multiplayer had to find a friend to play in the same room with them, but computer gamers could play against people across the world. Most FPSes released in ’98 had online play, though how much of a focus it was varies from title to title. Most FPSes of ’98 were primarily focused on a single player campaign, with a limited number of maps available for online play, though some like Half-Life or Jedi Knight were quite popular online regardless. The primary exceptions to that were Starsiege: Tribes and Aliens Online (PC), two games entirely focused on often team-based online multiplayer. The single player in these two was very much an afterthought.
This trend would amp up considerably the next year, as 1999 would be the year of the arena shooter. In ’99, Quake 3 (PC), Unreal Tournament (PC), and Turok Rage Wars (N64) all released, and the first two of those became iconic classics for daring to drop the single player campaign and only have multiplayer-style arena battles with a lot of maps. FPSes with campaigns would make a big return soon, though, as Halo (Xbox/PC, 2001) moved the genre in a more simplified direction and Call of Duty (PC, 2004) took the Half-Life style of roller coaster campaign to new heights, but multiplayer arena games never went away entirely; most notably, the Half-Life mods I mentioned before called Half-Life: Counter-Strike (PC, 1999) and Half-Life: TeamFortress (PC, 1999) are some of the most successful franchises ever, with smallish levels and a much more realistic design. On the other end of the spectrum, Overwatch (PC, 2016) is also a very popular arena shooter.

My flight, car, and tank combat action games from 1998. I should also have Incoming for PC but can’t find the disc. G-Police is the 1998 PC release of a 1997 PS1 game, so it will not be mentioned below, but I put it in the photo.
Action – Flight Combat (Arcadey, Simmish, or 3DOF)
This category here combines together several different genres, in both the Action and Simulation genres, because I think these games should be compared to eachother. Note that realistic flight simulators are not in this category.
Top List: Descent: FreeSpace – The Great War (PC) [Best Space Sim], Star Wars: Rogue Squadron / Rogue Squadron 3D (PC/N64) [best Flight Action], Stellar Assault SS (SAT) (JP Only), Forsaken (PS1/PC) [PC ver. is the best 3DOF] & Forsaken 64 (N64), Buck Bumble (N64).
Honorable Mentions: Incoming (PC worldwide, DC in Japan; the US/EU DC release was in ’99), Colony Wars: Vengeance (PS1)
Some Lesser Titles That Are Worth Mentioning: V2000 (PC/PS1, EU only), Hardwar (PC), Xenocracy (PC/PS1, EU only), Ares Rising (PC), Barrage (PC), Blast Radius (PC/PS1), Fatal Abyss (PC)
Special Mention: Independence War (PC) (EU ’97, US ’98). This is a good space sim, one of the better ones of the late ’90s. It won awards and is easily a top three title for the genre if it counted, but is ultimately really a 1997 game.
Genre Categorization Troubles: I combined all of these different kinds of flight combat games for a reason, categorizing them is hard. Which of these games are more action, and which are more sim? That may sound simple, but it’s not; it’s actually tricky and depends on who you ask. Some games, everyone agrees on — FreeSpace and Independence War are space sims in the Simulation genre, that I am only listing here because they are similar to these games. On the other hand, Forsaken is a 3 Degrees of Freedom (3DOF) game, a title with FPS-style controls except in three dimensions, and thus often is listed with FPSes. The tough part are the games in the middle. For instance, is Incoming a 3DOF-like FPS in the air, or a very light simulation title? It depends who you ask: GameFAQs thinks yes, other places no. If we count it I would put it in second or third, behind PC Forsaken but ahead of Barrage. But if we count Incoming, should other simple flight action games like Top Gun: Hornet’s Nest (PC) or Star Wars: Rogue Squadron (N64/PC) count as Action games? Now that depends on where you look up the answer. There is no agreement on there the line should be. On GameFAQs, 3DOF games or similar, designed for mouse and keyboard, are included among the FPS genre, while other joystick-aimed games usually get listed under Simulation. I know that it is challenging to choose just one genre for these games, Mobygames’ solution of simply allowing multiple genres for a single game is the better answer, because otherwise… well, these are the genres each of these sites give these selected games:
Incoming (PC) – GameFAQs: Action – FPS; Mobygames: Action – Shooter, Simulation; Wikipedia: Shooter, Flight Simulator
Star Wars: Rogue Squadron (N64/PC) – GameFAQs: Simulation – Space – Combat; Wikipedia: Action, Arcade Flight; Mobygames: Action – Shooter
Stellar Assault SS (SAT) – GameFAQs – Simulation – Space – Combat; Wikipedia: Space combat simulation; Mobygames: Action – Shooter, Arcade
They all agree that Barrage and Forsaken are Action – FPS games, though, and that Top Gun: Hornet’s Nest is a flight simulator. These make sense.
I understand why sites can’t agree on other games, though, because games like these have elements of both Action and Simulation, to varying degrees. These “different” genres are closely related. Even a simple flight action game like Descent or Incoming has a more complex control design than a ground-based first person shooter due to having to deal with movement in three dimensions. In order to keep everything together I decided to list all flight combat here. I will mention the more simmish ones again in the Simulation genre, but only in very brief detail.
The Top Games: Anyway, with that over with, I should discuss the actual games. The top two in this genre are pretty important. The first Descent: FreeSpace is a late entry into the space sim genre previously defined by Wing Commander and X-Wing/TIE Fighter. Freespace 2 is perhaps even more iconic than the first one, and is regarded as probably the best space sim that isn’t a Star Wars game, but the first title is also very high quality. It is hard to match up to TIE Fighter, but this game is as close as anything else I’ve played gets. As is also true for games like X-Wing, Freespace is significantly more complex than the other games on this list, but less than the more serious simulators in the Simulation – Flight genre. In the ’90s space sims were a separate genre from flight sims, and I maintain that here. As for Rogue Squadron, it is a fantastic flight action game with some of the best, most fun arcadey flying maybe ever. The game started a four-game series of Star Wars flight action games from Factor 5, and it was a favorite of mine at the time — I got the PC version in 1999 and loved it. All four games are great, this one very much included. Factor 5 were tech wizards and show it off here There is fog fairly close, but otherwise the graphics are outstanding. Factor 5 would get rid of that fog in the followup, Star Wars: Battle for Naboo (N64/PC, 2000). The PC version of Rogue Squadron is better than the N64 one, but for the N64 that version looks and plays fantastically, particularly with the Expansion Pak 4MB RAM expansion that the game helped launch. Rogue Squadon was an acclaimed title which won awards for a reason, it is great. This game is one of the best action flight combat games ever.
As for the other games, Forsaken and Forsaken 64 are pretty good 6DOF (Descent-clone) shooters, like a hybrid between a FPS and a flight action game. Descent got surprisingly few clones, and Forsaken is a pretty good one. I wish it had a map, but it’s otherwise good. Note that the N64 version is different from the PC/PS1 one and has different levels. Stellar Assault SS is definitely better. It’s a real shame it never got a Western release and the Japanese version is highly expensive! The first game, Shadow Squadron (Sega 32X, 1995) is simple but fantastic, and the Saturn sequel is more of the same but better. You again mostly just shoot straight ahead, but do also have a charge shot this time and an energy meter. There are also indoor missions where you fly inside facilities. Buck Bumble (N64), made by Argonaut of Star Fox 1 and 2 (SNES) fame, is good, but not as great as you might expect from its pedigree. The shooting is good, but it has somewhat annoyingly close fog, much closer than the fog in Rogue Squadron. The game plays decently well, but it’s no match for the top games in the genre. Its iconic rap intro might make some people put it higher on the list regardless of its gameplay, though.
The Honorable Mention titles: The first game in this category, Rage Software’s Incoming, was a serious graphical showcase. Of all flight games released in ’98, Incoming has some of the best graphics. It is fun to play, too. However, the gameplay is simple and basic, you just fly around and shoot stuff. The game tries to mix things up with some turret shooting sequences and some light strategy bits, but they aren’t as good as the main game is. Also, the game gets maybe a bit too hard after the first few missions. Still, it’s a fun time. On the other hand, while many people would surely put Colony Wars: Vengeance higher on their list, I never liked that game all that much so I’m putting it low. I just never enjoyed playing either G-Police or Colony Wars much at all. This game is only on the list because other people like it; I do not. It looks nice visually, but all games in the series badly need some kind of lock-on targeting system, they don’t have one and having to point directly at anything in order to hit it even with missiles is NOT how this kind of game should control! If all you have is lasers, as with Shadow Squadron (32X, 1995) that’s another thing, but this game has more weapons than that.
The games in the ‘lesser titles’ category are all ones scoring a 6.something on Mobygames. Of them V2000 is the most interesting looking, it is one part third person hover shooter and one part strategy as you have to try to balance between attack and defending the humans. It is the sequel to an older game called Virus and is by Frontier Developments of Elite fame, though this is not a massive trading sim like that; this is more something which probably should be in the next genre down, with the shooting games there. Ares Rising is a more traditional, albeit lower budget, space combat game. It looks okay. Hardwar and Xenocracy, however, are both one part flight combat and one part simulation. The strategy layer is optional in Xenocracy, however, while the trading sim element is central to Hardwar. It is set in a single city which you fight and trade in. So yes, Hardwar is open world, very rare for 1998! This title is notable for its ambition and some love it. Barrage is another simple but flashy looking flight shooter with mouse and keyboard controls. It’s easy but entertaining. Blast Radius I probably should leave off the list; it is Psygnosis using the Colony Wars engine for a simpler space shooter with minimal story, just fly and shoot. Blah. Lastly, Fatal Abyss is a mediocre flight combat game only really here because of its underwater setting; it is the only underwater shooter this year.
Action – Car/Tank Combat
[Note: GameFAQs puts some of these games in Action and some in Simulation. These all should be in Action other than I’76, which could go in Simulation. ]
Top List: BattleTanx (N64), Vigilante 8 (PS1/N64, later DC), Carmageddon 2: Carpocalypse Now (PC), Interstate ’76: Nitro Pack (PC, expansion pack for Interstate ’76 (PC, 1997)), Rogue Trip: Vacation 2012 (PS1).
Less good: Auto Destruct (PS1), Twisted Metal III (PS1), Crime Killer (PC/PS1).
The Better Games: The more action-focused tank or car action variant of the vehicle sim was a hugely popular genre in the ’90s, and 1998 was no exception. However, while the top four are good games, none of these games are among the best ever in the genre. Vigilante 8, Carmageddon 2, and Battletanx are solid, but all-time bests? Probably not. This list won’t convince many of this being the best year for this genre. Still, these games deserve attention. Interstate ’76 is a great simmish car combat game, if you include it here, but it released in 1997. Its expansion pack from ’98, the Nitro Pack, is good, but scored a bit lower than the base game had. It adds a full new campaign and better 3D card support, though, so it’s a solid expansion. Vigilante 8 has the highest review average of any of these games. It is kind of a Twisted Metal-style arcadey car combat spinoff of Interstate ’76. It’s a fun little game but nothing really special, though driving around blowing people up is entertaining. As with most of these games it is better in multiplayer than single player. I’d probably rather play it than the other console car combat games here, but this has never been a genre that appealed to me all that much. On the other hand BattleTanx has a low review average, but I think it’s pretty good so I’m putting it on top. It’s a decently fun but short single player game with an absurd story and lots of fun tank-blasting action, but the four player multiplayer is particularly fantastic. The N64 version of the sequel, BattleTanx: Global Assault (N64, 2000), is even better.
Carmageddon 2 is really its own thing, entirely different from the other games in this category. I mentioned it earlier in Racing, but the series’ main focus is mostly on the cars bashing into eachother until you are the only survivor while picking up weapons and running over civilians, not on driving through the checkpoints to finish the race. The games are love-or-hate, but I have always enjoyed them. Carmageddon is violent escapist fun, not realistic at all but that’s the point.
The Problem: For many, the biggest problem for the genre this year was that in 1998 Sony and the developer of the first two Twisted Metal games, SingleTrac, separated. This led to the original studio making the knockoff-sounding title Rogue Trip along with several other games such as the very fun third-person jetpack shooter Outwars (PC), while Sony had a new team make a very disappointing third main series entry. The first two Twisted Metal games are much more popular than the later ones, but while neither of these two is a beloved classic, Rogue Trip is a lot better than Twisted Metal III.
The other kind of vehicle combat games are ones designed more for single player, such as Auto Destruct or Crime Killer. These two allow you to drive around in decent-sized levels, doing missions that involve blowing up other cars. Expect mediocrity, unfortunately.

Shmups and shooting action games from ’98. I wish I had more, but shmups are expensive! Several later home ports are used to represent earlier arcade games; see below. Note that Metal Slug Anthology for PS2 is here to represent Metal Slug 2 (NG), Raiden Fighters Aces for X360 for Raiden Fighters Jet (ARC), and Time Crisis II (PS2) to represent its arcade release. Also The House of the Dead (SAT) is the home port of an arcade game from ’97 so it does not qualify for the main list below.
Action – Misc. Arcadey Action (Light Gun Shooter, Rail Shooter, Shoot ’em up (Top-down or Isometric), Run & Gun, and more)
To be clear, when I say shmup (top-down or isometric) here I am not including traditional auto-scrolling shmups. Those are a separate genre, below. This catch-all arcadey shooting action genre includes the less common top-down shooting games, among others, not those. Also, please note that this subgenre does not include free-flight flight action games, it is for more on-rails games. Free flight shooting action games are in the flight combat genre, above — think titles like Barrage, Incoming, or Forsaken. Anyway, I am combining all of these types of shooting games into one category because of how few titles there are in each subgenre, and also because I often combine all of these kinds of games together when sorting games. If you combine these you get a pretty good list that compares reasonably with any other year of games in these subgenres.
Top List: Future Cop: L.A.P.D. (PC/PS1), Metal Slug 2 (ARC/NG), Shock Troopers: 2nd Squad (ARC/NG), The House of the Dead 2 (ARC; DC port ’99), Assault: Retribution (PS1).
Honorable Mentions: Robotron 64 (N64) [enhanced version of the previous year’s Robotron X (PS1, 1997], Centipede (PC/PS1/DC).
Lower Tier: MediEvil (PS1), Apocalypse (PS1), Nitrous Oxide: N2O (PS1), Super B-Daman Battle Phoenix 64 (N64, JP only).
Special Mention: The House of the Dead (SAT; port of the 1997 arcade game)
On Categorization: First, I need to say, putting Future Cop in this category is a bit controversial. Wikipedia lists it as a third person action game, for instance, but on GameFAQs it’s in Simulation. That categorization also makes some sense, but I put it here because of its overhead perspective and focus on action. This is a much more complex game than anything else in this section, though. I could go either way on this one, but I should mention it here because elements of these genres are present.
About The Games: Either way on where it should be listed, Future Cop LAPD is a fantastically fun sci-fi action-shooting game. It is third person, but while behind the mech, your view is zoomed out so much that it plays more like an overhead game than a behind-the-character one, hence its inclusion in this genre. The game is great fun. The missions are brutally hard and very long, so beating it will be quite hard, but it’s worth at least attempting. The multiplayer is also amazing, with strategy/action hybrid design that is unlike anything seen before. The multiplayer mode is a noteworthy predecessor to games like DOTA (which started as a Warcraft III mod in 2003) or Tower Defense games.
As for the other games, Metal Slug 2 is great. However, while the series in general is probably run & gun’s best ever, MS2 is not the best Metal Slug game. The game aimed high, and added great new features like the two playable female characters to the series, but it has constant slowdown that really holds it back. Of the Neo-Geo Metal Slug games, the next two, X and 3, are definitely better than 3. Still, even an average Metal Slug game is still better than almost any other shooter, and Fio and Eri date to ’98, which is great.
The House of the Dead 2 is the light-gun shooter of the year, by far. It’s a top tier classic that may be more remembered for its Dreamcast port the next year, but the arcade game is the same cheesy fun as on DC. The voice acting is comically bad, it’s awesome stuff. The gameplay is quite good for its genre as well. Assault: Retribution is one of the better 3d overhead-ish run & gun action games of its generation. It isn’t incredible but it is good, which is more than you can say for most games of its type then; most were quite mediocre, such as the two PS1 Contra games. Compared to games like those, Assault: Retribution is quite surprisingly well made. Shock Troopers: 2nd Squad is a pretty good overhead run & gun topdown shooter. This genre was mostly dead by this point because of the rise of 3d, and this is one of the last 2d ones. It’s got 3d-rendered graphics, which aren’t everyones’ favorite, but still it is a great fun Neo-Geo blastfest. It’s quite good. Robotron 64, meanwhile, is basically an enhanced version of the previous year’s Robotron X for PS1, but while that game was a somewhat unplayable disaster, this one is pretty good. The key difference is the camera, which now is zoomed out so you can actually see the whole stage and what is going on. This change makes the game dramatically more fun. If you play this game play this version.
Other Titles of Note: The games outside of the top group are interesting enough that some people will enjoy them regardless. These include Apocalypse (PS1) and Centipede (PC/PS1/later DC), as well as Nitrous Oxide: N2O (PS1), a second rate Tempest 2000 knockoff of sorts, except as a rail shooter. I’ve never liked N2O, it feels slow and just never gets exciting, but it is average anyway and has flashy visual effects. Centipede is alright, though. I got it for PC back when it released and enjoyed it. It’s flawed but fun, if you don’t quit in frustration because it can get hard. It has a mostly overhead camera and you shoot through many segmented areas, defeating the centipedes and other foes in each one before you can progress. A jump button adds some decent platforming bits, which is nice. Apocalypse is another 3d run & gun-ish shooting game, like Assault: Retribution but not quite as good despite having Bruce Campbell’s name and voice. It’s a fine game though, and is simple blasting fun.
MediEvil is a weird one. It got solid reviews, and indeed has one of the highest review averages of any game in this category. However, I can’t make any sense of this; I have always hated this game, ever since I first played it in the late ’90s. I think both games are awful F-tier games and do not understand their low B review averages. Either way, the game is an overhead-view hack and slash action game with some platformer elements. You may not have a shot but spend a lot of time dodging enemy fire. Super B-Daman Battle Phoenix, however, is not good. This light gun style shooter doesn’t use a gun since there isn’t one for the Nintendo 64, so you just use a controller to move the cursor around in a handful of very simple target shooting minigames. Multiplayer is the main draw here, but with barely any content and quite basic gameplay there is no reason to play this one ever.
Action- Shoot em Up (Shmup)
Shmups are automatically-scrolling shooters where you control something you move around the screen, shooting enemies and avoiding their shots. They primarily come in two variants, horizontally scrolling or vertically scrolling. Other kinds of arcadey shooting games go in the genre above and not this one, though I will mention a few overhead shooting games as well.
Top List: Armed Police Batrider (ARC; JP only), Radiant Silvergun (SAT; JP only), Blazing Star (NG/ARC), ESP RA.DE (ARC; JP only), R-Type Delta (PS1; JP ’98, US/EU ’99), Gunbird 2 (ARC; DC ’99). Honorable Mention: Touhou 4: Lotus Land Story (PC98; JP only).
Also Noteworthy: Touhou 5: Mystic Square (PC98; JP only), Star Soldier: Vanishing Earth (N64/ARC), Dangun Feveron/Fever SOS (Arcade), Guardian Force (Arcade/Saturn; JP only), Raiden Fighters Jet (Arcade), RayCrisis: Series Termination (ARC; PS1 ’99).
Disappointing: Asteroids (PC/PS1; also GBC and N64 in 1999).
Special Mentions: Gradius IV (ARC) – It’s kind of a 1998 game and kind of a 1999 game — see below. This is one of my favorite shmups of ’98 if we count it. Also, Einhander (PS1) released in Japan in ’97, but the US in ’98. Square’s shmup was actually quite good and one of the most popular of its day and still holds up well, but it was originally a 1997 release. G-Darius (PS1) similarly is a 1998 home port of a 1997 arcade release.
Looking at the primary subgenres, this is what you get:
– Horizontal – Blazing Star, R-Type Delta, Gradius IV*, G-Darius* (& Einhander)
– Vertical – Armed Police Batrider, Radiant Silvergun, ESP RA.DE, Touhou 4 and 5, Gunbird 2, Star Soldier: Vanishing Earth, Dangun Feveron, Guardian Force, Raiden Fighters Jet, RayCrisis
–Top-Down – I put these in the above genre. Shock Troopers: 2nd Squad, Centipede (1998), and Robotron 64 would go here.
These are all-time great lineups in either the Vertical or Horizontal subgenres for sure, but not so much for top-down, though they’re decent.
Anyway, all of those top six or seven games are no-doubt classics. The top three or four stand against anything else in the genre in popularity and importance. RS I mentioned in the first article. It is one of the most popular shmups ever. Blazing Star is my pick for best Neo-Geo shmup, edging out Viewpoint. Batrider is probably the best shmup that only genre fans have heard of; this Raizing classic dominated first place on the shmups.system11.org forum’s best games ever lists for many years. That says a lot, and that is why I put it in first on this list. Beyond that, number four title Esprade is one of Cave’s most popular games. It shows up on most Cave fan’s top fives, and is an important title because it was their first with flying people as the characters, something they would do a lot of subsequently. I’ve never cared much for Cave games beyond Dodonpachi myself, so my personal 1998 shmups list would not have Esprade on it, but it’s here for Cave’s many fans.
The Touhou series is one of the most famous bullet-hell shmup franchises. It’s either that or Cave’s Dodonpachi games, for sure. The two that released in ’98 are for the PC-98, while a lot of people start with the Win9x games from 2002, but still, these are Touhou games with all of the graphics, beautiful bullet patterns, and gameplay styles of the newer games in the franchise. It’s impressive how fast, smooth, and bullet-filled the screen gets on these games designed for older computers. These are bullet-hell games, no compromises. I picked 4 for the upper tier in part because its stage 3 theme, Bad Apple, is quite famous. You almost certainly have heard at least some of its many remixes.
1998’s Gradius and R-Type games are a bit more iffy, though. That is, both games are well made, but they are very similar to the earlier titles in their franchises, and those early titles are the iconic ones. It’s amazing that 1998 got both R-Type AND Gradius games, but did it get the best ever R-Type and Gradius games? Probably not. I’d say those two games really reveal this as a 1998 list and not an all-time one. R-Type Delta is a good game, though. Sure, it has iffy PS1 polygon graphics that do not look the best, but it is R-Type all the way, with slow-paced but very challenging gameplay. It has interesting stages to experience, if you can get through them. This was the final R-Type game of the original series; the next title, R-Type Final (PS2), changes things somewhat.
Gradius IV, similarly, is basically a classic Gradius game, but with polygon models. As an arcade game it looks better than console-only R-Type Delta, and it’s pretty good, but it is a very safe game dedicated to being a lot like the original Gradius, but in 2.5d with polygons now. Also, Gradius IV has an asterisk because the full release didn’t come until early 1999. Looking online you will see it sometimes listed as a ’98 release and sometimes February ’99, but this is apparently because it was shown in pretty much finished form at an arcade show in November ’98, and has a 1998 copyright date on its title screen, but it seems that it was not sold to arcades until the next February. Is that a 1998 game? Well, kind of not, but either way, I don’t think that many people would pick Gradius IV over the original game or Gradius III. It’s a fine enough game but doesn’t match up to its predecessors. Still, it’s a good Gradius title and mostly is just ‘more of the same but 2.5d now’ and how is that bad? It’s not! Gradius is my favorite shmup series and Gradius IV was Konami’s last Gradius game made internally by Konami, so it is pretty significant. Konami would make some Otomedius shmups in the ’00s but those are a different, and much lesser, thing than Gradius.
Regardless of which years you put them in, these games mark the end of an era for both franchises. Both games ended their series. Gradius IV as I said was the last of Konami’s Gradius games they made themselves. Gradius V is an exceptionally great game, but it was developed by Treasure, of Radiant Silvergun fame. It is noticeably different. Similarly, R-Type Delta ended the original R-Type series. Irem would go back to the franchise on PS2 and PS4/X1 with the R-Type Final games, but long time gaps separate each of those games and they have some significant differences from the original series. Final takes inspiration from classic R-Type but is distinct from it.
Gunbird 2 is then-popular shmup developer Psikyo’s lone entry in the genre this year. Best known for their Strikers 1945 series, the two Gunbird games have a lighter and more comedic tone with amusing anime characters to play as and a silly story, though the gameplay is serious and involves screens full of bullets, like usual. Psikyo games aren’t full-on bullet hell, but are very close. The screen is often full of enemy fire for you to try to avoid. I like all of Psikyo’s shmups, they are good to great for sure. Their style works very well for me, with nice 2d sprite art and challenging but not impossible stages to fight through. It’s a shame that Psikyo got closed down in about 2003.
As for the second tier noteworthy titles, of those, Star Soldier: Vanishing Earth was the last full single player game in that classic series. It is a good, fun game but is kind of easy. Raiden Fighters Jet is a good game in a well thought of Raiden sub-series. It would not get a home release until the Xbox 360, but when it did it got a lot of attention. RayCrisis is an average game, but it is notable for being the final game of a trilogy that began with popular title RayForce, aka Layer Section or Galactic Attack (ARC 1994, PS1/SAT 1995). The first game is a beautiful 2d title, but unfortunately its two 2.5d sequels are not on its level.
My shmups of ’98 top 5 list, ranked: Blazing Star, (Gradius IV), Armed Police Batrider, Radiant Silvergun, Gunbird 2, Star Soldier: Vanishing Earth.
[Insert photo of Heretic II, Outwars, Space Bunnies Must Die, Beast Wars: Transformers, and Dark Vengeance here]
Action – Third-Person Action or Third-Person Shooter (behind the character)
Note: the number in parenthesis is the critical review average of that game on Mobygames.
Top List: Heretic II (PC) [84%], Outwars (PC) [74%], Die by the Sword (PC) [79%], Tomb Raider III (PS1/PC) [79%] [note I also mentioned this one in Platformer (3D); I know the internet calls this series Action-Adventure games but I’m sorry, they aren’t.], Nanosaur (Mac; PC 2002)
Also maybe worth mentioning, tank-controls titles of mixed quality: Dark Vengeance (PC/Mac) [64%], Space Bunnies Must Die! (PC) [55%], Ian Livingstone’s Deathtrap Dungeon (PC/PS1) [69%], MediEvil (PS1) [80%], Asghan: The Dragon Slayer (PC; EU only) [60%]
Mentioned for its box and theme, not its quality: H.E.D.Z.: Head Extreme Destruction Zone (PC) [62%] [you could put Space Bunnies Must Die! in this category as well.]
Worst of the Year Contenders: The Fifth Element (PS1) [60%], C: The Contra Adventure (PS1) [39%]. Special Mention: Beast Wars: Transformers (PC port of the 1997 PS1 game) [45%].
While third-person beat ’em up or weapon-based action, action-adventure, or action-RPG games were well represented in ’98 with games such as Zelda – Ocarina of Time, TES Adventures: Redguard, Tenchu: Stealth Assassins, or plenty more games of lesser note, the third-person, behind the character shooting-focused game was still a very new thing. Having to draw your character on screen adds to the polygon count requirements and shooters need smooth gameplay and a good framerate, so games with a lot of shooting naturally moved to first-person perspectives in the ’90s. Third person shooting action games often went for more pulled-back cameras as you see above in Future Cop LAPD or Metal Gear Solid. Others went for a slower pace instead of fast action. Only a few games tried to have the speed and action of a FPS but in third person.
Regardless, third person action games of either the shooter or hack and slash action varieties were in a very different place in 1998 from where they are now. Some genres are more similar then and now, while others are more different, and this is one of the ones that changed significantly some years later. Between the rise of open worlds and deliberate Soulslike combat for third person action games and cover-based shooting for third-person shooters, these genres looked somewhat unrecognizably different in the ’90s, a time before Demon’s Souls or cover-based shooters. And that is why I am merging these two somewhat different genres into one — or three genres, if you consider that some of these are often called Action-Adventure games instead of just Action or Shooter titles — for the kinds of games being made in 1998, I think it makes a lot more sense to merge these genres than it would to separate them. Regardless, at the time, the dominant force in third person behind the character action games was Tomb Raider. For any who forget, Tomb Raider has tank-style controls, where you move forwards with up and rotate your character with left and right. I think those controls can work fine, but this control scheme is deeply unpopular in recent years, so this is something many people will dislike about many of these games. Even some 3d platformers used tank controls, such as Croc: Legend of the Gobbos (PC/PS1/SAT, 1997).
There was one alternative control scheme: first-person shooter style controls. The idea of a third person shooter with FPS-style controls was actually quite new in 1998. The standout title was Heretic II (PC), from Raven Software. This game is the final game in the Heretic / Hexen series of previously first person fantasy shooters. Heretic II is basically a FPS with the camera pulled back outside of the character, but the change is relevant to the gameplay. I have always thought that Heretic II wasn’t as interesting a game as its predecessors Hexen and Hexen II, but it did get good reviews and was, again, one of the first fast-paced, smooth-playing third person shooters. It also showed the new, more linear style of first or third person shooter level design. Where many of the other games in this category have massive, complex levels to explore, Heretic II, like Half-Life, is a much more focused game with a straightforward path through each stage. This game is where Raven changed from puzzles and mazes in their shooters to linearity and simplicity. As such, it shows the new direction that these genres would take in the next decade: being exciting linear roller coaster thrillrides, not maze games with monster closets. Doom was out, Half-Life in. Heretic II doesn’t have the environmental events of Half-Life happening all the time, but even so the design philosophy change from the Hexen games is dramatic. Clearly Raven recognized the changes that were coming to the industry, of PC and arcade developers going console and simplifying their games as a result, before they really happened, and you see that with Heretic II.
As I said, this was a major change from the past. Raven’s first game, Heretic, is basically fantasy Doom, with Doom-style mazelike levels to explore. 1995’s Hexen was a massive and complex first person adventure set in a single huge connected world, where you wandered around fighting numerous powerful enemies and looking for switches and the path forward, or the path to a switch that opened some door somewhere else, if you can ever figure out which one and where that place is. It is a challenging game that takes serious commitment to beat, and while I did have the game in the ’90s — it was the first FPS I owned — like most people I eventually gave up on it. Hexen 2, from 1997, has more streamlined level layouts than the first one, but still is a complex puzzle game with large-ish levels and tricky, confusing puzzles.
So, at the time, seeing Raven abandon that for a much more linear game focused on action was somewhat shocking, and disappointing. It is a bit short as well, perhaps it was rushed. Either way, Raven’s choice to change their design style to make their games a lot simpler and more approachable in the future may have sacrificed complexity but it surely greatly increased the percentage of players who finished their games. Raven stuck with this simplified, linear action game style going forward. Their next game was Star Trek Voyager: Elite Force, a very linear and simple FPS. I got it at the time, had fun, and finished it. It’s a fun thrillride that you’ll blast through. The old Hexen Raven was gone by this point. After that Elite Force 2 was more of the same, and then their two Star Wars games, Jedi Knight II and Jedi Academy, are similarly simplified, linear games, without any of the scale and complexity of games like Hexen or Jedi Knight 1. I have always found JKII very deeply disappointing because of this, it’s high on my list of most disappointing games ever. Still, simple can be fun; I like Elite Force 1 almost as much as Hexen. Both styles can be good. But when something already is one thing, I’d rather see it stay that way than simplify games to reach a wider audience, as you see going from JK1 to JK2, or, for another developers’ example, ActiVision going from Interstate ’76 (1997) to Vigilante 8 (1998).
Anyway, with that aside of sorts done, what about the other games in this category? There are a fair number, in two major groupings. The other major third person shooter style game is Outwars (PC). I have always had a serious soft spot for Outwars, ever since I played the demo of it quite a bit online back in the late ’90s on Microsoft’s Internet Gaming Zone. The Outwars demo was a pretty popular multiplayer game, but I don’t think most people actually bought the full game. This jetpack-based sci-fi shooter was made by SingleTrac, of Warhawk, Twisted Metal, and Jet Moto fame, but is much more obscure than any of them, despite being published by Microsoft. I’m not sure how that happened, but it is too bad that the game didn’t catch on, because SingleTrac brok up and went out of business in 2000 and its successor companies focused entirely on console games like Warhawk and Twisted Metal, and not this more ambitious title. Outwars has its flaws, including average graphics and frustrating fall damage, but it also has large levels and a great feeling of movement as you zip around on your jetpack. It may not match Tribes, but still it’s a lot of fun.
Another third-person shooter is H.E.D.Z.. While the game itself is by all accounts average, the box is ridiculous, just go look it up! I badly want a copy of this box. It’s basically an arena shooting-focused game with a huge number of cartoony heads you can swap between on your character.
As for Nanosaur, anyone who remembers Mac games of the ’90s surely remembers this game. Nanosaur is a third person shooter/platform game where you wander around sizable levels as a dinosaur with a jetpack — yes, that is yet another jetpack third person game in 1998, it is clearly something of a trend — shooting other dinosaurs and taking eggs. It was a digital-only shareware game with one large area to explore and a 20 minute timer and it looks every bit the sharware game that it was, but it’s an amusing little game worth a play. It was rare that the Mac had an exclusive game but this one was for a few years and it’s a fun time.
Next are a bunch of third person action games with Tomb Raider inspiration. First is an actual Tomb Raider game, Tomb Raider III: Adventures of Lara Croft. Though platforming and looking for switches are the main gameplay elements, the games have enough shooting that I think it’s reasonable to think of them as a third person shoopter, so it deserves mention here. These games are probably closer to being third person shooters than anything else. However, this third game is when people turned on the series; the first two were massive hits, but the third was seen as more of the same, except harder now. The series survives to this day, but the third through fifth games didn’t capture the magic of the first two.
Space Bunnies Must Die! (PC) is an average game that isn’t especially notable for its gameplay, but I have to mention. It’s a Tomb Raider-styled third person shooter action game with an attractive female lead, except expect to do more shooting than Tomb Raider and less platforming. It’s alright. There are better third person shooting games from ’98, but I had to mention this one particularly because I absolutely love the boxart. Shiny silver boxes are the best! The games’ boxart is right up there with Oni and Micro Machines 2 on my list of favorite boxes.
Dark Vengeance (PC), Die by the Sword (PC), Asghan: The Demon Slayer, and Deathtrap Dungeon (PC/PS1) are all fantasy hack and slash focused action games with some exploration and puzzle elements and Tomb Raider-inspired tank controls for your character. Beyond that each is quite different, though. Dark Vengeance has the largest, most almost Metroidvania-ish levels. You will backtrack, a lot, as you look for switches and keys while fighting foes with somewhat deliberate combat. It also has three playable characters that each play differently. It is flawed but ambitious — you have directional attacks, not just a slash button. Deathtrap Dungeon is simpler, with basic combat. It is inordinately difficult however, and is probably the weakest of these three games. Die by the Sword is a unique but very janky game; it is very love-or-hate. You play on the keyboard, moving with one hand and attacking with the numeric keypad with your other hand. Each key on the numeric keypad controls your attacks and hand motion precisely. If that sounds odd it is, but it’s worth experiencing at least once. Of the games in this grouping Die by the Sword got the most praise from reviewers, and considering its uniqueness that makes sense. Despite being hated by some it did win a few awards. Lastly, Asghan: The Demon Slayer is a French PC game. I haven’t played it but from its poor reviews I think you can expect mediocrity and jank. Still, there were not all that many games like this in ’98 so it is notable regardless.
Lastly, the three ‘worst of the year’ contenders are all quite bad. The Fifth Element was EGM’s pick as one of the worst games of the year, and others agreed. C: The Contra Adventure is the second of two 3d action Contra games that gen. Quite the opposite of the series’ beloved earlier titles, it’s regarded as one of the low points in the series and worse than the first 3d one, Legacy of War (PS1/SAT, 1996). But myself, the PC release of 1997 PS1 game Beast Wars: Transformers is the one I dislike the most. Perhaps it shouldn’t count because of its console release the previous year, but it’s the only one of these three I played at the time and I thought it was one of the worst games I had ever played.
Third Person Shooter (Cover-Based)
And here we have another popular subgenre that isn’t usually listed as its own category on sites like Mobygames or GameFAQs, but has its own unique identity so I should mention it… except that it didn’t exist yet in 1998. Yes, as I said in the first article and again above, cover-based third person shooters were created the next year, in WinBack (N64, 1999). Before that, there were many strategy games with cover systems, stealth games where you sneak around and kill people from the shadows, and first or third person shooters where you could hide behind walls or such in order to avoid enemy fire. However, the cover-based shooter as we know it, with waist-high walls that you automatically hide behind, did not yet exist, so obviously the selection here is pretty bad from a cover-based shooting standpoint. Uh, Half-Life and Heretic II are totally cover shooters, yeah… not really. The tactical first person shooters Rainbow Six and Delta Force are closer, though still not quite the same thing with their slower pace and more strategic focus. Whether this absence is a negative or not for 1998’s game library depends on your opinion on this genre, surely. I’ve never been much of a fan myself, I hate Gears of War (Xbox 360, 2006) and its sequels.
Action- Third Person (Tactical)
The other subgenre of third person action games on GameFAQs is Tactical third person action games. These games aren’t close in third person titles, but instead have pulled-back cameras, like the ‘other shooting games’ genre above except slower paced… but not quite slow enough to go into the Strategy genre. I get why this is its own subgenre, but you could get rid of it and put both of these into other genres. This is a somewhat uncommon subgenre, though there are actually two games released in ’98 GameFAQs lists in this genre: Ubik (PC; PS1 ver. released in 2000 in EU only) and Spec Ops: Rangers Lead the Way (PC; a PS1 ver. was cancelled). Ubik is an interesting but very flawed game from Cryo, a French developer known for flawed adventure games. This one is an overhead-style shooter inspired by Syndicate (many platforms, early ’90s). It got mediocre reviews but was ambitious, so some may find it interesting. Just stick to the PC version though, the PS1 port sounds very broken. You could put this in the Strategy (Tactical) genre like Syndicate. Spec Ops wasn’t ambitious, but it was another one of that new trend of modern military shooters. The actual gameplay is, by reviews, below average standard-FPS-but-third-person stuff, though, without the realism of Delta Force or Rainbow Six. The actual gameplay here sounds just as arcadey as the titles in the above subgenre, it could go there. Still, because of its theme it is considered a different subgenre.
A multiplayer-focused take on this subgenre would get much more popular in following years than it was in 1998, as GameFAQs considers the Battle Royale genre to be a part of this category. Thinking about it, that makes sense to me. In these games you only have one life per game and there are a lot of players in the match, all fighting to be the one and only survivor or team, while looking for items scattered around the world. Battle Royale games reached massive popularity in the later 2010s, first popularized by PlayerUnknown’s Battlegrounds (PC, 2017), and remain very popular thanks to megahit title Fortnite (many platforms, 2018) among others. This is another type of game that did not exist yet in 1998; though large team multiplayer shooters such as Delta Force or Starsiege: Tribes did release, they did not have any modes with item drops and a fight to a single survivor.
Action-Adventure
This genre has elements of both action and adventure games, but without the significant RPG elements of an Action-RPG. The protypical example of this genre is Zelda. There is significant overlap between this category and third-person action games, to the point where many titles can go in either category. Depending on where you look online, Action-Adventure may or may not exist as a separate genre. MobyGames, for example, does not have this genre. Instead everything it it is included in the Action genre, with descriptors added to tell you that this action game has puzzle elements [and thus is something other sites would call an action-adventure game]. GameFAQs or Wikipedia, though, do separate Action-Adventure games into their own genre. As the name suggests, these games generally mix together action games and adventure games in some way. There really doesn’t seem to be much agreement on what exactly counts as an action-adventure game and what doesn’t though. For example, while working on this article, I was surprised to find that all Tomb Raider games are considered Action-Adventure games on both Wikipedia and GameFAQs. I know I haven’t played most of the games, and perhaps this is reasonable for the newer ones, but the originals? Sure, Tomb Raiders 2 and beyond have large levels and plenty of exploration, but I don’t think there are any real adventure game elements present; lots of platformers have exploration, that doesn’t make Mario 64 an action-adventure game for example!
The worst of this is GameFAQ’s “Action Adventure – Linear” subgenre, which makes no sense to me. I don’t think almost anything in that subgenre is an action-adventure game, and the few that are should just go in Action Adventure – General. Hack and slash third person action beat ’em ups, platformers, general action adventure games, it is a mix of all of those things. God of War (the original) doesn’t have adventure game components, don’t be ridiculous! Games like those will not be in this genre here. I wasn’t sure what to do with this subgenre. Which games should be in this subgenre, which in Action, and which in Adventure? Where should Survival Horror games go? I’m unsure but went with this, which includes Survival Horror games here in Action-Adventure.
Top List: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (N64), The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening DX (GBC) (colorized remake of a 1993 game with a bit of new content), Metal Gear Solid (PS1), Resident Evil 2 (PS1 ver.; others later), Tenchu: Stealth Assassins (PS1).
Interesting but Flawed Tier: The Elder Scrolls Adventures: Redguard (PC), King’s Quest: Mask of Eternity (PC), Bomberman Quest (GB/C; JP ’98, US/EU ’99), Deep Fear (Saturn). These games all have Mobygames critical averages of 76% to 79%.
Lesser Titles: James Bond 007 (GB), Mission: Impossible (N64; PS1 ’99), T.R.A.G. [aka Hard Edge] (PS1; JP ’98, US/EU ’99), Dolphin’s Dream (JP ’98, EU ’99 as Diver’s Dream, no US release), Quest for Camelot (GB/C), Resident Evil 2 (Game.com)
Infamously Terrible: OverBlood 2 (PS1, JP release; US 2001)
Additionally: I put these games in Beat ‘Em Up, Platformer, or Third-Person Action, but these games have some Action-Adventure elements so some would consider them to be in this genre though I don’t: Body Harvest (N64), Tomb Raider III: The Adventures of Lara Croft (PC/PS1), Dark Vengeance (PC), Deathtrap Dungeon (PC/PS1), MediEvil (PS1), and more.
Special Note: Two quite noteworthy games which released in Japan in ’97 and then the West in ’98 are Alundra (PS1) and The Granstream Saga (PS1). That is why they are not mentioned below despite both being pretty good.
Ocarina of Time was in the first article in greater detail. Console gamings’ most beloved title ever, OoT is an epic adventure with spectacularly great and innovative gameplay, good visuals for the time, great puzzles and dungeons, very fun combat with the best lock-on system ever in a game up to that point, and so much more. It is a must-play for all. Link’s Awakening DX is only barely less amazing; LA, in its various forms, is my favorite 2d Zelda game. This classic 2d overhead Zelda game is a moving title with fun combat, brilliant dungeons, and an island mystery to solve. My favorite version is the original B&W release, not this color version, though, as I’ve always found its color choices garish. They do not look the way my mind imagined the game looking when I played the original version. Also the new color dungeon is neat, but its reward significantly overpowers you, if you use it the game becomes easy. If you finish the color dungeon you cannot refuse to be powered up, either, which is lame. And lastly, they added more hints in the dungeons. That’s okay but I probably liked it better before, with just enough hints to keep you on track without spoiling the puzzles. Still, LA DX is fantastic. At least one of the three versions of Link’s Awakening is a must-play, and DX might be the best option for ones’ first playthrough of the game — it plays amazingly and is more of the authentic experience than the Switch remake.
Resident Evil 2 is a very different kind of thing from Zelda; it is a survival horror game, of the graphic adventure / action game hybrid. It is both adventure and action, though, so here it is. The game was a massive hit and is by far the most popular of the adventure game-style Resident Evil games, before Resident Evil 4 moved the series in a more third person shooter direction. This is the best classic RE game. I am not a RE fan, but this one has always been my favorite game in the series.
Next, after putting Survival Horror into this genre, I also decided to put Stealth (Action) games here as well. I chose to not make Stealth a separate genre, as it can be too many different kinds of games and is more a descriptor than its own genre (sorry Wikipedia…), so Metal Gear Solid and Tenchu are here. However, I’m not sure if Tenchu should be, because it is an entirely linear, level-based game, in a category where all other titles mentioned have some kind of open world connecting the games’ areas. Perhaps it should go in third-person action. For now it is here, though. Either way on that, 1998 was among other things the year of the stealth game, and along with Thief: The Dark Project, which I put in the FPS category where it was placed at the time, this was the year that modern stealth games first released. I listed those two here because GameFAQs puts them in the Action-Adventure genre, which does make sense. Those three games formed the core of a new genre, the stealth genre, which first existed on its own in 1998. Thief pioneered stealth gameplay as a serious endeavor, with light levels, sound, and more mattering significantly as you tried to break in to places, memorize guard patrol routes, and steal what you were there to take. It’s an outstanding game. Tenchu took a much more action game approach, but also advanced the stealth genre with its sneaky stealth assassin slash third person action gameplay. It’s a lot of fun. As for Metal Gear Solid, I covered it in part one. It is a highly influential cinematic action-stealth game still beloved by many. I am not one of them at all, but do not deny its importance.
The next tier are games with very similar review averages for very different reasons; as I said earlier they all score between 76% and 79%, but some are because of lots of jank while others because of being fairly average. The two American games finish here because of being interesting but very janky games that can be frustrating to play. Despite that both are important and are good games if you get used to them. King’s Quest: Mask of Eternity has a sad story behind it. It was an ambitious, interesting, and flawed game which got some critical acclaim but didn’t sell amazingly. Mask of Eternity was Sierra’s last King’s Quest game and legendary designer Roberta Williams’ last game for decades. It sold okay but not as well as hoped, and she was sidelined at times during development as the team put more action and combat and an RPG-style experience points and level system into the game, following trends. The results were mixed, and also make this a somewhat hard to quantify title — is it an action-adventure, or an action-RPG? I put it here because of the still-significant adventure game elements, but perhaps it should be removed and put in the RPG genre. Lastly, Redguard is an adventure / action hybrid, a bit like Mask of Eternity but buggier and with a large space to explore, as you would expect from Bethesda. Unlike regular Elder Scrolls games, this one has one set character you play as, a smaller, focused map, and many more adventure game elements and many fewer RPG elements than regular Elder Scrolls games have. Redguard got decently good reviews, but did not sell well at all, putting its publisher Bethesda in financial trouble. The “Elder Scrolls Adventures” line was abandoned after this title. Creator Todd Howard has said that it would probably have sold better on consoles than it did on PC, which is likely true, its concept is more like a console game. It’s too bad there wasn’t a later console release.
The two Japanese games in this tier are more here because of being decent but unspectacular. Deep Fear is a survival horror game which didn’t release in the US because of the Saturns’ collapse. It is solid for the genre, not something as great as RE2 but fine. Next, Bomberman Quest scores the same as Deep Fear. It is a Zelda: Link’s Awakening style action-adventure game for the GB and GBC, except with Bomberman. So, there is a world map and you talk to people and such, except most of the powerups you get are bomb upgrades and the like, and some enemies require specific upgrades to defeat. I think it’s a good game. It’s no Zelda-tier great, of course, but nothing in the genre not by Nintendo is. This is a largely overlooked title that’s actually worth a look.
Less interesting is another Game Boy/GB Color game from late ’98, Quest for Camelot. Based on the movie of the same name that also released in ’98, this title from Titus lives down to the companys’ poor reputation and is a bland affair most reviewers called boring. I thought about buying it later on in the GBC’s life because I wanted a Zelda-ish game for GBC and couldn’t find Bomberman Quest, but made a good decision and got the amazing platform-action game Bionic Commando: Elite Forces (2000) instead.
Action-Adventure – General
I would assume that ‘general’ means ‘average for the genre’. That is to say, as with many Action-Adventure games, a game that has both linear and open-world elements. To reprise my thoughts on open world games, what exactly an open world game is depends on who you ask and what their definition is. How open must a game be to be open-world? Most open-world games do gate progress, locking some areas behind progress in a main story. The world usually isn’t totally open from the start, and even when it is, some areas are locked behind the story in almost all cases. Open-world can mean ‘a mostly or entirely linear game with large open levels’ or ‘a very nonlinear game which allows you to go to many areas in any order’. The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time, ’98’s premiere game, is, I would say, the former more linear style, as most all Zelda games from between A Link to the Past and Skyward Sword are; though it allows enough freedom to somewhat feel like the latter type at times there is a linear quest, and most dungeons must be played in order. The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening DX is just as linear-ish, while also open. Survival (Horror) games have their own subgenre, but if they didn’t games like Resident Evil 2 and Deep Fear would surely go here as well; they are not true open worlds, but certainly are not entirely linear either.
Action-Adventure – Linear
I said above that I don’t like this genre; I’m sorry but no Tomb Raider isn’t an adventure game. With that said though, if you don’t call stealth action its own genre, it would make sense to put Tenchu: Stealth Assassins in this genre — it is an entirely linear game, after all, unlike your average semi-open but semi-linear action-adventure or survival horror game. Metal Gear Solid is also quite linear, but not as much as Tenchu as the game takes place in one setting instead of a series of discrete levels that you never return to. Tenchu is theo nly game I’ve mentioned in this category which definitely belongs in this category, but if you want to disagree with me and call Tomb Raider or Dark Vengeance Action-Adenture games, they would certainly go in this category.
Action-Adventure – Open-World
See above for my thoughts on what Open-World means, it is a complex designator indeed. What makes something truly an open-world game? Are both of ’98’s Zelda games Open-World? GameFAQs says so, but I would probably disagree; both have an open world, but in that world you spend most of your time on a linear quest through dungeons. They are games that are both open and linear. Indeed, all games I have mentioned in this category have a linear main quest with open-world side elements. That is normal in the open world genre of course, I guess the dividing line is on how much you can explore that world freely. And on that respect, Redguard probably counts as open world, or at least as much as a Zelda game of the time is certainly. It very much has a main quest path you follow with dungeons and such, but you also can explore the whole island. King’s Quest: Mask of Eternity is in that same category of games with a linear quest but also an open world and significant exploration along the way. Both of these games are quite flawed, and are not among the year’s best games that’s for sure, but are noteworthy regardless. There may be a better open-world action-adventure game from ’98 I’m not thinking of, but most of those are more RPG than action-adventure. You can have some RPG elements in an action-adventure game, but once the main focus is on RPG fights and levelling, the game probably should go in the RPG genre. On that one you could put Mask of Eternity in the (Action-)RPG genre alongside similarly adventure game-influenced Sierra Action-RPG Quest for Glory V: Dragon Fire (PC), as Mask of Eternity does have experience points and that level system. Anyway, either way on that, Mask of Eternity, Redguard, or Ocarina of Time are probably as close to an open-world-ish Action-Adventure game as you will get in 1998.
Action-Adventure – Sandbox Third Person Crafting
This subgenre is the one which includes Minecraft style games. Nothing in ’98 is directly comparable. There are games with elements of Minecraft, but nothing which puts the whole package together. The closest is probably Ultima Online: The Second Age (PC), due to it having a high degree of player choice and creation, including of buildings and more, and free sandbox gameplay. To a lesser extent the EverQuest beta for PC had some of these elements as well. I should mention some other games as well. First, Lego Creator (PC), a Lego Town building toolkit which lets you place an infinite number of Lego blocks to build a city. The free-build part of Minecraft is very much like a more advanced version of this, and it was Lego’s first such release, though there was an unlicensed title from 1997 called Air Blocks (PC) with a similar concept. Even so, Lego Creator is noteworthy. It also is a fully 3d game and you can move around in the city you created in first-person 3d if you wish. Vangers (PC) is also worth mentioning, as it is a very open-ended sandbox racing, action, adventure, and trading game. It does not have creation beyond some car customiation, though. I’d also like to mention those Jedi Knight 1 (PC, 1997) hacks that allowed people to make walls appear during online multiplayer games. This was quite fun, particularly on the Bespin map with all its open air space around the station! I am not aware of any first person game with wall creation before that, so it’s noteworthy for sure. I should also mention SimCity 2000 (PC, 1993), as the free city creation of games like that has to have been an inspiration for Minecraft as well. So, overall, there was nothing quite like Minecraft before its release, but you can see the origins of it in a bunch of games available in ’98.
Action-Adventure – Survival
This subgenre is whatGameFAQs calls Survival Horror games and similar horror-themed action-adventure games. So it’s pretty clear, isn’t it? The elite title in this category in ’98 was mentioned above, it’s Resident Evil 2 (PS1). As for lesser titles in this category, there are a couple of lesser ones: the decently average Deep Fear (Saturn, EU/JP only) and the infamously awful to a quite entertaining degree OverBlood 2 (PS1; JP release, US 2001). The horror genre in general was very strong in adventure games in 1998, and that carries over to action-adventure as well — even though there are few titles here, when one of them is maybe the genres’ best and most popular game ever that counts for a lot.
[photo here of Grim Fandango, Journeyman Project 3, Blackstone Chronicles, Morpheus, Of Light and Darkness, RedJack, Starship Titanic]
Adventure
Adventure games center around conversations, puzzles, and/or story, and probably do not have action components. If they do, they are a sideline beneath the story and/or puzzles. Please note that educational or young child-focused games are in the Edutainment genre instead of this one. There were a lot of adventure games in ’98. I will mention a lot of them and go well down the list, but very far from all. Including everything, hundreds of adventure games released in ’98. That may sound like a lot, but the numbers were down from a few years earlier.
Note that the numbers in parenthesis below are the MobyRanks. I probably should remove all of these in favor of the much more useful Mobygames Critical Averages but have not done this so far.
Adventure (Graphic Adventure, aka Point and Click Adventure)
Top List: Grim Fandango (PC) [8.5], Sanitarium (PC) [8.1], The Journeyman Project 3: Legacy of Time (PC) [7.7], Tex Murphy: Overseer (PC) [7.5], Black Dahlia (PC) [7.4]
The Next Best Titles By Review Average: Divi-Dead (PC; US/JP, 18+ pornographic hentai game) [7.4], LSD Dream Emulator (PS1; JP only) [7.3], Galador: The Prince and the Coward (PC; EU only, Poland/Germany only until a 2020s English release) [7.4], Nightlong: Union City Conspiracy (PC) [7.4], The Pink Panther: Hokus Pokus Pink (PC, EU only) [7.3], John Saul’s Blackstone Chronicles (PC) [7.1]
The Lower Tier of Possibly Noteworthy Games: The X-Files Game (PC) [7.1], Rent-A-Hero [note, this is not the Sega game. Totally different game.] (PC, EU only) [7], Morpheus (PC/Mac) [6.9], Nancy Drew: Secrets Can Kill (PC) [6.9], RedJack: Revenge of the Brethren (PC/Mac) [6.7], Dark Side of the Moon (PC) [6.7], Of Light and Darkness: The Prophecy (PC) [6.5], Reah: Face the Unknown (PC; EU ’98, US ’99) [6.6], Echo Night (PS1; JP release, US/EU ’99) [6.6], Starship Titanic (PC) [6.3], Ring: Legend of the Nibelungen (PC) [6], Clock Tower: Ghost Head (PS1, JP release; US 1999 as Clock Tower II: The Struggle Within) [5.8] and more and more there are so many! To list the rest of the 6.3 to 6.0-score tier: Comer (PC), Hellnight (PS1; JP ’98, EU ’99, no US release), China: The Forbidden City (PC/Mac, also PS1 in ’99), MTV’s Beavis and Butt-Head: Do U (PC), Juggernaught (PS1; JP ’98, US ’99), Hopkins FBI (PC), Celtica (PC). Below these are scores more games, some retail titles, many indie games or Japanese-only visual novels. I will mention those in the next category down.
In order to break these games up into subgenres, several differentiators are used. First, I have already separated out action-adventure, rpg-adventure, visual novel, and text adventure games into their own categories. Within what remains, there are three basic types of adventure games, with three common themes. The types are item and conversation focused games of either first or third person – the choice there affects gameplay significantly, and logic puzzle focused first person games. Live-action-video FMV games could also be considered a separate category, though they have a lot in common with the first person categories. Meanwhile, the main game themes are horror, comedy, or mystery. Adventure games are usually one of those three things.
Note: I described Grim Fandango in the first article. It is the greatest adventure game ever made. It is a third person item/conversation game with comedy and mystery themes. The failure of games like it and many other titles above to sell as well as the publishers hoped basically was the death-knell for adventure games. Seeing the market declining, some publishers switched to adding more action to their adventure games, resulting in a boom of survival horror games like Resident Evil 2 and action and adventure hybrid titles like Quest for Glory V and King’s Quest VIII: The Mask of Eternity, games which I discuss in their genres. 1998 was surely the most important year in adventure gaming history. It saw Lucasarts’ best adventure game ever barely make its budget back, helping convince the company to drop adventure games a few years later; the Quest for Glory and King’s Quest series end, partially due to decent but not amazing sales of the two games released this year (though both well outsold Grim Fandango, apparently.); and a bunch of other adventure games release that didn’t sell amazingly either. If you can identify the games above by their subgenres, you would notice that the Myst-style first person puzzle genre had faded; after five years of a flood of Myst clones, there were fewer of them in ’98. However, the ‘conversations and item puzzles’ style of adventure game didn’t return to popularity either, as the sales of such games from ’98 show.
Of the teams making adventure games in ’98, though, the primary thing you notice is the prevalence of horror themes. While there had always been horror adventure games, the sheer number of them in ’98, in both traditional and action adventure titles, was different. More games had horror themes, and fewer were primarily FMV based, though a few still were. From the psychological horror of Sanitarium or Clock Tower II to the traditional horror story of the first person puzzle adventure game John Saul’s Blackstone Chronicles to the survivial horror of Resident Evil 2, horror adventure games were everywhere. Sanitarium, an overhead isometric adventure game — yes, that is a unique perspective for the genre — is a particularly important standout title. This game may be somewhat obscure today, but it is a beloved classic and is a ‘peak’ game, one of the adventure game genre’s best games not made by Sierra or LucasArts. It is more than a few peoples’ favorite adventure game ever and for good reason, the setting and design are compellingly interesting. The game won some Best Adventure Game of 1998 awards, and deserved them. Of course, as per usual for the time given the trendlines of the genre, the developer would not make another adventure game after Sanitarium.
LSD Dream Emulator is an utterly bizarre title which tries to turn a dream diary one of the developers had been keeping into a game. It was ignored at the time, but is a popular title now because of how bizarre and experimental it is. You explore environments in first person without a clear objective, experiencing the weirdness within each dream. There isn’t really any objective or purpose here, so this is one of the first ‘walking simulators’. As an aside, in Japan the adventure game genre has always been almost exclusively first person. For some reason, outside of games with combat like the survival horror action-adventure game genre, the third person adventure game never caught on there at all; instead all adventure games are either first person exploration games where you move from point to point, or visual novels which bring you through a story. The Japanese games here are no exception, they are all first person. The main difference is about whether you have free movement, move from point to point, or follow a story in preset locations.
As for the other games, four of the titles are both good games and their studios’ final graphic adventure games. Tex Murphy: Overseer and Black Dahlia are two of the last major FMV adventure games, games with characters played by live actors displayed on prerendered backdrops. They are quality titles for their subgenre, but while previously popular the style was fading at the time. Overseer was the fifth and final game in its series, after it Access Software dropped adventure games to focus only on golf. Their golf games would continue to use images of human actors for several more years. Black Dahlia was Take Two’s third and final adventure game. It is a creepy murder mystery story with lots of live actors. The other major titles have drawn or modeled characters instead of human actors. Pirate-themed first person adventure RedJack got a mixed reception, but I liked it. While first person, it is more of a classic adventure game than a Mystlike. Sadly it failed to sell and was its studio’s last game. Yet another last is John Saul’s Blackstone Chronicles, a creepy first person horror adventure game based on a book series. It has rendered environments and speech, but no FMV. It’s worth a look if you like horror stories. Developer Legend Entertainment had made quite a few adventure games over the years, but dropped the genre to switch to FPSes after this one. And last but not least, Starship Titanic is an interesting, though flawed, adventure game with writing from Douglas Adams of The Hitchiker’s Guide to the Galaxy fame. It is a first person puzzle adventure game somewhat in the Myst vein, but with conversations with various robot characters on the eponymous starship and, interestingly for its time, a text parser option to make conversations more challenging and varied. The game was its studio’s only game before shutting down.
And as for second-to-lasts, Of Light and Darkness would be Interplay’s second-to-last adventure game, followed by Y2K: The Game (PC, 1999). Of Light and Darkness has very interesting art design made by a known artist, though the actual gameplay quality is mixed. The two biggest names of adventure gaming were also almost done with the genre — Lucasarts would make only one more after Grim Fandango, Escape from Monkey Island (PC, 2000), a relative disappointment compared to previous titles. And Sierra, who didn’t release a pure adventure game in ’98 but had multiple hybrid titles such as Quest for Glory V and King’s Quest: Mask of Eternity, would also make only one more, Gabriel Knight 3: Blood of the Sacred, Blood of the Damned (PC, 1999). That one was a better last hurrah, though it does have one infamous puzzle about a moustache…
On the other hand, one of the most popular adventure game series ever started in 1998, and it was made by an American studio: Nancy Drew: Secrets Can Kill, the first of what is now surely dozens of Nancy Drew adventure games from Her Interactive. Based on the popular girl detective, it is a first person adventure game with animated characters. It has mostly logic puzzles but also some items. It is aimed at a younger female audience but has multiple difficulty options to allow people of different skills to play. Adventure games had always appealed to female audiences, but most ’80s and ’90s adventure games star male characters. It makes sense that one with a female protagonist would be a hit, and this was.
Graphic Adventure games were not quite on the verge of death worldwide in 1998, though. In Europe they actually were improving, finally almost reaching the quality of the American games from studios abandoning the genre in droves in the late ’90s. The quality of European adventure games from ’98 is mixed, as the list above shows — that top five are all American games. The top European games are Nightlong and Galador, followed by games such as Rent-A-Hero (1998), Reah, Ring: Legend of the Nibelungen, and Starship Titanic. European adventure game quality would improve after this. The Longest Journey (PC, 2000) is an all-time classic, most notably, and Benoit Sokal’s Amerzone (PC, 1999) would start a long-running series. It would be at least a decade until graphic adventures started fading in Europe.
In Japan the visual novel genre was reaching a new peak of popularity, but Western adventure, adventure-RPG, and adventure-action games were mostly in retreat. If titles like King’s Quest VIII: Mask of Eternity were an attempt to save adventure games, it didn’t work. Europe would continue to make bigger-budget adventure games in the next decade, with titles such as The Longest Journey and Syberia particularly notable, but even there by the 2010s the genre would eventually fade to a more indie game-focused level in favor of more simplified things like walking simulators.
A few words about each game mentioned above that I have not covered (Note, I have not played any of these games myself.):
Divi-Dead – [18+] I’m not sure if this should be in adventure or visual novel but it does seem to have movement between locations, it’s not just watching a story.
Galador: The Prince and the Coward – Nicely animated European classic adventure, though it apparently has issues.
Nightlong: Union City Conspiracy – Good classic detective story with a Blade Runner style setting, though this game isn’t as innovative as the game Blade Runner (PC, 1997). Third person.
The Pink Panther: Hokus Pokus Pink – Classic item puzzles adventure game.
The X-Files Game – Fully live action video FMV game with six discs. Some liked it, some hated it.
Rent-A-Hero (1998) – Nicely animated European classic adventure game, early ’90s style.
Morpheus – Myst-style first person puzzle adventure.
Dark Side of the Moon – FMV adventure game with live action video and multiple discs.
Of Light and Darkness: The Prophecy – Art-first game with great art but questionable gameplay.
Reah: Face the Unknown – Myst-style first person puzzle adventure.
Echo Night – Japanese first person horror adventure game by From Software.
Clock Tower: Ghost Head – Third game in its series of Japanese horror adventure games where you play as women trying to thwart supernatural horror movie killers.
Hellnight – First person Japanese adventure game where you and a girl try to escape a horror movie killer.
China: The Forbidden City – First person adventure with a historical setting.
MTV’s Beavis and Butt-Head: Do U – Licensed game based on the TV show. Okay but downgraded sequel to its very popular and acclaimed predecessor, Beavis and Butt-Head in Virtual Stupidity (PC, 1995). It’s from a different team from the first one. The studio shut down after this game flopped.
Juggernaught – Japanese adventure game with CGI-rendered visuals, logic puzzles, and, yes, a horror theme.
Hopkins FBI – This is a very violent animated adventure game about trying to stop a serial killer. It’d get an M rating at minimum today for sure.
Celtica – Myst-style first person logic puzzle game but with a Celtic theme.
Comer – This is another first person adventure game with puzzles, though it’s much more indie than the others above.
Adventure – Visual Novel
Top List: Sakura Wars 2 (SAT) (JP only) (also a strategy game), Machi (SAT, PS ’99) (JP only), One: Kagayaku Kisetsu e (PC/PS1) (JP only), serial experiments lain (PS1) (JP only), Triangle Heart (PC) (JP only).
Note: Western options are few but there are a few unspectacular ones for kids, such as Rockett’s Tricky Decision (PC/Mac) and Rockett’s Secret Invitation (PC/Mac).
In Japan, the visual novel was really hitting its stride in ’98, with important titles for the genre’s development. Visual novels were most frequently romance games, often with sexual content in their PC versions but with that stuff removed on consoles. If not that, murder mysteries were the most common alternative. There were noteworthy titles in the genres’ development in ’98. The best pure adventure game of ’98 in Japanese lists is clearly Machi, a murder mystery story. The game is great enough to finish fifth in a 2017 Famitsu list of the best adventure games ever. Sakura Wars 2 [aka Sakura Taisen 2] is also noteworthy since the series was such a huge success at the time. That series of visual novel / turn-based strategy hybrid titles were very popular for a while in Japan. You play as a guy managing a team of girls who are both pilots defending Japan from monsters, and a theater troupe. Apparently the plot gets somewhat serious, with an antiwar theme. As a console game it obviously did not have adult content and was the fifth best selling Saturn game in Japan, selling a bit over 500,000 copies. It outsold the first one.
For me though, even though I haven’t played it or any of these games in this genre, One is perhaps the most noteworthy, as it is one of the games by the people that would become Key, the masters of the sad love story visual novel or anime. Before making their iconic 1999 classic Kanon, most of that staff made One: Kagayaku Kisetsu e for a different studio. It is a somewhat similarly sad and weirdly supernatural title, like Kanon. The PC version is adult, the PS1 version not, as expected. Apparently Nasu, the writer of Tsukihime and Fate Stay-Night, was inspired to be a writer by One. Noteworthy indeed. As for those others, Triangle Heart is mostly noteworthy for being the origin of the spinoff Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha magical girl action series. Nanoha is a minor side character from Triangle Heart. The lain game is a weird, and highly expensive now, experience, sought after by fans of that iconic anime. I haven’t played the game, but it is highly regarded, and the anime is my favorite anime ever. And yes, the anime is from 1998. TV anime had its best work ever this year as well. The timing is not a cooincidence, as it is an anime about the impact of the internet on Japanese society. It could not have been made earlier.
As for those two American games, the Rockett series was a five-game series from ’97 to ’99, all of which are animated stories where you occasionally make a choice that branches the story slightly. The series didn’t really end, it just stopped being made after game five after Mattel bought the studio and shut it down, but they are fine. We had the first game, Rockett’s New School (PC, 1997), back in the late ’90s, which was surely a gift for my sister, and there’s minimal replay value but it’s mildly amusing for like half an hour. Most of the characters are quite stereotypical though. Oh, there was also a spinoff nongame comic creator in the series released in ’98 called Rockett’s Adventure Maker (PC/Mac).
Adventure – 3D First Person
The first-person, puzzle-heavy adventure game, inspired by the megahit Myst, was a fading genre by 1998 as I said earlier. If you want a Myst-style game released in ’98, the much more average titles Morpheus or Reah might be your best bet. They both have first person viewpoints with nice CGI environments and complex logic puzzles. First person adventure games with more item and conversation-based gameplay also released, such as RedJack, Starship Titanic, Of Light and Darkness, and all the Japanese games are also first person.
Adventure – 3D Third Person
For some reason GameFAQs thinks that separating out graphic adventures that use polygons into a separate subgenre is relevant. I’m not sure why. Regardless, Grim Fandango is the highlight here, being the genre’s best game ever and all and having polygonal characters on prerendered backdrops.
Adventure – General
GameFAQs uses this for games which they aren’t sure of the subgenre of. Look at the list and you will see a massive list of mostly Japanese visual novels.
Adventure – Text (aka Interactive Fiction)
While there were some indie text adventure released in 1998, there aren’t any that anyone outside of the Interactive Fiction fanbase would have heard of, as its fans call this subgenre. ’98 was before the IF renaissance, but there were a few mostly freeware or shareware IF games released in ’98, and even one retail title sold by mail order. That retail one is Once and Future (PC), surely the most important IF game of the year and the product of five years of work by a longtime writer in the genre. It is a ‘modern person thrown into Camelot’ title, and it sounds like it is fairly well written. Of the more indie titles, Anchorhead (PC), Losing Your Grip (PC), and Photopia (PC) are some of the few others. Anchorhead is a horror-themed game, fitting well with the trend in graphical adventure games that year as well.
[insert photo of Axis & Allies, Clue, and Top Shop here]
Miscellaneous
These are games in genres that don’t fit into the other nine main genres on GameFAQs. It makes sense to combine these varied styles of games into one, each is totally different but not a large enough genre to stand on its own in this list.
- Miscellaneous-Application – Not games, not applicable here.
- Miscellaneous-Compilation – This is a collection of various games. Obviously for an article like this they would be considered individually.
- Miscellaneous-Demo Disc – Demos are certainly games, but I am not discussing them here. I will say though that I was subscribed to PC Gamer throughout 1998 and loved those discs. See my old PC Gamer Demo Discs article for a list of the demos on those discs.
Miscellaneous – Board/Card
Top List: Chessmaster 6000 (PC), Board Game: Top Shop (PS1/SAT, JP release; US 2001, PS1 only), Hoyle Board Games (PC), LEGO Chess (PC), Virtual Chess 64 (N64), Axis & Allies: The Ultimate WWII Strategy Game (PC), Clue: Murder at Boddy Mansion (PC).
Others of Note: The Game of Life (PC/PS1), Trivial Pursuit: CD-ROM Edition (PC), Stratego (PC), and so many more… Sorry, Operation, Scotland Yard (EU only release), lots of chess and card games, and more, all released in ’98.
A whole lot of electronic adaptations of board games released in 1998. It was perhaps the beginning of a peak era for digital boardgames, since with the advance of technology they now could have graphics as detailed as the board games themselves and new features like online multiplayer as well, in the PC games of course. Board game adaptations before this were more obvious visual downgrades from their tabletop form. However, these games were generally overlooked at the time as far as rankings and best games lists and such were concerned, so it’s hard to make a list of the best ones. There are dozens of boardgame releases this year to consider. I put six in the top list instead of five because all six are good enough to be worth mentioning.
These games come in three categories: the board game adaptations, the Battle Chess knockoffs, and the original titles. Well, title; the only original title here is Board Game: Top Shop, a Japanese computer boardgame. It’s an above average to good game actually, in the Monopoly vein. The Battle Chess games here are Lego Chess and Virtual Chess 64. I call them Battle Chess games because both are chess games with animated fight scenes each time you take a piece, as in the early ’90s classic Battle Chess. These are fun games to play for a while, though if you get more seriously into chess you would want to play something with top-quality AI and no animations. Still, for more casual play they are solid entertainment.
The two board game adaptations we got in the late ’90s are in the last, and largest, category, though, traditional board game adaptations. Axis & Allies is the same thing as the board game, but takes like a tenth as long because of having the computer roll the dice for you and such. I liked the board game quite a bit, but this difference really shows how much of the time of a board game is taken up with make-work tasks that computers automate in seconds. However, you can only see a small amount of the map at a time instead of the whole thing, so even if it takes many hours longer, the real board game is more fun. Still, it’s good for the time, though today you can find better ways to play A&A online. Clue: Murder at Boddy Mansion is a good adaptation of the board game with some PC-only added features. We played Clue regularly when I was growing up, though my mother is great at it and usually won so it usually wasn’t close, so we got this and had fun with it. As for the number one title here, I haven’t played it, but we did have Chessmaster 3000 (PC, 1991) back in the early ’90s and I loved it, and by all accounts the series stayed great, so I am sure that Chessmaster 6000 is also fantastic. Chessmaster was the premiere chess game series at the time, with challenging AI and a good featureset for learning how to improve at the game.
I know less about the games in the Others of Note category. I’m sure they are all solid adaptations, though there is probably little reason to go back to these games today, you can play the board game or better, newer computer versions elsewhere. The Scotland Yard game looks somewhat interesting, though. Despite the British setting the game is French-made. It was by Cryo so expect some kind of weirdness I am sure.
Miscellaneous – Edutainment
There was a boom of titles which combine education with some game compoment from the mid ’80s to early ’90s, but I feel like their popularity faded after that. There were many edutainment games releasing in ’98, of course, but the peak of quality was before this, The Learning Company’s many hits first among them. The Learning Company still existed in ’98, but for me at least this was past their peak. The ‘edutainment’ games in this list mostly have less educational value than The Castle of Dr. Brain or Treasure Mathstorm, from everything I can see, but I was too old for edutainment games for young children by 1998, so I have never played any of these. If we just look at Mobygames and sort by Mobyrank though, we get this:
Top List: Pajama Sam 2: Thunder and Lightning aren’t so Frightening (PC/Mac), ClueFinders: 3rd Grade Adventures (PC), Rugrats Adventure Game (PC), The Rugrats Movie: Activity Challenge (PC), Star Wars: Droidworks (PC), I Spy (PC/Mac), Freddi Fish 3: The Case of the Stolen Conch Shell (PC), and The Amazon Trail: 3rd Edition (PC/Mac).
I am sure all of those are solid; I know kids a bit younger than me really liked Humongous Entertainment’s kid-focused adventure games such as Pajama Sam and Freddi Fish. I have not played them myself, but from my understanding they are more entertainment than learning, though; they maybe should not be in this genre due to that and some sites do list them as just Adventure and not Edutainment. The Amazon Trail: 3rd Edition is much more educational. Unlike The Oregon Trail, this game has a modern-day setting. You travel through the Amazon, while learning about its history and trying to survive the dangers. It sounds okay but similar to past titles. One game here stands out, though: Star Wars Droidworks particularly looks interesting, and unlike most of these it’s definitely a learning game. Oh, I Spy is a puzzle/minigame title I decided to put here since it is for young children.
Miscellaneous – Exercise/Fitness
There may not be any releases in this subgenre this year.
Miscellaneous – Gambling
I hate gambling, so I stay far away from this utter trash in real life, much less the unbelievably stupid idea of playing a digital slot machine or something.
… What is this, you question that given my Mario Kart World (Nintendo Switch 2, 2025) addiction? Uh, I understand your skepticism, but it is true. I STRONGLY dislike real or digital gambling. Anyway, looking at the releases, there are a fair number of titles but only two have a Mobyscore, and both are pretty bad, under a 7. Those two are:
Top List: Leisure Suit Larry’s Casino (PC), Golden Nugget 64 (N64; expanded port of a PC/PS1 game from ’96/’97).
Also of Note: Neo Cherry Master (NGP), Caesar’s Palace II (PS1). The Neo-Geo Pocket (Color) would have many slot machine and pachislot releases, including one of its first games.
Miscellaneous – Party/Minigame
While party or minigame collections had existed for years, often in some kind of digital boardgame form, the genre changed forever in 1998 in a fundamental way due to the release of one key game…
Top List: Mario Party (N64)
Mario Party, developed by Hudson for Nintendo, reinvented the board game / minigame collection. Minigame collections had existed before ’98, and so had digital board games, and even board games with some minigame elements, but there had been nothing quite like Mario Party before, with the strong focus on a large number of minigames alongside a full digital boardgame. Where previously a minigame collection might have a handful of minigames, here there are scores of them, of many different types, all made to a high quality level. The game would have many copycats after its release, but it all started here, in ’98, with Mario Party 1. The first one is definitely not the best game in the series, the second one for N64 is the fan favorite, but you wouldn’t have Mario Party 2 without the first game and it started out well, apart from the injury problems some people had from the stick-spinning minigames. Nintendo had to offer a glove to people who had bought the game because of that. I am not sure if that makes this game better or worse, but it’s true. 1998 is when this genre was, for the most part, created. Board games and minigames both existed before, but not exactly this kind of combination of the two. It would prove to be a very successful formula. Future years would see many more than one game per year release in this category, but at their core they all copy this title.
Miscellaneous – Trivia/Gameshow
Top List: You Don’t Know Jack Volume 4: The Ride (PC/Mac), Head Rush (PC/Mac), Jeopardy! (1998) (PC; Hasbro), Wheel of Fortune (1998) (PC; Hasbro).
You Don’t Know Jack was the premiere trivia game series of the time, and its developer released two trivia games in ’98, the top two titles in this list. These are all fairly simple multiple choice games with four possible answers per question, but they try to be amusing so they’re fun enough I guess. We didn’t get any of them back then but I tried some. As you can guess I was never as entertained by these as a lot of people seemed to be. If the name sounds familiar, that’s because the modern phone & console/PC party Jackbox party games are by a direct descendant of the studio who made You Don’t Know Jack, so they continued making some of the most popular party games well after YDKJ faded out. The series started before 1998, though, it wasn’t a new idea here. As for Jeopardy and Wheel of Fortune, these were the first from Hasbro. Previously Sony and Gametek had made games based on these popular gameshows, but in ’98 a new studio gave it a try. The results are similar to previous entries. My nostalgia says that Sony’s is the best one though, heh – Jeopardy! (1994) (PC/Sega CD, 1994).
Puzzle
Puzzle – Blockdropping, Matching, or Logic
Please note: Puzzle-Action games are listed separately below; this category combines all other kinds of puzzle games.
Top List – Tetris DX (GB/C), Hexcite (GB/C), Ballistic/Puzz Loop (ARC; home ports ’99-’00), Devil Dice (PS1; JP/US in ’98, EU ’99), Bust-A-Move 4 (ARC/PS1).
Also Noteworthy: Wetrix (N64, PC/PS2 later), Susume! Taisen Puzzle Dama (N64, JP only), Brain Drain (GB), Wrecking Crew ’98 (SNES; JP only), Puzzle Link (NGP, JP/EU only).
Special Mention: In ’98 Super Puzzle Fighter II Turbo released on the PC in the US (arcades/PS1/SAT earlier), and Puchi Carat released on PS1 in JP/EU and Saturn in JP (arcades ’97).
While some people might say that 1998 was not one of the puzzle genre’s best years, as the Tetris game was a rerelease and there was no Puyo Puyo this year for instance as the fourth game relased in ’99, ’98 actually had some significant puzzle titles. The most important by far is Puzz Loop, also known as Ballistic. This arcade game would reach massive international fame once shamelessly ripped off by a certain other developer as Zuma. Yes, Zuma may be good, but it is a knockoff. Puzz Loop takes the concept of other match-3 games like Bust-A-Move, but has the balls follow a set track, automatically moving towards a central well. You shoot balls out from a hole in the center, trying to match colors to keep them from reaching the middle. It’s a fun, and stressful, concept that was executed well from the beginning. Tetris gets top billing on this list, though, because it was a color update to the most popular puzzle game ever, Tetris for the original Game Boy. It was good, adding not just color but also a battery to save your best scores and a few rule updates. In second, and in first for me because this is a 10/10 game on my list, I know few other people care, but I seriously love Hexcite, a game based on an obscure Japanese board game that I wish I could find a physical copy of. I wrote a review of it a few years back. It’s an amazing board/puzzle title that I got completely addicted to for at least a year some time ago. It is just incredible stuff.
As for the others, Devil Dice is a very good puzzle game where you control a character who can move around dice, trying to match dice by rolling them together with the same number on top. It’s really quite fun and well made. Bust-A-Move 4 is a good, A-grade game, but personally BAM 3, aka BAM ’99 on N64, is my favorite game in the series. Even so, 4 is more of the same great bubble-shooting fun. Wetrix is an interesting 3d puzzle game where you use pieces to make reservoirs to try to hold all the water that soon starts flooding the stage. It’s pretty good, look it up if you haven’t played it. And last, Susume! Taisen Puzzle Dama is a decent little puzzler from Konami. It’s the N64 entry in its then-ongoing Puzzle-Dama and Tokkaedama puzzle game franchise, and has both modes in one, albeit with original characters and not the franchise ones used in almost every other title in the series, such as the Tokimeki Memorial versions on PS1. It’s basically like an easy version of Puyo Puyo — you only need to match three to form a match.
Puzzle Link is a solid little blockdropping game. It’s the premiere NGP/C-exclusive puzzle franchise, though even on that platform it was probably outshone by the NGPC version of Bust-A-Move. Despite that, it’s a fun little ‘blocks dropping in a well’ game where you connect things with curving parts to clear them by linking the pieces. It’s pretty good, though the color version from ’99 is the same exact thing as this except in color. Brain Drain and Wrecking Crew ’98 are much more in the logic puzzle genre, though. Brain Drain most certainly is; it’s a pure logic puzzle game with some very tricky puzzles. There is a randomly rearranged field of objects and you need to put them in the correct order by rotating groups of four within a time limit. It’s tough. As for Wrecking Crew ’98, this Japan exclusive isn’t a platform-puzzle game like its NES predecessor. Instead, this time it’s a match 3 colored blocks puzzler. Blocks drop from above and you either destroy them or use a switch which rotates a single row in order to arrange them into sets by color. It’s fine but average stuff, nothing special.
Lastly, Puchi Carat is a pretty great arcade game, and the home port’s just as fun. It’s a shame it never released in the US on PS1. If the arcade game had been from ’98 it would be in the main list for sure. This list won’t convince anyone this is an all-time list, but any year with one of the better Tetris games should rank well.
If we look at the subgenres of the puzzle genre, this is where each one fits:
- General – N/A
- Hidden Object – This genre wasn’t much of a thing yet, apart from book conversions such as the old Where’s Waldo games or one title from ’98, I Spy (PC), a simple game for young children. The adult-aimed hidden object genre would not appear until the mid ’00s or so, after real adventure games started to fade out in favor of those simpler titles that require less effort to play.
- Logic – Brain Drain, Hexcite, Devil Dice
- Matching – Bust-A-Move 4, Susume! Taisen Puzzle Dama, Super Puzzle Fighter II Turbo (PC), Wrecking Crew ’98
- Stacking (Blockdropping) – Tetris DX, Wetrix, Puzzle Link
Puzzle-Action
Top List: Sutte Hakkun (SNES; digital Nintendo Power release only in ’98, cart release in ’99), I.Q. Final (PS1; JP/EU only, no US release), Egg (JP only release), Bomberman: Party Edition (’98 JP, ’00 US), Bomberman World (PS1).
Sutte Hakkun is a good puzzle-platformer. It looks like a platformer, but plays like a logic puzzle. It’s pretty good and well worth a play. I.Q. Final is the sequel to the first Intelligent Qube (PS1, 1997), which was released worldwide and got good reviews. Sadly it didn’t sell well enough for the sequel to get a US release, but regardless, it’s a very good block avoidance puzzle game. Try to avoid falling off the end of the stage! These are the two top titles in this category for sure this year.
On another note, Egg is a very weird but pretty cool game. You hit an egg around a stage, and as it rolls it takes control of territory. You will build a civilization in your territory, and compete against another player for dominance of each stage. It’s weird but actually pretty good. Give it a try. It has next to no language barrier once you understand what to do.
Sadly, the last two games on this list aren’t as successful, and those are the two traditional Bomberman games. They are fine, but a bit disappoining considering the series’ history. Bomberman World and Bomberman: Party Edition are okay but neither one matches up to Saturn Bomberman (SAT, 1996) or the TurboGrafx Bomberman games, that’s for sure. There were a total of seven Bomberman games in ’98 as Hudson tried to make him their cross-genre mascot, but I wish that they had focused more effort on one traditional Bomberman game instead of making two somewhat half-baked ones. That may be a bit harsh as both do have higher review scores than the other four Bomberman games that year, but I do think it’s true. As for the other five Bomberman games though, they were in other genres. I have already mentioned the 3d platformer Bomberman Hero, and also the 2d platformer that’s a colorized version of the previous years’ B&W game, Pocket Bomberman (GB/C). a turn-based strategy game I may mention later, the top-down action-adventure Bomberman Quest (GB/C), and a kart racing game I’ll get to soon. That is a lot of Bomberman games but if you look up their scores, they all got C-tier grades. Hudson seems to have struggled in the later ’90s despite making a few very memorable games like Bomberman 64 [aka Baku Bomberman in Japan] (N64, 1997), and looking back, it was all downhill after ’98. They would have a few more decent years but after that their decline became terminal and the company would be sold to Konami and then shut down by the early 2010s.
Anyway, I should get to the point, Bomberman World and Bomberman: Party Edition, both Playstation games from opposite ends of the same year. Why did Hudson release two similar games on the same platform? Well, the game designs of both are different. World released in January and tries to be the next — and maybe kind of last — TV console 2d Bomberman game. It has nice isometric 2d graphics, but the gameplay isn’t as varied as 1996’s Saturn Bomberman and it doesn’t look quite as good as that game. Party Edition released in December and is a remake of the original Bomberman, but with some nice multiplayer added. It’s clearly a smaller-scale offering than World, but actually reviewed slightly better. Its ‘kill all enemies in every level to proceed’ gameplay is very basic, but well, it is a remake of the first NES game, so you should expect that. Both are smaller-scale titles than what was surely the biggest-budget Bomberman game of ’98 and probably his actual best game that year even if reviews don’t reflect that, the 3d platformer Bomberman Hero on N64, but both are fun, classic Bomberman titles.
Overall, this is most certainly not a peak year for puzzle-action games. Titles released, but none are among the genres’ greats.

Many of my racing games from 1998, all together, by platform. The bottom row are games released in 1999 that are ports of games from ’98 on other platforms. California Speed (center right) is also in this category, I just put it higher up to fit it into the picture. VR Powerboat Racing: Pure Power is a retail demo with only three tracks, but it is the only PC version of the game I own so here it is. Sonic R is the PC port of a Saturn game from 1997.
Many of my racing games from 1998, all together, by platform. The bottom row are games released in 1999 that are ports of games from ’98 on other platforms. California Speed (center right) is also in this category, I just put it higher up to fit it into the picture.
Racing
The racing game genre is broad, so I break it down into categories. The primary breakdown is between simulation and arcade racing games. I don’t make one list with both types.
Racing – Racing Simulation
Top List – Grand Prix Legends (PC), Colin McRae Rally (PS1/PC) (EU release, other regions ’99), Viper Racing (PC), F-1 World Grand Prix (N64, later DC/PS1/PC), Monaco Grand Prix: Racing Simulation 2 (PC/N64/PS1/DC).
Honorable Mentions: Motocross Madness (PC), Air Racing (PC; third party addon for Microsoft Flight Simulator 95 or 98 (PC, 1995/1997), Driver’s Education ’98 (PC) and Driver’s Education ’99 (PC). The latter two games are there for unique design more so than amazing quality.
Special Mention: The Western release of 1997 (in Japan)’s Gran Turismo (PS1) was the best-selling racing sim ever up to this point by a wide margin. Another noteworthy game released in Europe in ’97 that released in North America in ’98 is F1 Racing Simulation (PC), from Ubisoft, the first game in the series that Monaco Grand Prix continued. It was a critical hit here but sold poorly.
In ’98, Formula One sims dominated the realistic racing genre. Grand Prix Legends I mentioned in the first article. It is the most highly regarded racing sim from Papyrus before its developers founded iRacing. Remember, this Grand Prix Legends is different from the iRacing Grand Prix Legends mode that is essentially the sequel to this game. Beyond that game, F-1 World Grand Prix is the best of the console F1 games, with Monaco Grand Prix finishing in a solid second place. F-1 World Grand Prix may have had a bunch of ports, but original developer Paradigm only made the N64 game and its sequel. The ports are inferior to the original; they were a good N64 studio who had previously made Pilotwings 64 (N64, 1996). Monaco Grand Prix is more similar across platforms.
Driver’s Education ’98, and also the ’99 edition if it also released in 1998 as some sources online say, are very highly interesting in terms of design: they have a highly realistic chunk of city to drive around in! The actual gameplay is a series of driving-test tutorials, but you can also freely drive around the city if you wish. This is one of the very first games with such a design, predating 1999’s much better known Midtown Madness or Driver for PC. One of the very few games before this with open-city driving is Vette! (PC, 1989). I thought that 1998 didn’t have anything like with open city driving other than maybe Vangers or Carmageddon 2: Carpocalypse Now until I remembered this one, so I am glad I did so that I could include it here.
As for the rest of these titles, Colin McRae Rally began an important series that would become the Dirt series of simmish rally racers. The first one isn’t as realistic as the Dirt games would become, but it was a massive hit in Europe particularly and was more realistic than previous games in the genre. Viper Racing is a somewhat lightweight sim, but it’s fun and has great crash and car damage modeling. You won’t find damage modeling in most licensed racing games, that’s for sure; Gran Turismo has none, for example. This does. Motocross Madness is another one of those hybrid titles, an arcade/sim crossover with more realistic handling than Moto Racer, but lots of very arcadey elements like being able to jump very high up into the air. It’s the Forza Horizon of ’90s motorcycle racing games, I guess. And Gran Turismo releasing in the West was hugely significant. Gran Turismo would be a massive seller in both the US and Europe, selling a good 4 million copies in each region. The game is a pretty lightweight sim compared to top PC sims like GPL or 1996’s Geoff Crammond’s Grand Prix II, and again has no car damage, but that is surely an important part of how it sold many millions of copies while the hardcore sims always were more niche. Given that the kind of racing it covers isn’t that popular in the US, it’s interesting that the game sold so well here. How many Americans had ever even heard of GT racing before this game? Almost noone. And yet, the GT games were at the very top of the US PS1 sales charts. That clearly says a lot about their quality.
As for non-car racing simulations, there’s only one I can think of: a third party expansion for Microsoft Flight Simulator 95 or 98 (PC, 1995/1997) called Air Racing – Can You Win the World’s Fastest Race? (PC). It uses the MFS engine to create aerial races around large poles.
Racing – Arcade-style Racing Games of All Types
Top List: F-Zero X (N64), Daytona USA 2: Battle on the Edge (ARC), XG2: Extreme-G 2 (N64, later PC), Moto Racer 2 (PC/PS1), R4: Ridge Racer Type 4 (PS1).
Honorable Mentions: Speed Busters: American Highways (PC, later DC), 1080 Degrees Snowboarding (N64), Motocross Madness (PC) if you list it here.
Other Titles of Lesser Note: Many! See the categories below for more games.
Most people would put R4 at second place on this list at the lowest, but it’s my list so it’s lower. It is okay but I just don’t find it all that engaging. Regardless, the racing genre had a massive number of good and great games this year, it is nearly impossible to choose only five. You can tell this is my list from the inclusions of XG2 and Moto Racer 2, I just couldn’t leave them out. A more objective top list might have 1080 Snowboarding and Speed Busters or Motocross Madness instead of those two, but I like XG2 and Moto Racer 2 better than those three games. At least, that is true on the PC; N64 XG2 and PS1 MR2 do not match up to the PC releases.
The racing genre deserves more than that, though. Even after breaking the genre into subgenres as I will below, I’m still only scratching the surface of the vast numbers of good or interesting racing games released in 1998…
Racing – Arcade Games
This category is for actual arcade games released in arcades.
Top List: Daytona USA 2: Battle on the Edge and its followup Daytona USA 2: Power Edition, California Speed (also N64 the next year), Sega Rally 2 (also DC the next year), Radikal Bikers (had an EU-exclusive PS1 port in ’99), Hyperdrive.
’98 probably isn’t the best year ever for arcade racing games, but all of these titles are pretty fun. It is unfortunate that many were arcade exclusives, that severely limits a games’ reach. I am a big San Francisco Rush fan, and its developer Atari Games made two racing games in ’98. However, the arcade one was California Speed, which is a point-to-point racer, conceptually basically a Cruis’n game in the Rush engine. Expect a lot of straight lines and smooth curves. It’s fun, but but is easier than the main Rush series; this is light entertainment and not something that will take serious play to learn. As for the two Sega games here, Sega Rally 2 and Daytona 2 are both pretty good. Daytona 2 is the much more legendary of the two, though, being an expensive, beautiful-looking game with some of the best graphics of any game released in 1998. It is the second of two racing games running on its hardware, after ’97’s Scud Race, and tragically neither one got a home port pretty much ever. It is very sad. Daytona USA 2 isn’t the iconic classic that the first Daytona is, but its expense and relative rarity are surely part of why. It is still a top tier arcade racing game that should have come home. As for Sega Rally 2, it isn’t the visual stunner that Daytona 2 is, and is generally regarded as a downgrade from the very popular original Sega Rally, but it’s still a pretty good game, especially in arcades; the Dreamcast version isn’t as good as the arcade is.
Radikal Bikers is interesting. Spanish studio Gaelco was one of the only European arcade game developers of the ’90s and ’00s, and Radikal Bikers is an over-the-top action driving game, a lot like its better-known followup Smashing Drive (ARC 2000, GC/Xbox 2002). Smashing Drive got poor reviews but I’ve always thought it was an above average game that is certainly fun to play, so I should play this one sometime. And last but definitely not least, Midway’s arcade game HyperDrive is a very cool looking futuristic hoverbike racer running on San Francisco Rush-style 3DFX hardware. It’s a real shame it never got a home port, but with only four tracks they would have had to add quite a bit to it for it to be a more full-featured console game and sadly I guess they weren’t interested in doing that. This game is up there with Sega’s futuristic racer Motor Raid (Arcade, 1997) in being games that I really wish had home ports.
Racing – Futuristic Racing
Top List: F-Zero X (N64), Wipeout 64 (N64), XG2: Extreme-G 2 (N64/PC), Powerslide (PC), S.C.A.R.S. (N64/PC/PS1).
Honorable Mentions: HyperDrive (ARC), DethKarz (PC), Motorhead (PC/PS1), Carmageddon II: Carpocalypse Now (PC), Radikal Bikers (ARC; PS1 ’99 EU only).
Not as Good: Streak: Hoverboard Racing (PS1), Mad Trax (PC; EU only).
Special Note: Red Asphalt (PS1) (EU ’97, NA ’98) released here in ’98. I think it’s a fantastic game, it’s too bad I can’t count it here. I would be top five.
What an amazing lineup! Those top four are four of the best futuristic racing games ever, no question. F-Zero X is the elite title here, a beloved classic I, and many others, love. It is a nearly perfect masterpiece. If you have not played it before play it immediately. It’s a 60fps game too, completely smooth. Wipeout 64 is an interesting one, the Wipeout series of Playstation futuristic combat circuit racing games gone N64, with levels adapted from the PS1 games with some alterations and new design ideas in the single player — now the single player is a series of missions with different objectives, instead of just racing championships. It is a quite challenging game despite being probably slightly easier than the PS1 games. It’s an amazing experience and my personal favorite Wipeout game. XG2 is another favorite of mine, a combat-heavy racer I regard highly. I know its review average is more mid-tier, but people are wrong on this one. The N64 version does have framerate problems, but even so it’s an impressive game with huge, complex tracks and outstanding gameplay. This game has some of the best tracks in the genre! Play it on PC for the best experience, as I did back when I first got it. I think most of the people criticizing this game have only ever played the sometimes choppy N64 version; I love that version too, but its ambition sometimes was a bit too much for the hardware to handle. On PC the framerate is perfect. PowerSlide is much lesser known than those three N64 classics, but it’s a fantastic game from a team in Austrailia. As the name suggests it’s a powersliding-heavy game with often dirt tracks. It has somewhat realistic physics but still has enough of that arcade charm to be a lot of fun. The game controls impressively well and I highly recommend trying it. It’s a tragedy that the developer, Ratbag, got shut down before making any more games. Midway bought the studio and then closed them like six months later instead of scaling up the team for next-gen development. It was shameful stuff, though typical in the games industry sadly. Anyway, look up Powerslide, it’s really great.
Moving on, DethKarz is a decent futuristic racer, but I find it really frustrating — it has a lot of floating roads with no walls, it can be hard to stay on the track and not fall off, and the handling isn’t the kind I like, it feels floaty. My first reaction to this game was quite negative. It got good reviews though so clearly other people see something in it I didn’t. SCARS is basically a futuristic kart racing game with weapons being central to the races, so it barely deserves to be in this genre, but I’ll put it in both. I think it’s a good game, but don’t love it as much as many seem to. It’s here more for its popularity than anything. As a little aside, Powerslide and DethKarz were both supposed to get N64 ports, but sadly both were cancelled. Apparently the DethKarz port was at least half done but has never leaked. Motorhead is a simple and straightforward racer. It’s fun, but you can tell it was a console-first design; you drive on narrow-ish tracks, with flashy lighting effects being as much of the point of the game as the actual gameplay is. It’s entertaining but probably too simple. It is also barely futuristic. Still, it reviewed well.
On the other hand, Mad Trax got poor reviews from the few outlets which reviewed this European exclusive. It is simple and straightforward but definitely my kind of game, I like it. The visual look is great! It has a very Pod-like aesthetic, but with some item pickups and more straightforward tracks than Pod (PC, 1997). Streak: Hoverboard Racing is basically the third actual JetMoto game, another casualty of SingleTrac and Sony breaking up. It scores poorly, similarly to the first two, not better or worse than either. Genre fans may want to give it a try. Sony’s Jet Moto 3 would release in 1999 to a similarly mediocre reception.
Also noteworthy and in its own category is Carmageddon II: Carpocalypse Now (PC). This is the second game in a somewhat infamous combat racing game where you can win by either destroying all other racers, going through all the checkpoints, or killing all human civilians on the map. Destroying the other racers is the easiest and most fun way to win most ‘races’ in the series. This sequel is not the iconic classic-of-sorts that the first game is, but it’s a decent racing game with large city levels and somewhat San Francisco Rush-inspired handling. The Carmageddon games move towards open world design in a way you didn’t see otherwise at this point – each map is a large area you can drive freely around in. Carmageddon II is PC only, but Carmageddon 64 (N64, 1999) is based on it, with maps inspired by a few levels from this game. Only the PC game has humans to run over, though; the N64 version replaces them with zombies, as all the console Carmageddon games do.
Lastly, I covered Hyperdrive and Radikal Bikers in the previous category, so see that.
Racing – Motorcycle, Ski, or Snowboard
Top List: Moto Racer 2 (PC/PS1), 1080 Degrees Snowboarding (N64), Motocross Madness (PC), Road Rash 3D (PS1), Redline Racer (PC; later DC as Suzuki Alstare Extreme Racing).
Honorable Mention: Big Mountain 2000 [aka Snow Speeder] (N64; JP ’98, US 2000).
Other Ski/Snowboard Games of Mixed Quality: PenPen TriIceLon (DC; JP ’98, West ’99), Cool Boarders 3 (PS1), Twisted Edge: Extreme Snowboarding (N64), Snow Break (PS1; JP/EU only, no US release), Skiing 1999 Edition [aka Sierra Sports Ski Racing].
I know tossing motorcycle and ski games together might be odd, but they do kind of fig together — both work as either racing or stunt games. 1080 is the obvious popular leader in this category; it is the most popular snowboarding game ever. With great graphics and controls, 1080 was like nothing before. The gap between this game and the low quality of most other skiing or snowboarding games of the day is ridiculous. The game has both races and a half-pipe stunt mode that was one of the better stunt modes in a game before Tony Hawk.
As for Road Rash 3D, I know most people dislike the game, but it’s actually my favorite game in the series. Most Road Rash games prioritize combat over racing, but in this one it is the other way around and I prefer it for that. The PC version of Moto Racer 2 is my favorite superbike motorcycle racing game ever. It is a simple but exceptional game. It is a very fast and fun arcade-style game, and is awesome stuff to play, as you blast through courses, learning the turns and trying not to hit the sides. The tracks do blend together, as they were made in a course builder so there are dozens of tracks with just a handful of visual themes, and tracks are always very narrow perhaps because of also having to work on the Playstation, but the sense of speed and control in this game is the best in the genre. The graphics on PC are fantastic as well.
Motocross Madness is also very good. It’s a lot more realistic than Moto Racer 2 so doing well takes more practice, but once you figure it out it’s good fun. It’s not on par with my favorite dirtbike racing game, Excitebike 64 (N64, 1999), for a more realistic dirtbike motorcycle racing game with big air, but it’s great stuff and is a better trick arena game than that one is. Riding around in its huge open spaces, jumping far into the air, and doing tricks before you finally land feels great, if you can get used to the physics. The sequel from the next year is the same thing but a bit better, but still it’s a solid game. Between 1080 and Motocross Madness, trick-focused games had a solid year in ’98 even if Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater didn’t quite exist yet; the first game in that series released in ’99. And lastly, Redline Racer had a mixed reception for some reason, with solid reviews for the PC version but poor ones for its later Dreamcast port, but I’d call it a quite fun, very under-rated game on either platform. It’s fast and fun, a lot like Moto Racer 2 but not quite as great. Very much like that game you zoom along narrow tracks, avoiding obstacles and learning the turns.
Big Mountain 2000 is an interesting one. If this was purely my list, it would be in the top five, knocking out out Motocross Madness or 1080. Motocross Madness, I must admit, is a game I more admire than I actually like, myself. Its physics can be frustrating and the gameplay loop is repetitive. Also I rarely find stunts in games interesting, and I don’t in either 1080 or Motocross Madness. I know that’s just me but I have to say it: 1080 is too stunt-focused to hold my interest long term. Rush 2049 (N64) is the big exception, the one stunt game I deeply love. Anyway, Big Mountain 2000 is like the opposite of any of those: it’s a snowboard or ski racing game that is a pure racing game, not a stunt game. There is only a very minimal stunt component here. Instead, you ski or snowboard down each of a series of slopes, trying to complete it as quickly as you can. The sense of speed is good and the controls work quite well once you figure them out. The visuals are bland but the fast gameplay and courses that feel like real mountains make this a really good game in my opinion. See my opinion summary for more. I may be the only person who thinks this is a great game, but I do. The game is my favorite skiing or snowboarding game of its generation, seriously.
The other skiing or snowboarding games are a mixed bag. Twisted Edge: Extreme Snowboarding is from Boss Games, a great N64 racing game developer, but of their four N64 games this is the weakest one. It’s too bad that the game released the same year as 1080, because it’s not even close to it in quality. It’s still decent, but bland. PenPen TriIceLon is a very simple and weird, mostly kid-friendly snow racing game. It is short and entertaining for the limited time it lasts. Each race has three parts, with a running section, a swimming one, and a sliding one. Cool Boarders 3 saw that series change developers. The first two were by Japanese UEP Systems, but the third game was developed by American team Idol Minds. It plays a lot like the second game but with better graphics but blander gameplay. I have not played it but while I know these games were popular I really hated every CoolBoarders game I have ever played, including my pick for one of the worst Dreamcast games, UEP’s Rippin Riders (Dreamcast, 1999), so I doubt I’d think any better of this one, but I guess you never know; it is a different team. Snow Break looks very bland, a playable but probably mediocre experience. Skiing 1999 Edition is the second skiing game from Sierra, following Front Page Sports: Ski Racing (PC, 1997). It tries to be a sim-style game like the first one, so you race down real mountains and must make every gate or you’re out. Much like the first one the game is slow and frustrating. I want to like these games but don’t, and nor do the few reviews the series got. I love that it is purely a racing game and isn’t also a stunt game, but the racing just isn’t as good as it should be.
Racing – Arcade-style Unrealistic Modern Racing
Note: I am going to leave out arcade games from this category and focus on home exclusives. Daytona USA 2 would otherwise be in the top five and Sega Rally 2 and California Speed also mentioned.
Top List: Speed Busters: American Highways (PC, later DC as Speed Devils), Need for Speed III: High Stakes (PC/PS1), R4: Ridge Racer Type 4 (PS1), Rush 2: Extreme Racing USA (N64), Top Gear Overdrive (N64).
Honorable Mentions: Ultim@te Race Pro (PC), or perhaps Test Drive 5 (PC/PS1), maybe.
Bad: Test Drive Off-Road 2 (PC/PS1). Hard Truck (PC) is also poor, though its sequel would be important; more on that in the Simulation genre.
On the PC, Ubisoft’s Speed Busters really surprised me, I wasn’t expecting it to be better than NFS, but it is. Great game! It’s too bad it didn’t become a franchise apart from its two Dreamcast versions. It’s a somewhat over-the-top game with a ridiculous FMV intro and tracks with settings across America as seen by its French developer. Some have obstacles to avoid, such as dinosaurs around Hollywood. The main mechanic is a turbo meter you have to manage. Moving on, the PC version of NFS3 is a very good game with nice graphics that hold up well, good controls, and classic supercar racing action. It has a simple mostly single race based single player mode. The problem with it is that the PC version of NFS4: High Stakes contains all of its content plus a lot more. Yes, the NFS3 tracks are unlockable in PC NFSHS, though not on the PS1. If you’re going to play one of those games today High Stakes for PC is the obvious choice. Still, Hot Pursuit is simpler and is straightforward fun, unlike the sometimes brutal campaign mode in High Stakes, so both have a place I guess.
As for the console games, R4 is surely the most popular game on this list but I don’t love it as much as some. It’s good though. I covered it in the previous article. Top Gear Overdrive is very fast and plays great, in some ways it might be the most solid of the four N64 Top Gear games. It was one of the first N64 games with Expansion Pak support. Its developer, Snowblind, would go on to make one more N64 Top Gear game and then changed genres and made the popular action-RPG Baldur’s Gate: Dark Alliance (PS2, 2001; GC/Xbox 2002). As for Rush 2, it is interesting. The graphics are about even with the first N64 game from the previous year. The game was one of Atari Games’ few home console exclusives. It’s like Rush 1 for N64 but with bigger, longer tracks. I think the tracks are probably a bit too long and are less thrill-focused than the tracks for the arcade games are, but it is a home-only release so the different design style makes sense. I like it less than the other two N64 Rush games but it’s still a really fantastic game; I do love this series after all. The PS1 version of NFS3: Hot Pursuit is fine enough but not as good as the PC game, or the three other console games I just mentioned. For the hardware it’s good but EA didn’t try to have the PC games work perfectly on console, they are downgraded a bit to fit the system.
Returning to the PC, Ultim@te Race Pro, from Kalisto, is a game I got in late ’98, bundled with my 3DFX card. It has very skiddy controls designed for powersliding and nice graphics. The handling isn’t as perfect as the Sega games it wants to be, and there are only four actual tracks and no championship mode, only single races, so it will only keep you coming back if you want to improve your times, but it’s solid. I think Kallisto’s third-person action games were awful — think The Fifth Element (PS1) or Nightmare Creatures (PS1 1997; N64 1998) — but they were at least average at making racing games. It’s too bad they didn’t make more of them. Lastly, Test Drive 5 is a simple and somewhat average game focused on longer point-to-point races as all prior Test Drive games were, but it’s fun. Test Drives 4, 5, and 6 are all by the same studio and are very similar. They are bland but, I would say, fine. They all got poor reviews but may be entertaining if you like simple point-to-point racing. Test Drive Off-Road 2 (PC/PS1) is awful, just as its predecessor is, but the main series isn’t so bad. Critics agreed — TD5 scored a 70% average, while TDOR2 got a 54%. That sounds about right.
Racing – Kart Racing
Top List: S.C.A.R.S. (PS1/N64/PC), Penny Racers [aka Choro-Q 64] (N64; JP ’98, West ’99), Choro-Q Park (SAT; JP only), Choro-Q 3 (PS1; JP only), Bomberman Fantasy Race (PS1; JP ’98, West ’99).
Perhaps Also: Doraemon Kart (GB).
Another Cross-Genre Mention: Plane Crazy (PC/PS1).
Special Mention: Snowboard Kids (N64; 1997 JP, 1998 US/EU) released in the West this year. Additionally the PC version of Sonic R (Saturn 1997) released in ’98.
The kart racing genre was somewhat weak in 1998, so much so that perhaps it should be in the ‘weak genres’ tier in part two. SCARS is a decent game, but it’s nothing special so perhaps it should be there. As an aside, SCARS goes here as well as in futuristic, it is both things. For the most part 1998 was a year where people continued to play Mario Kart 64 or Diddy Kong Racing on their N64s if they had one. Beyond SCARS, the main event in the genre this year was a pile of Choro Q games, known as Penny Racers in the West. There were different versions on each platform of the Playstation, Saturn, and Nintendo 64, plus plane and boat spinoffs on the PS1 as well. All three main games are similar and have similar visuals, but each has its own tracks and content, they are not the same. I am not sure which is best so I put the one I have played, the one US-released one, in first. The series’ multiplayer focus certainly is easier to engage with on N64 than PS1 or Saturn so I think this makes sense. Regardless, Choro-Q games are kart racing based, but they are not straight Mario Kart clones, there is less of an emphasis on items and more on drifting.
The only other kart racer of any note I can find from ’98 is Bomberman Fantasy Race (PS1), which is Hudson’s thoroughly mediocre attempt to bring Bomberman to every popular genre they could. I guess maybe the linescroll/kart hybrid Doraemon Kart (GB) (JP only) also could be mentioned in that tier. Kart racers almost could be in the ‘genres that weren’t good in ’98’ list, though enough people like SCARS that I chose to not put it in there.
Additionally, they are a different subgenre, but futuristic combat racers like Extreme-G 2 and Wipeout 64 have weapon systems as well. So does Plane Crazy, which plays a bit like a flying kart racer as well, with a weapon system and everything. If we combine the categories this genre is looking better.
As a note, the pretty good kart-style snowboard racing game from Hudson, Snowboard Kids (N64, 1997 JP, 1998 US), released here in early ’98. It wins this category by a lot if you include it, but it did release in Japan in late ’97. Its sequel from early ’99 is even better. Sonic R for PC might even finish second in this category if we counted it; it’s a very odd game but is at least somewhat interesting, with its open stages designed for you to explore while you race and absurd soundtrack. Just make sure to get the first PC release if you pick this one up for PC; the later Sonic R / Sonic 3D Blast dual-pack release removes all of the music from the disc, which is very disappointing. Sadly that is the version I have.
Racing – Air or Boat Racing
Top List: Plane Crazy (PC/PS1), Air Racing (PC; Microsoft Flight Simulator 95/98 third party expansion), Aero Gauge (N64), Choro-Q Marine: Q-Boat (PS1; JP only), VR Sports Powerboat Racing (PS1/PC).
Note, the middle title is a sim, but I listed it here because it’s an air racing game. Neither of the standalone games here are incredible, but they are both a fun time for this somewhat different subgenre. Plane Crazy for PC is one of the best arcadey plane racing games ever. It’s a pretty fun game and is the highlight here by far. Aero Gauge is a futuristic flight racing game so it’s really in both of those categories, but while decent the game has some issues. See my old summary of it for more on that one. As for VR Sports Powerboat Racing, some people like this game and it got decently mediocre reviews, but I really disliked it. I have only played the PS1 version so perhaps it’s better on PC, but on console I hate the controls and gameplay of this title, skip this mess! The graphics are poor also, and don’t expect many waves. Wave Race 64 (N64, 1996) this definitely is not.
Racing: Topdown Racing or Overhead-ish Racing and/or Combat
Top List: Vangers (PC), Circuit Breakers (PS1), The Shutoku Battle (GB/C; JP only).
Not So Good: Team Losi RC Racer [aka Buggy in EU] (PS1).
Special Mention: Grand Theft Auto (PC/PS1), which released in Europe in ’97 and the rest of the world in ’98.
This subgenre doesn’t have much in ’98, and two of the four games I have mentioned have cameras that really are behind-the-vehicle so they probably should be in the above category and not this one. Even so, the few overhead racers here are mostly good. GTA is one of the very early action games set in a single large space, not multiple maps. It has most of the chaos of its later 3d sequels, though simplified a bit because of the top-down perspective. The game isn’t exactly a 1998 release but it needs a mention, I am American.
On Vangers, it is also an overhead driving/shooter. Those who know this insane trip of a game know why it must be mentioned here. The game is a crazy, open world driving combat adventure in a future where people are all human-bug hybrids. The world is broken up into maps and isn’t one single space, but still, it’s quite a unique title. It’s from a Russian team and uses voxel graphics. It’s a must-check-out title for any purveyor of the weird.
Circuit Breakers and Team Losi RC Racer both have behind-the-vehicle perspectives, but pulled slightly back to show more forward area of the track than you would see from a straight behind view, so I’m including them here. It’s borderline so feel free to disagree if you want. Both play more like an overhead game, an RC car game for Team Losi or a Micro Machines game for Circuit Breakers, so in terms of gameplay I think they fit here. Circuit Breakers is from the developer of some Micro Machines games and teh connection shows. It’s a decent to good game that is little-mentioned today. Team Losi is much less good; that’s a subpar game for sure. It is a basic checkpoint racer. The only other topdown racer I’ve found from ’98 is The Shutoku Battle (The Highway Battle) (GBC) (JP Only), an obscure early GBC game only released in Japan. It looks pretty solid, could be a fun one. It’s a highway racing game in the style of the Tokyo Xtreme Racer series for DC, or others.
Worst Retail Racing Game of 1998: Probably Test Drive Off-Road 2 (PC/PS1). The first TDOR was a pretty bad game that unfortunately I did own in the ’90s from a compilation. Sadly the second game does not improve things much. Of all ’98 racers with a MobyScore this is the lowest and I completely understand why. Team Losi RC Racer and, I would say, VR Powerboat Racing are also poor quality.
My 1998 Racing Games Top Five: F-Zero X (N64), Wipeout 64 (N64), Moto Racer 2 (PC), Extreme-G 2 (PC), and… well, there’s a four-way tie for fifth between Rush 2: Extreme Racing USA (N64), Big Mountain 2000 (N64), Road Rash 3-D (PS1), and PowerSlide (PC). They all score exactly the same. It is very hard to pick one but I think I’ll go with Powerslide.
Role-Playing Games – RPGs
RPGs – Traditional – Turn-Based, Pausable Realtime, or similar
This category does ot include anything with action combat unless it is pausable.
Top List: Baldur’s Gate (PC), Xenogears (PS1), Pokemon Yellow (GB) (JP ’98, US ’99), Panzer Dragoon Saga (SAT), Might & Magic VI: The Mandate of Heaven (PC).
Honorable Mentions: Suikoden II (PS1; JP release, US ’99), Fallout 2 (PC)
Other Noteworthy RPGs Released in Japan in 1998: Legend of Legaia (PS1; JP release, US ’99), Thousand Arms (PS1; JP release, US ’99), Dragon Quest Monsters (GB/GBC; JP release, US 2000 as Dragon Warrior Monsters), Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure (PS1; JP release, US 2000), Jade Coccoon: Story of the Tamamayu (PS1; JP release; US 1999), Elie no Atelier: Salberg no Renkinjutsushi 2 (PS1; JP only, the second game in the still-ongoing Atelier franchise), Black/Matrix (PS1/SAT, JP only); Madou Monogatari (SAT; JP only, note that this is entirely different from earlier titles of the same name in this Puyo Puyo-adjacent RPG series starring Arle), Grandia Digital Museum (SAT, JP only) [this is a dungeon pack expansion of sorts for one of 1997’s best RPGs, Grandia, it has no story], Lunar 2: Eternal Blue Complete [remake of a 1995 Sega CD game] (SAT ver., JP only; US got the PS1 ver. in ’99 as did Japan). Of these, Legend of Legaia is probably the best known, or Lunar 2 Complete. The original Lunar 2 for Sega CD is one of my favorite RPGs ever, but I don’t love this remake quite as much as the original.
Japanese RPGs from 1998 with Roguelike elements: Baroque (SAT; JP only, was ported to PS1 in ’99 with added features, only Western release is of the PS2/Wii remake. This first person game has action combat but pauses when you open the item menu so you could call it an action-RPG, but because of the pausing I put it here.), Chocobo’s Dungeon 2 (PS1; JP release, US ’99), Waku Waku Puyo Puyo Dungeon (SAT; JP only), PoPoRoGue (PS1; JP only, this is in the PoPoLoCrois series)
Some More Japanese RPGs of ’98 of lesser note: Robopon: Sun & Star Versions (GB/C; JP release, US 2000 for Sun version only; Pokemon clone), End Sector (JP only; card battle RPG), Seventh Cross: Evolution (DC; JP release, US 2000), Slayers Wonderful (PS1; JP only), Makeruna! Makendou Z (PCFX; JP only), Twinbee RPG (PS1; JP only), Quest 64 (N64; US release, JP ’99 with some bugfixes), and many more. The RPG genre was still absolutely massive at this time in Japan.
Korean RPGs of ’98: Rhapsody of Zephyr (PC; Asia only, there was a a later DC port that was JP only).
Other noteworthy American RPGs of 1998: Return to Krondor (PC), Blades of Exile (PC; fourth game in the Exile/Avernum series). Most other Western RPGs had action combat.
Special Mention: Pokemon Red/Blue (GB), which released in Japan in 1996 but the US in ’98. Yellow did release first in ’98, which is why it goes in the above main list despite probably being less beloved than the base Red or Blue versions. Additionally, Final Fantasy VII (PC) released in 1998, a PC port of the ’97 PS1 classic. I am mostly not mentioning ports here but this was very popular and won some awards so here it is.
Analysis by Region: In 1998, the RPG was one of the most popular genres in Japan and had been since the later ’80s. The variety and depth of Japan’s RPG releases that year are truly impressive. There may not have been a main-series release in the two most prominent RPG series, Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest, but there were more than enough major releases to say that yes, 1998 was one of the best years ever for JRPGs. Panzer Dragoon Saga, Xenogears, Pokemon Yellow, Suikoden II, Legend of Legaia, Jade Coccoon, Madou Monogatari, Atelier Elie, Thousand Arms, and so so many more? Yeah, it’s a top tier elite list for sure. Xenogears started a major ongoing RPG franchise, Suikoden II is the most popular game in its series by a good margin, there were many standalone and licensed RPGs by developers of all competency levels… for JRPG fans it doesn’t get better than the ’90s. The genre would fade in popularity in the mid to later ’00s, as budgets got to be too much for the declining size of the Japanese home market, but in ’98 numerous top-tier RPGs released in Japan. Many of them either never released in the US or released here later, but that was how it was back then. Oh, a note, there were also some all-time-great Japanese RPGs with action combat, but I will cover them below in the Action-RPG genre.
Meanwhile, in the US, there were many fewer total releases, but the quality of the ones that were released was very high. American RPGs were in a popularity renaissance led by publisher Interplay. Starting with ’97’s Fallout and Ultima Online and continuing with ’98’s Baldur’s Gate, PC RPGs were reacing probably their all-time popularity peak in the US. It would only a be a few years before the MMO genre mostly consumed PC RPGs, but in the interim there were both MMO and traditional RPG releases. Europe, however, really had not caught the RPG bug yet. European devs had made the occasional RPG earlier on, but they did not have any great ones in ’98. The only one of any note I can find is Brany Skeldalu [Gates of Skeldal] (PC; EU only then, only released in Czech at the time), a first-person ‘blobber’, still a popular subgenre. Baldur’s Gate would show Western developers the way forward for overhead RPGs, and in following years there would be some European games inspired by it. Oh, there a few decent European action-RPGs, not on this list.
Summary: Looking at all all RPGs from 1998, as is true for so many of these genres, you have a top four here of games that stand against any in the genre from any time, some other important titles that aren’t better than anything from other years, but help suppliment the list, and plenty of lesser titles only here because I am trying to be somewhat thorough without mentioning absolutely everything. The most important thing to happen in RPGs in 1998 by far was the Western release of Pokemon. Pokemon Red, Green, and Blue originally released in Japan in 1996, so it doesn’t qualify for the main list, but as I said above Pokemon Yellow did release there in ’98, so I can include that. Red & Blue must be mentioned for their worldwide impact, though; this list would look quite incomplete without the year’s biggest new hit franchise. I’ve never been a Pokemon fan but there clearly are reasons it spawned a megahit franchise that remains one of gaming’s biggest to this day.
As for the others, Baldur’s Gate, Xenogears, and Panzer Dragoon Saga were covered in the first article in detail. Baldur’s Gate 1 is an amazing game which set off a Western RPG renaissance after some down years, and has what I think of as the best RPG strategic combat engine ever. Its sequel from 2000 is even better, but the first has a lot going for it as well — the first game is more open-ended, the second more streamlined. Xenogears is a story-heavy game with one of the most interesting and in-depth stories seen in an RPG up to that point, and which started an ongoing franchise. Panzer Dragoon Saga is one of the genre’s most beloved titles among the few who have played it. I need to play it sometime, but that price… ack. M&M VI: The Mandate of Heaven is a first person RPG with pauseable action combat. It has a large open world, probably the largest of any game released this year, and brought its classic series into the modern era. It was a noteworthy title at the time that some still love. After ’98 publisher 3DO started cutting budgets and reusing engines a lot, but M&M VI released before that. Its engine would be used in the next few games in the series before it ended around 3DO’s bankruptcy. Lastly, Fallout 2 isn’t the iconic classic that the first one was due to some key staff leaving, but it is still impressive. It has a larger map with more areas than the first game and is much more open-ended. It is a big, sprawling game filed with sidequests and various things to do.
I am not going to cover all of the Japanese RPGs I listed above in detail, because these are complex games that I largely have not played myself, but I will note that some are games I previously covered with opinion summaries on my site, including End Sector, Jade Coccoon, Legend of Legaia, Slayers Wonderful, and others. As for Quest 64, it may be infamously bad, but on the other hand, it sold well and is well known so I have to mention it. It may be a too-streamlined game with many issues but the battle system is good and the world interesting to explore if you can survive the tedium of constant random battles. The game has a definite fanbase today too.
I would like to discuss the other major American RPG of ’98, Return to Krondor (PC). This is the third and final RPG in its style made by Sierra. It is a polygonal 3d, story-focused RPG with largely linear progression. The game doesn’t reach the heights of the exceptional first one, 1993’s Betrayal at Krondor, but it’s still a good game which aimed high. The story is particularly acclaimed, which makes sense considering that fantasy writer Raymond E. Feist wrote it. It was Sierra’s last attempt at a 3d turn-based RPG; the only one they published after this was Arcanum, which is an overhead 2d game more like Baldur’s Gate made by an outside team. Another end of the road here for a significant franchise.
RPG – Action-RPG
Action-RPGs are games with RPG-like level and stat systems, but the combat is active instead of pausable or fully turn-based. As a result action skill matters as well as thought and preplanning. I consider any RPG with action combat an Action-RPG for the purposes of this list. Action games with RPG style stat systems may also count here, though in 1998 RPG mechanics had not invaded almost every single kind of game as they have now.
Top List: Star Ocean: The Second Story (PS1, JP release – US ’99), Gauntlet Legends (ARC; home ports would release in ’99-’00), Quest for Glory V: Dragon Fire (PC), Parasite Eve (PS1), Brave Fencer Musashi (PS1).
Honorable Mentions: King’s Quest 8: Mask of Eternity (PC), Shadow Tower (PS1) (JP ’98, US ’99). Note, I also put KQ: Mask of Eternity in Action-Adventure, but it does have an RPG level system so it belongs here. See that section for more on this game.
Some other Action-RPGs: Dink Smallwood (PC; retail release only in EU, US was mail order only, made freeware in 1999), Hexplore (PC), Rage of Mages (PC), Get Medieval (PC)
Low review average Diablo clones: Cybermercs: The Soldiers of The 22nd Century (PC), Ancient Evil (PC), Lamentation Sword (PC; Korea only, released in the US in 1999 as Akuma: Demon Spawn).
The headline title here is the first one, Star Ocean 2, a sci-fi/fantasy hybrid RPG with a traditional JRPG-style world but action battles, is the best game in its series and is my pick for the greatest action-combat Japanese-style RPG ever. The rest of these games are good too, but that one is the elite, must-play title. I also really love Gauntlet Legends, it is a fantastic game and one of my favorite action-RPGs ever. I played a whole lot of it in arcades, N64, and more. This is a simple but brilliant game. You explore levels, attack enemies with your shots, and look for secrets. It is an incredibly fun and addictive game, it’s a real shame there isn’t really anything like it today. The later home ports are also good, the Nintendo 64 version particularly, but the arcade original is outstanding. The Dreamcast version is the most similar to the arcade; the N64 version changes things.
Shadow Tower is a FromSoft game and basically is a creepier, more horror-ish spinoff of King’s Field, From’s predecessor to the Dark Souls series. Expect slow-paced and quite challenging first person action combat with RPG stat-building as you kill enemies and pretty wild and creepy monster designs. Shadow Tower is a darker, more horror-styled take on King’s Field, a slow, deliberate, and very difficult first-person action-RPG that is as divisive as any other title in its somewhat unpopular franchise. Its creepy monster designs would be highly influential to Dark Souls. This is probably not a ‘peak’ game, the later King’s Field and Shadow Tower games are generally ranked above this one never mind the megahit Souls subgenre they would create ten years later, but it was an improvement over the two previous King’s Field games and is an important game in the FromSoft canon particularly for its monster designs. Dark Souls’ creepy, dark fantasy aesthetic owes a lot to Shadow Tower.
Quest for Glory V was yet another endpoint in 1998, the last game in a classic series that I love. It is an adventure-RPG hybrid. I like this game, but I think it was a downgrade in most ways from the engine that ran III, IV, and the I remake. QfGV has polygonal characters and prerendered worlds with a pulled-back camera. While in previous games battles were on a separate screen with action-style one one one fights, now you fight in the overworld as in any other hack and slash action-RPG. As a result combat is a bit like Diablo here. I get why they did this, but it makes the game feel less unique. Also, the story is solid and graphics are nice, but in the rush to release it features such as multiplayer and alternate playable characters were cut from the game. Even so, it’s a good game with decent combat and some fun adventure elements such as great writing and humor. QFGV is by now certainly an under-rated game few pay much attention to now, but even if it’s not one of the greatest games ever like QFGIV is, it’s still good. (Quest for Glory IV: Shadows of Darkness is my favorite game published by Sierra.)
As for the others, Brave Fencer Musashi is basically an action-RPG with platformer elements. It’s good, though Square’s 1999 title Threads of Fate is kind of a better version of the idea. Parasite Eve is a popular and well-made game with nice graphics, some fun action, and a quite insane story. I’m probably ranking it a bit lower than many would, the story is a bit too horror-adjacent to really interest me, but it is a good game and I did enjoy most of what I played of it. Lastly, Bomberman Quest is a somewhat Zelda-ish Bomberman game with a world to explore, people to talk to, and more. It’s a strange hybrid that actuallly works well.
The titles in the lesser tier are all C and D grade games by their Mobygames averages. These games all have overhead cameras. And yes, all of them have review averages lower than Bomberman Quest, I checked. Dink Smallwood is a top-down Zelda style indie game from a few British guys. It’s a fun action-adventure RPG that isn’t amazing but was popular at the time. It was made freeware in 1999, after the retail copies they had produced sold. It has level editors, a fan community, and an HD remake. Rage of Mages and Hexplore both have some clear RTS influence in their interfaces and presentation. Rage of Mages is a strategy/RPG hybrid from Russia. This game feels kind of like a units-only RTS, but you control only a small party and have full stats and levels and such. The camera is static, but the game does have 3d rolling terrain, which is nice. It’s somewhat average but fun. Hexplore is a bit like Diablo mixed with a bit of a units-only RTS feeling, as there is a minimap and your units say something every time you click to move. The gampeplay is simple but entertaining. It has a voxel world and you can rotate the camera around in a circle freely, which is rare for ’98. Sadly its French developer got stuck making only licensed games after this one. Get Medieval is a classic top-down Gauntlet clone by Monolith. It may have a poor review average, but as a huge Gauntlet fan I would say it’s an under-rated game. Gauntlet is fantastic and needs more clones like this one! I should make it clear, though, Get Medieval plays like the classic Gauntlet games, not the new full 3d of Gauntlet Legends. This is a simple overhead 2d game where you explore dungeons and fight monsters. The games’ attempts at being sexy and humorous don’t really land well, but I think the gameplay does. I do wish that it didn’t have Gauntlet’s always-decreasing health but instead ditched that like the home versions of Gauntlet Legends would, but ah well, Get Medieval is fun anyway.
The titles in that last category — Cybermercs, Ancient Evil, and Lamentation Sword — are all ones I have not played, but have gameplay clearly heavily inspired by Diablo. Diablo fans may want to give some of them a try.
Biggest RPG Debacle of 1998: Descent to Undermountain (PC). This badly broken game had a great idea — how about we take the Decent engine and make a dungeon-crawler RPG out of it? — but the engine was very difficult to make an RPG work in and the team struggled badly with the game. Ultimately the game released badly buggy and broken, and most of the bugs were never fixed. It’s pretty sad. There is a potentially interesting dungeon adventure here but it would have needed to have the bugs and crashes fixed to be really worth the effort, and they are not fixed so it isn’t.
RPG – Action-RPG – Soulslike
I guess I should put this here, because whether Soulslikes are actually their own genre or simply a subset of action-RPGs with similar design is apparently controversial, as neither GameFAQs or Mobygames list ‘Soulslike’ as a genre descriptor. Anyway, the Soulslike genre was created in 2009. The Soulslike genre of very difficult, slow-paced third person open-world hack and slash action-adventure or action-RPG games with precise timing required to stay alive did not exist yet in 1998, so it, obviously, did not have the best year… except it kind of did. You see, without 1998 the Soulslike may never HAVE existed, because two releases this year would, ten years later, be probably the primary influences towards the style and gameplay of FromSoft’s seminal hit Demon’s Souls (PS3, 2009), and thus the creation of the genre. Demon’s Souls is effectively one part King’s Field (PS1, 1995), and one part The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time (N64). Or, to mention two 1998 games, Demon’s Souls is a hybrid of Shadow Tower (PS1) (JP release; US ’99) and Ocarina of Time, as Shadow Tower’s dark tone and experience system where you gain stats immediately as you kill foes are more Soulslike.
King’s Field and Shadow Tower may be Dark Souls’ predecessor franchise in style and aesthetic, but in gameplay Soulslikes own more to Ocarina of Time. That game changed gaming forever, and nowhere is that more apparent than when you compare Shadow Tower to Demon’s Souls or Dark Souls. The Souls game formula essentially takes a much more challenging version of Ocarina of Time’s lock-on combat system and combat and pairs it with Shadow Tower’s grim aesthetic, brutal difficulty, single open map, and slower pace.
I shouldn’t even need to say it, but The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time does hold up well. People who play the game for the first time now like it, I have seen enough such impressions to know that. However, its moderate-at-best difficulty isn’t going to challenge a Souls fan much. And on the other hand, Shadow Tower is a well-made King’s Field game, but few of even the most dedicated Dark Souls fans enjoy the King’s Field or Shadow Tower games; the combat is just so slow and simple, it is very much an acquired taste. Sure, they may love the style and aesthetic, but the gameplay? Without the Zelda influence people like it a lot less. So, are Soulslikes a weak genre in ’98, or should we count the probable best game ever, Ocarina of Time, to be a proto-Soulslike and thus rank it higher? You, the reader, can decide that one; it’s a tough one isn’t it. I split the difference in the first article by putting it in the ‘still developing’ category.
RPG – Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game, or MMORPG
Top List: EverQuest (PC; beta tests leading up to its release in 1999), Ultima Online: The Second Age (PC; first expansion pack for this game from ’97), Lineage: The Blood Pledge (PC, South Korean release; US 2001), Underlight (PC; digital-only release).
This genre was high on the weak points list because while all of these games are noteworthy, Ultima Online had released the previous year and EverQuest wasn’t actually released until March 1999. There are only a few MMOs released in 1998, and while they are significant, in terms of quality the genre was very much a work in progress. The most popular MMO of the time was Ultima Online (1997), and it had its first expansion in 1998. Overseas, Lineage released in South Korea in 1998. Both of these games have overhead perspectives, not third person. Lineage plays somewhat like Diablo but as a grind-heavy MMO. It was a huge megahit in Korea, selling many millions of copies, but didn’t do well here, though that it didn’t release in the US until 2001 certainly didn’t help. By the time it released here EverQuest and Diablo II were out. And last but definitely not least, the most important MMO “release” of 1998 was the beta tests for 1999’s genre-redefining classic, EverQuest. EverQuest is the game which defines the third person MMO genre’s design expectations, World of Warcraft for instance was heavily inspired by it. The game wasn’t done yet in 1998, but open or semi-open betas for MMOs kind of count as a release in my eyes; I have always thought of Guild Wars as a 2004 release since its public betas began that year, for instance, even though the final release would not be until 2005. That was in open beta instead of limited access beta as EQ was, but still, it at least kind of counts.
As for that last game, Underlight is a very weird little game which never had a physical release. It has Doom-style graphics, dated for the time. Possibly inspired by digital chatroom with some MMO elements things like Sierra’s The Realm (PC, 1996), the title is entirely player-run. You can’t even get quests or level up without other human players helping you out with that, and are expected to role-play your character at all times as well. While never at all popular somehow it carved out enough of a niche to still exist, you can get it for free on Steam today.
RPG Subgenres – best game in each subgenre on GameFAQs
- Action-RPG – Star Ocean: The Second Story
- General – The usual category for games nobody has put in their subgenre.
- Japanese-style – Panzer Dragoon Saga (or Xenogears)
- Massively Multiplayer – Ultima Online: The Second Age
- Roguelike – I’m not sure, none are serious standouts. The best by reviews might actually be Chocobo’s Dungeon 2. Baroque also has some fans, it is probably second.
- Trainer – Pokemon Yellow
- Western-style – Baldur’s Gate
Simulation
The simulation genre is a weird one. More so than probably any other of the major genres excluding Miscelaneous, the genre name alone doesn’t really tell you all that much about the game apart from that it tries to simulate something. Beyond that, you need the subgenre to understand what kind of game it is.
Additionally, for some simulation games, whether this should be their primary genre or not is debated. For example, GameFAQs lists city-building games in the Strategy – Management genre. I’m not sure why they do this but they traditionally always were put in Simulation, so that is what I will do here. Wikipedia correctly lists them as Simulation games; Mobygames splits the difference by listing both genres on city-building games.
So what will I do? Well, put them here of course.
Simulation – Management – Building/Government
or Management/Business
I am combining these two subgenres because they are very similar. It would make no sense to separate them.
Top List: Anno 1602 (PC), Caesar III (PC), Railroad Tycoon II (PC, later DC), The Settlers III (PC), Harvest Moon GBC (GBC; JP ’98, US ’99; this is a colorized rerelease of Harvest Moon GB (GB, JP ’97, US ’98), not a new game), Yoot Tower (PC/Mac).
Honorable Mentions: SimSafari (PC/Mac), Bundesliga Manager 98 (PC; EU only).
Before I begin though, this genre for ’98 lies in the shadow of a game that wasn’t finished that year, SimCity 3000. Originally scheduled for release in 1998, to the point that the boxes and manuals are dated to ’98, it wasn’t quite done and Maxis’ third entry in the genre-defining series did not release until February ’99. We got the game that year and enjoyed it. It is an iterative sequel to SimCity 2000, so it does not take the game-changing risks that SC2k did and I was a bit disappointed because of that, but it is a solid iterative sequel adding more systems and features and nice upgraded graphics to the game. Unfortunately, it didn’t release in ’98.
There really are only a few definitely noteworthy games for this genre this year but all of the top three or four are important titles. Anno is particularly important since it started the series that would come to define this subgenre, and also for taking The Settlers’ place at the lead of the dense Eurogame resource and trading-heavy game category. The Settlers also had a release this year, The Settlers III, but in retrospect it was eclipsed by Anno 1602. When I think of a complex economic-focused strategy game with lots of resources to collect and trade, complicated economic tech trees, worker placement, and such, that quintessential European-style economics-focused strategy game, my first thought to describe it is ‘like The Settlers’, but I imagine most people would find ‘like Anno’ much more familiar. And the first Anno game is quite good.
Railroad Tycoon II is one of the most successful transportation sim games ever. Either this or A-Train (PC and others, early 1990s) are surely the best known railroad sim games, but that game is older. Railroad Tycoon II sold great and won awards. And last but not least, Yoot Tower is the sequel to SimTower (PC/others, 1994), a great but perhaps a bit too simple classic game that we got in the mid ’90s. It is very similar to the first one in both graphics and gameplay, so expect fun but somewhat easy building and management of a 2d side view skyscraper.
Now, why haven’t I mentioned Harvest Moon GBC? After all, Harvest Moon is an incredibly influential game, it invented the farming sim/RPG genre, and this is a solid early entry in the franchise. The farming of the console games is here, but the romantic side plots aren’t in this version. Regardless, while the GBC version is a quality title, it is just a colorized version of the previous years’ black & white game, Harvest Moon GB (GB, 1997), and also it is the first of three GBC Harvest Moon games, each with more features than the last. As a result of that, while good, this game isn’t as noteworthy as the other titles.
As for the honorable mentions, SimSafari was Maxis’ last spinoff Sim game, the last of many SimSomething titles that released through the ’90s that were made by Maxis itself. This one is the third of a subseries of kid-focused titles, following SimTown (PC, 1995), which we got at the time for my younger sister and is solidly made for younger kids but I found too basic to hold my interest for long; SimPark (PC, 1996) which is a simple park-builder; and this one, which plays like SimPark but is set in Africa. Lastly the Bundesliga Manager game is a German soccer team management simulation. They are popular in Europe. The best-known series in this genre is Championship Manager, but unfortunately it did not have an entry in ’98; Championship Manager 3 released in March ’99.
Simulation – Vehicular – Flight, Tank, or Underwater
Next are the flight, tank, and underwater simulation games. This genre is also difficult to define, however, as while it is easy to say that the more serious simulators all go in this genre, what about more arcadey sim-light titles? Should Incoming (PC/DC), Rogue Squadron (N64/PC), Descent: FreeSpace (PC), and Falcon 4.0 (PC) all go in the same genre, or not? The line between action flight game and simulation flight game is somewhat arbitrary, and you will get different answers on different sites for anything anywhere near that line. There clearly is no ‘correct’ answer here. I will start with the part that is certainly in this genre, serious vehicular combat simulations.
Top List: Falcon 4.0 (PC), M1 Tank Platoon II (PC), Jane’s WWII Fighters (PC), F-22: Total Air War (PC), Jane’s IAF: Israeli Air Force, Jane’s F-15, Red Baron 3-D (PC).
Honorable Mentions: Microsoft Combat Flight Simulator: WWII Europe Series (PC), European Air War (PC), Pro Pilot ’99 (PC).
Also perhaps of note: F-16 Multirole Fighter (PC), MiG-29 Fulcrum (PC), WarBirds (PC).
Note: F-22: Total Air War is an enhanced sequel/update for F-22: Air Dominance Fighter (PC, 1997). Red Baron 3-D is an enhanced version of Red Baron II (PC, 1997), fixing that games’ many faults. Pro Pilot ’99 is an iterative sequel to the previous years’ Pro Pilot ’98 (PC, 1997) as well.
It is tough for me to rank these; this isn’t a genre I have ever played much. Should I go by awards? European Air War won best flight sim from Gamespot, Falcon 4.0 from PC Gamer, if you look at the Mobygames rank Total Air War has the highest rating, followed by M1 Tank Platoon II… it’s hard to decide. I mostly went with the Mobyrank here, except putting Falcon 4.0 in first.
Before we begin, all titles in this subgenre were developed with the assumption that the player is using some kind of joystick. That is, a flightstick-style joystick at minimum, or a full HOTAS setup, with a large throttle alongside a fancier joystick loaded with buttons, if you want a more sim-ready setup. Some of these games are playable without a joystick, but I would not recommend it without at least a basic joystick like a Microsoft Sidewinder Precision Pro or something. In the ’90s and earlier joysticks were the most common form of game controller PC gamers had alongside their mouse and keyboard, gamepads were less common. Some flight action games at this point were getting away from joystick control, in favor of FPS-style mouse and keyboard controls or gamepad control, but these titles are not among them.
Based on overall quality, 1998 is probably the best year ever for the flight simulator genre. If you look at Mobygames’ rankings, six of the 29 flight simulation games that have an 8.0 or higher MobyScore are 1998 releases. No other year has more than three. However, at the same time, 1998 was near the end for the flight simulators’ reign as one of PC gaming’s most significant and important genres. It may be easy to forget this today, but racing sims and flight simulators were major, AAA-tier genres in the ’80s and ’90s on computers. But right around the turn of the millenium, vehicular combat games of all types faded in popularity. The big tank action game boom of the mid to late ’90s faded out around 2000, tank simulation games faded at the same time, there were no more big budget AAA flight combat simulation games after ’98 on par with 1998’s masterpiece Falcon 4.0, which was covered in the first article, and more. Remember what I said about MobyRank? Only one flight simulator from the past decade makes their list with an 8.0 average or higher, Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 (PC/Xbox One/Xbox Series, 2020). Yeah.
Falcon 4.0 launched with many issues, but its place as the last seriously hardcore realistic flight simulator with a big budget counts for a lot. In 1998 flight and tank games of all kinds, arcade or sim, were omnipresent, but just a few years later that would all change. The days of the large for the time budget survey sim, a game dedicated to accurate modeling of one type of vehicle, started to end here, with the many sims of 1998’s failure to sell as well as their publishers wanted. Anyway, that is Falcon 4.0: A brilliant work of genius that was the end of an era, and also a borderline untplayable game unless you want to actually learn how to fly an F-16. Play the modern updated fan version if you try it.
As for the specifics about the rest of these games, the most notable is M1 Tank Platoon II, a modern tank combat game. It it is one of the last tank-specific simulation games ever made. If you look at Mobygames’ rankings for tank simulation games, M1 Tank Platoon II is second place today, behind only Operation Flashpoint: Cold War Crisis (PC, 2001), a military sim with a bunch of controllable vehicles. There was also a pretty good tank sim the previous year, iM1A2 Abrams (PC, 1997), but M1 Tank Platoon II is better. There were a few other tank sims in ’98, but they are of much lower quality than this one.
The three Jane’s titles were all published by EA but each was developed by different teams. They are all highly regarded, though they aren’t the best Jane’s titles; that goes to the two Jane’s Longbow games, from 1996 and 1997.
Anyway, the main differentiating factor between the vehicular combat simulators of ’98 games is what time period they are set in. Red Baron 3-D (Sierra) is a World War I game; Jane’s WWII Fighters (EA), Microsoft Combat Flight Simulator: WWII Europe Series (Microsoft), and European Air War (MicroProse) are World War II games; M1 Tank Platoon II (MicroProse), Total Air War (Digital Image Design), Falcon 4.0 (MicroProse),Jane’s IAF (EA), and Jane’s F-15 (EA) are modern day; and Pro Pilot is a modern day civilian flight game. These are all quality titles, depending on which kind of flight you are the most interestied in, the more close-range dogfights of WWI and WWII or the longer-distance missile warfare of modern jet combat. Of all the kinds of combat simulators, the only thing missing from 1998’s library is underwater sims. There were no submarine sims in ’98, unfortunately. There was one underwater combat game but it’s more arcadey. Also, while there is that one civilian flight game, Pro Pilot is a bit weaker than the others on this list; it’s decent but not on par with Microsoft’s civilian flight offerints, but it is the only one released in 1998. Microsoft Flight Simulator ’98 (PC, 1997) released the previous year.
I listed the publishers above for a reason. What about the studios behind these games? Well, Digital Image Designs’ last game released in late 1998, a decent military action/strategy game called Wargasm (PC). Yes really. They were trying too hard to be ultra ’90s and it didn’t work. MicroProse, damaged by cofounder Sid Meier having left back in 1996 to found Firaxis, sold itself to Hasbro in late 1998, and Hasbro shut down both of its main studios less than a year later, cancelling their games in development. EA dropped the Jane’s license after the year 2000, and largely got out of flight simulators after that. Sierra of course was gutted in 1999, abandoning the genre then. Of these studios that leaves only Microsoft, who dropped the Combat Flight Simulator line after 2002 in favor of only occasional civilian flight games, though those are of very high quality.
Simulation – Space (Combat)
I listed the Miliary Space Sims with the Action Flight Combat games above, for completeness of these similar genres. As I said at length there, it is very hard to determine where the line between action and simulation is in this kind of game and sites do not agree. With that said:
Top List: Descent: FreeSpace (PC), Star Trek Starfleet Academy: Chekov’s Lost Missions (PC; expansion for 1997’s PC game Star Trek Starfleet Academy), Hardwar (PC).
Also Possibly of Note: Ares Rising (PC), Xenocracy (PC/PS1, EU only)
Great Action Space Flight Games: Star Wars: Rogue Squadron (PC/N64), Stellar Assault SS (SAT; JP only), and others; see the flight action category above for more.
Special Mention: I-War (PC; EU ’97, US ’98) won awards and is quite good but released in its first region in 1997 so it doesn’t count.
The list here is thin, but high quality. Descent: Freespace is one of the all-time great space simulation games. This game and its sequel, as I said in the flight action category they do not belong in, are some of the genres’ best ever that aren’t Star Wars games. The engine is so good that a recent mod uses the Freespace 2 engine to make a new Star Wars sim. It looks amazing.
The other titles are not on that level. Starfleet Academy: Chekov’s Lost Missions is an expansion with some more content for Interplay’s sim-lite flight action game from the previous year. This game is a lot like Wing Commander in terms of complexity, but it’s a fun time if you enjoy flying around and blasting Klingons and Romulans.
Of games that could be considered either a simulation or an action game depending on who you ask, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron (N64/PC) is the best, followed by Stellar Assault SS (SAT; JP only). Below that, Hardwar (PC), Xenocracy (PC/PS1, EU only), and Ares Rising (PC) certainly count. Hardwar in particular is interesting — it is an open-world flight combat and trading sim game set on a space colony planet. Those who like trading-and-combat games like Elite or Privateer should probably try this obscure title. Ares Rising and Xenocracy are more average looking space sims. I have not played them. Lastly, it is not a sci-fi game, but since I mentioned Rogue Squadron, perhaps I should put a mention of Buck Bumble (N64) here since its gameplay is somewhat similar, it’s just that you control a bee with a gun instead of a spaceship.
Simulation – Space (Civilian)
Top List: Battlecruiser 3000AD V2.0 (PC), Skybase / Space Station Simulator (PC)
Battlecruiser 3000AD is a very infamous game because the first version, Battlecruiser 3000AD (PC, 1996) was absurdly ambitious but very badly broken and buggy when it released. Also, designer Derek Smart is infamous for his internet flame wars against his haters. Even so, this second release from ’98 is much more stable and finished than the first version. This utterly unique series absolutely are combat games, but you can make what you want out of it, so putting it in a separate category from the above games makes sense. BC3000 is a battlecruiser space simulation title. You can wander around anywhere in the galaxy, fighting, trading, exploring, or more, with your battlecruiser and its crew and fighters. The simulation level is quite detailed as you control the various systems on the battlecruiser with mouse menus, as well as fllying in first person when you want. Later titles in the series, called Universal Combat, would add on-planet exploration and combat as well. I have always admired the ambition and scale of these games, but as someone who has never liked open world games, this title, just about the ultimate in open worlds, is unlikely to be my thing. I really should try either this version or Battlecruiser Millenium (PC, 2002) sometime though.
The other title here is actually pretty interesting looking — Skybase, or Space Station Simulator in Europe, allows you to assemble, explore, and spacewalk out of a space station like the then-in-planning International Space Station. This isn’t actually a game, but instead a digital edutainment tool where you click around and move through a space station point-to-point with Myst-style movement, but still it’s pretty cool. That you can assemble your own station, choosing which modules to connect in the way you want, is pretty great; that raises this above being just a pure educational title.
Simulation – Tank, Car, or Mech Vehicle Combat
Top List: M1 Tank Platoon II (PC), GunGriffon II (SAT, JP only), Interstate ’76: Nitro Pack (PC, expansion for the base game from 1997).
Okay but not as good: Spearhead (PC).
Poor: iPanzer ’44 (PC), Panzer Commander (PC).
RTS/Tank Hybrid Titles: These are not exactly simulation games but they kind of are, so I’ll mention them again: The three hybrid tank action/RTS games of 1998: Battlezone (1998) (PC), Urban Assault (PC), Uprising 2: Lead and Destroy (PC).
This is a separate category for ground vehicle sims only. I included the best ground vehicle sim, M1 Tank Platoon II, with the air combat sims above, but I will also highlight it here. It is probably the last great exclusively tank-focused military sim. Additionally I repeat Interstate ’76: Nitro Pack, which I mentioned before in the car combat action category. It is definitely at least part sim. The one and only third person mech sim of 1998 is GunGriffon II (SAT, JP only), which like most later Saturn releases stayed in Japan but is a good mech game, just like its predecessor which we did get. It’s a quality more arcadey mech game, like other console mech titles. Any mech action fan should definitely give it a try, the language barrier isn’t too much of an issue.
The other ground vehicle combat games are much weaker and are very borderline for a mention here. Spearhead (PC), for instance, uses the iM1A2 Abrams (PC, 1997) engine for a more arcadey action-focused game. It’s apparently mediocre. Two others, iPanzer ’44 (PC) and Panzer Commander (PC), sound like they are worse than that. Still, four tank sims is a solid lineup, particularly when one is an all-time great. As I said earlier, this would really be the last great year for tank-exclusive sims, before they got consumed into general military simulation action games like War Thunder or ARMA.
Overall, mech sims in particular were very weak in ’98, as I mentioned in the first article. Gungriffon II is a good game, but 1999 brought four major mech games, three for PC — MechWarrior III, Heavy Gear 2, and Starsiege — and one for Playstation, Armored Core 2. Yeah. On the other hand, these go in FPS and not Simulation, but the two powered suit with jetpack shooters, Starsiege: Tribes and Outwars, are good. Additionally, the three FPS/RTS tank game hybrid titles are interesting, and not something we have seen many of since. The best one is Battlezone (1998). And lastly there were two mech strategy games in 1998 that are pure strategy games, most notably the great MechCommander (PC). The other one is CyberStorm II: Corporate Wars (PC).
Beyond that, for some reason GameFAQs decided that all of the car and tank combat action driving games should go in this subgenre of Simulation. Seeing Twisted Metal III (PS1) be called a simulation game is really quite wrong. Future Cop LAPD (PS1/PC), which I put in Action – Misc. shooting games, is a more valid inclusion than Twisted Metal, though I wouldn’t put it here either. I like Wikipedia’s listings more, and agree with them for all of these games plus more, such as Spearhead (PC) and BattleTanx (N64) that they put in their correct genres. I’m sorry to spend so much time in this article discussing genre categorization, something few to no readers are likely to care about, but I do care.
Simulation – Vehicle (Civilian)
This is a genre for civilian trading sims like Euro Truck Simulator. There aren’t any combat-free trading sims from ’98, only some games with both fighting and trading such as Hardwar (PC) and Vangers (PC). The first Hard Truck (PC) did release in 1998, but it’s not really a trading game like its sequels are but instead is a racing game, and not a very good one at that. It didn’t make the list for the racing genre above. Also, unlike its sequels, it’s not open world. You can carry cargo, but it’s not a trading game.
-Vehicle (Train) – Train-driving sims have long been a popular genre in Japan. The first key work in this genre released in ’97, Densha de Go! (PS1, 1997). A PC port did release in 1998, along with a couple of knockoffs of unknown quality, Densha Daisuki: Plarail de Ippai (PS1) and Pocket Densha (GB). Densha Daisuki does have a dedicated train handle controller that released with it, like the one for Densha de Go!, so it had some effort put into it, but it did not become a series. There is also a European train sim which got bad reviews called 3D Railroad Master (PC).
Simulation – Virtual (Career, Pet, Virtual Life) – Virtual Career games weren’t much of a thing in 1998, but Virtual Pet and Virtual Life games are. I do not know what order these games should go in, but there are a bunch of options. Western titles include Catz 3 (PC), Dogz 3 (PC), and Creatures 2 (PC). Creatures 2 is the best reviewed of those by far. In Japan the Tamagotchi craze was in full swing, and the Playstation, Saturn, and Game Boy all got Tamagotchi games. I don’t know their quality. Sega Saturn de Hakken!!: Tamagocchi Park (SAT; JP only), Game de Hakken!! Tamagotchi Osucchi to Mesucchi (GB; JP only), Hoshi de Hakken!! Tamagotchi (PS; JP only). There were a bunch of other virtual life games as well of various qualities. One more notable one is Melon-chan’s Growth Diary (NGP, JP only), an interesting early Neo Geo Pocket game. Hey You, Pikachu (N64; JP release, US 2000) also released in 1998, complete with its required microphone accessory. In this very simple game for young kids you talk to Pikachu and he supposedly does things, though it doesn’t work very well. Still, this talk-to-virtual-life-creatures genre would become popular for a short time, best known for Seaman (Dreamcast, 1999).
Additionally, in Japan some adventure games are called SLG titles, or Simulation Love Games, so you may see them listed as simulations. Some of these do have simulation elements, but most generally are considered adventure games first. There are more games in both Pet and Virtual Life, but I have no idea if any are noteworthy so I will leave it there.
Sports and Wrestling
For this genre there are two approaches: the games with the highest review averages at the time, or the games with the most lasting relevance, such as it is. The two lists have similarities but are not the same. Either way, I find it very hard to choose an order here; games get very different review scores on different platforms, ones’ favorite sport heavily colors which ones any person or source prefers, and such. Do not take the order here seriously.
For this subgenre, the number in brackets after each title is that games’ professional review average on Mobygames. I went with this over the MobyRank because the more I look at that, the less I like how 50% of it comes from the user ranking on a site with often few user scores.
Top List By Lasting Relevance: WCW vs. NWO Revenge (N64), NFL Blitz 99 (Arcade; N64 ’99 as NFL Blitz 2000), International Superstar Soccer ’98 (N64), Madden ’99 (N64/PS1/PC), FIFA ’99 (N64/PS1/PC) or World Cup ’98 (N64/PC/PS1).
Top List By Review Average (ranking by version which scored the highest): International Superstar Soccer ’98 (N64) [91%], NHL ’99 (PC; lower scores on N64/PS1) [90% PC; 86/85/80 on consoles], Links LS 1999 (PC) [89%], International Superstar Soccer Pro ’98 (PS1) [89%], FIFA ’99 (N64/PC/PS1) [89/88/88/87% across platforms].
More 1998 Sports Gmaes By Review Average: World Cup ’98 (N64/PC/PS1) (89/88/86/85% across platforms), International Superstar Soccer Pro ’98 (PS1) [89%], Madden ’99 (N64/PS1/PC) [88% on N64; much lower on PC/PS1], NFL GameDay 99 (PS1/PC) [87% on PS1, lower on PC], NBA Live 99 (PC/N64/PS1) [85%], NFL Blitz ’99 (Arcade) [no listing, but the later N64 version, NFL Blitz 2000 (N64, 1999), got an 85%. Lower on other platforms.], NFL Quarterback Club (N64) [85%], NCAA Football 99 (PS1/PC) [85% on PS1, much lower on PC], Kobe Bryant in NBA Courtside (N64) [83%], Tiger Woods ’99 PGA Tour Golf (PC/PS1) [81% on PC, lower on PS1], WCW / NWO Revenge (N64) [80%], All-Star Baseball ’99 (N64) [80%], Battle Flip Shot (Arcade/NG), Major League Baseball featuring Ken Griffey Jr. (N64) [77%], High Heat Baseball ’99 (PC/PS1) [69%], and more.
Special Note: The home release of NFL Blitz (N64/PS1/PC) happened in 1998, after releasing in arcades in ’97. This was one of the most popular and successful sports games of the year but is excluded because of my ‘first year of release’ rule.
I am a baseball fan, so what I care about the most here are the baseball games. And for baseball games, unlike other sports, I like more simmish games. In other sports I generally prefer the most arcadey games possible — NBA Jam is my favorite basketball game for example — but for baseball I prefer something more realistic. 1998 had a solid assortment of baseball games, with at least seven or eight major titles releasing across various platforms. Of them, the most popular as far as review scores goes is clearly Acclaim’s All-Star Baseball ’99 (N64), a title with probably the best graphics in any baseball game from ’98, great pitching and batting control, and more simmish elements than the usual console game. It will never match my nostalgic favorite baseball game ever, Accolade’s classic Hardball 3 (PC, 1992, also on Sega Genesis without the real MLB players that the PC version has from an addon disc), but it is certainly good. On the PC side, though, which one of the four major baseball games was best depends on who you ask. PC Gamer (US) magazine had a clear favorite though, they rated High Heat ’99 (PC/PS1) an 86% while the other three titles were in the 60’s. High Heat has sprite-based characters so it is simpler than some, but the core gameplay is pretty good. It was a new franchise from 3DO and began a popular series. Other sources disagree and prefer Triple Play ’99 (PC/PS1/N64) or Microsoft Baseball 3D (PC). It’s too bad that Hardball 6 (PC/PS1) wasn’t better, but sadly it marked the decline of that previously genre-leading franchise. There would be only one more game in the series before it ended, Hardball 6 2000 Edition (PC, 1999). Major League Baseball featuring Ken Griffey Jr. (N64) is also a popular classic for the more arcadey baseball fans, though its sequel Ken Griffey Jr.’s Slugfest (N64, 1999) is an improved version of the same thing, so that is the one you should play. I chose to put All-Star Baseball ’99 in the top list and High Heat in the runners-up category because the former is the year’s most acclaimed title, the ’98 baseball game with the highest average on MobyGames, and the 1998 baseball game I have rated the most highly on my list. High Heat also places because of PCG’s support and its solid classic baseball gameplay.
Anyway, sports games are a staple, and most of them are yearly titles in ongoing series. Either the game is a title in the middle of a decades-long franchise, as with EA’s sports serieses, or it is the first game in a series as with High Heat Baseball ’99, or one of the last like Hardball 6, or a one-off like Microsoft Baseball 3D, but regardless, they are titles that often become outdated quickly since there are new sports games in all of those same sports the next year. All of the next years’ games may not be better, but some will be. In baseball for instance, High Heat and All-Star Baseball would both improve further over the next few years. Nobody would believe that this list is a list of the best sports games ever because 1998 wasn’t a year with many fully new all-time classics that manage to break out the usual come-and-go nature of sports games and actualy stick around in the public conciousness like NBA Jam (Arcade, etc, 1992) or NHL ’94 (Sega Genesis, 1993).
Moving on to sports outside of baseball, which games or series around in ’98 stand out the most, were best at the time, or have remained in the public conciousness in the years since? In that latter category, the title I put in first on the list is a part of the most popular series ever in wrestling history, Aki’s Nintendo 64 wrestling games. 1998 did not bring the most popular Aki N64 wrestling game today, that would be their last one, WWF No Mercy (N64, 2000). However, it did bring their best selling one, WCW/NWO Revenge (N64), which was the second AKI-developed wrestling game released on the N64 in the West and their third overall. The gameplay and engine are pretty much the same as the WWF games to follow, just with different characters and maybe a few less modes. WCW/NWO Revenge is one of the best selling third party N64 games ever, as well, and was Aki’s last WCW game before switching over to the WWF (now WWE). I dislike wrestling quite a lot myself, but I know how legendary these games are to their large fanbase as much as anyone. This series deserves its place here. Aki’s main competition was Acclaim’s WWF WarZone (PS1). It was a successful game at the time, but as more people played the Aki games Acclaims’ rapidly faded in popularity. Acclaim’s games are more complex to play, Aki’s simpler and more approachable.
Of the team sports games, Konami’s International Superstar Soccer ’98 (N64, also Pro version on PS1 from a different team) was the most popular and most highly acclaimed. ISS ’99 is one of Konami’s most beloved early soccer games and has the highest user score of any sports game from 1998 on Mobygames today. This title is the clear winner.
Following that, both at the time and today the next tier is dominated by EA Sports titles. I put Madden and FIFA on the first list because they are both still very successful franchises today. On Madden, Madden ’99 sounds like a fine football game but probably not the best one in the series, as this century’s Madden games are more popular than the ones from the ’90s. Madden ’99 did introduce one important feature though, Franchise Mode. That would become central to the experience over time. In Madden series rankings it often is ranked as the best Madden game of the ’90s, but series fans have a strong preference for the Madden games of the ’00s to mid ’10s so it does not finish all that high on most lists. When it comes to EA’s soccer series then called FIFA, the 1997 entry is the most popular retro FIFA game, Road to the World Cup ’98, due to its huge team lineup and that you can play both the World Cup qualifiers and a full tournament. 1998 saw two releases, FIFA ’99 and World Cup ’98, but both have fewer teams than the previous year’s entry and aren’t quite as popular. World Cup ’98 only lets you play as the teams that actually made the tournament, not all the potential qualifiers as the previous one did. Neither EA title matches up to ISS, but EA was the biggest name in sports so more people played its games anyway.
Don’t forget EA’s other sports games, either — NBA Live ’99 and NHL ’99 were also quite popular, award-winning titles. NBA Live ’99 may have a lower review average but PC Gamer (US) gave it Sports Game of the Year, for example. Most other sports awards were won by those home console releases of 1997 arcade great NFL Blitz (N64, particularly). It is a fantastic, and violent, arcade football game. I can’t stand football but quite like NFL Blitz. The new arcade title NFL Blitz ’99 released this year as well, and improves over the original across the board. It would release on consoles the next year as NFL Blitz 2000 (PS1/N64/DC, 1999). Whether NFL Blitz 2000 (aka ’99 in arcades) or 2001 (aka 2000 Pro in arcades) is the better game is a question debated by series fans, but either way NFL Blitz 99 is one of the best arcade-style football games ever made. After 1999 Midway abandoned arcades and most of their series started to decline.
As for games from other companies, Sony’s NFL GameDay ’99 (PS1 ver.) won best sports game of ’98 from several Playstation-only outlets. Somewhat forgotten today due to its developer not surviving the ’00s but a very successful big name franchise in the ’90s, Access Software’s Links LS ’99 golf game was one of the best and most successful sports games of the year. There is a large gap between its review average and EA’s golf title. Acclaim also had a good football game in the N64 exclusive NFL Quarterback Club ’99.
And last but not least, Nintendo released several sports games in ’98 on the N64: quality realistic basketball game Kobe Bryant’s NBA Courtside, a title which would start a three-game series on N64 and GC; snowboard racing great 1080 Degrees Snowboarding, who some would put in Sports; and the aforementioned baseball game Major League Baseball Featuring Ken Griffey Jr., which is quite fun.
One title which could possibly be put in this genre is the fun arcade game Battle Flip Shot (NG). It is one of several Pong-inspired Neo-Geo games. As Pong is based on tennis and table tennis, I thought that Sports was probably the best place for this game, though you could go with Arcade Action as well. Like Windjammers before it, two people bounce a ball back and forth, but with a lot of added stuff to make the game much more exciting than the original Pong was. It’s a great fun game, though developer Visco would improve on the title in its followup, Bang Bead (NG, 2000).
Overall, while these games are still fun for fans of their subgenres, obviously this genre’s list won’t convince anyone that this is an all-time list. Sports games are too ephemeral for that, and the most popular retro sports games are older titles like Tecmo Super Bowl, NBA Jam, or NHL ’94, not anything from 1998. And for skateboarding and by extension extreme sports, most of those go in Racing, but if we want to consider them here then 1998 slips even further, because Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater, the title that defines that genre, released in 1999. The nineties may have been an era of extreme game themes and extreme advertising, but when it comes to content ’98 has nothing on ’99 for skateboarding. The only skateboarding game in ’98 was Street Sk8er (PS1; JP ’98, US ’99), and by all accounts it’s nowhere close to Tony Hawk. However, if we consider that 1080 Degrees Snowboarding (N64) and Motocross Madness (PC) were 1998 releases with pretty solid trick systems, the year actually holds up pretty well and certainly beats any before it in this field.
Now, you may think thaqt’s more than enough about sports games, but it’s not; I haven’t discussed plenty of other sports subgenres yet, like hunting or boxing games. So, here is a list of all sports subgenres, with comments for ones I have not mentioned yet.
Addendum: Sports – Best By Sport
Individual Sports
- Athletics – None (there was a winter olympics in 1998, not a summer one, and the main winter olympics game from Konami released at the end of 1997.)
- Biking – MTB Dirtcross (PS1; Japan only) or perhaps Big Thanks Super Keirin (Saturn; this was a demo not sold at retail and it’s unclear if it released in ’97 or ’98), though the latter is a track cycling game so the settings are less interesting than Dirtcross’s are.
- Billiards – Virtual Pool 64 (N64). This is based off of Virtual Pool 2 (PC, 1997), I believe.
- Bowling – Animaniacs: Ten Pin Alley (PS1) or Brunswick World Pro Bowling (PS1; later ported to PC (2000) and N64 (1999))
- Combat – Boxing – Knockout Kings (PS1). EA’s Knockout Kings / Fight Night series would last over a decade and did reasonably well, and it started here.
- Combat – Wrestling – WCW/NWO Revenge (N64); second: WWF WarZone (PS1).
- Futuristic – Battle Flip Shot (NG)
- Golf – Links LS ’99 (PC); second: Tiger Woods PGA Tour ’99 (PC/PS1).
- Horse Racing – There were a half dozen horse racing games in ’98, including both gambling horse raising sims such as Winning Post 3: Program ’98 (PS1, JP only) and horse games for girls (Barbie Adventures: Riding Club (PC). I don’t know which ones are best.
- Nature – Hunting – There were a lot of fishing and hunting games released in 1998, dozens of them. These were very popular but most were very low budget games that weren’t very good. This was particularly true for the mostly bad hunting games. I’ve never played any of these but I’ll go with Carnivores (PC) for hunting because you are a time traveller hunting dinosaurs in that one and it sounds like it’s competently made. For regular hunting, Deer Hunter II (PC) isn’t very good but is less bad than the infamously abysmal first one. The first several Cabela’s Big Game Hunter games released on PC in ’98 as well but they reviewed poorly also.
- Nature – Fishing – For fishing, a whole lot of games released, but I’ll go with the Harvest Moon spinoff fishing RPG series, River King/Nushi Tsuri. There were several games that year: Nushi Tsuri 64 (N64, JP only), Kawa no Nushi Tsuri: Hikyou o Motomete (PS1; JP only), and Umi no Nushi Tsuri 2 (GB, JP only). I don’t know which is best but all three have similar concepts. The previous entry in the series, Legend of the River King (GB; JP ’97, US ’98), released in the US this year as well. If you want a traditional fishing game maybe try Fisherman’s Bait: A Bass Challenge (PS1/Arcade); it sounds okay.
- Other – There were a few little darts and such games released in ’98 but I don’t know if any are good, I can’t find much about them.
- Skate – Street Sk8er (PS1; JP ’98, US ’99). The definitive skateboarding game released in 1999, Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater. This title is a bit like it but much less complicated and acclaimed. It’s all ’98 has for skateboarding games though.
- Ski/Snowboard – 1080 Degrees Snowboarding (N64). There are others but this one is far and away the best.
- Surf/Wakeboard – None
- Tennis – Centre Court Tennis (N64; JP ’98, EU ’99, not released in the US) is a perfectly decent average game, so it wins in a thin field… unless you count Battle Flip Shot (NG) as a Tennis game, in which case I’d give it to that one. The definitive tennis game would release the next year in Sega’s Virtua Tennis (Arcade; later DC).
Team Sports
- Baseball – All-Star Baseball ’99 (N64)
- Basketball – NBA Live ’99 (PC/PS1/N64)
- Cricket – Brian Lara Cricket (PC/PS1; EU/Oceania only release)
- Football – Madden NFL ’99 (PC/PS1/N64)
- Futuristic – Dead Ball Zone (PS1)
- Ice Hockey – NHL ’99 (PC/PS1/N64)
- Rugby – None
- Other – Dodge de Ball! (PS1; JP release, US 2003 as XS Junior League Dodgeball) – this is a Super Dodge Ball style game but very low budget.
- Soccer – International Superstar Soccer ’98 (N64)
- Volleyball – V-Ball: Beach Volley Heroes (PS1; EU only)
Strategy
Strategy – Real-Time, Turn-Based, or Wargame
Top List: Starcraft: Brood War (PC; Mac 1999), Shining Force III Scenarios 2 and 3 (SAT; JP only), Worms 2 (PC), Norm Koger’s The Operational Art of War, Vol. 1: 1939-1955 (PC), MechCommander (PC).
Honorable Mentions: Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines (PC), Sakura Wars 2 (SAT; JP only), Myth II: Soulblighter (PC/Mac).
Others, Mostly Good: See below for lists of Western and Japanese games respectively.
The top four in this genre are all popular and important classics among the best ever. Starcraft is the best thing ever, but I covered it in the first article. It is an RTS legend, and a game still played professionally today. Worms 2 is the essential Worms game which defined the visual look of the rest of the franchise. It is a brilliant turn-based strategy classic. TOAOW is a very important title in the wargaming subgenre which was regarded by PC Gamer and others as the years’ best wargame and started a noteworthy series of turn-based strategy games. And last but definitely not least, Shining Force III is a beloved trilogy which still has devoted fans. There were other Japanese tactical strategy games in ’98 other than SFIII, but that is the clear most popular one. On Worms 2 in particular, I have never understood why its sequel, Worms Armageddon, is the one that seems to be remembered the most. Armageddon is, in fact, pretty much just Worms 2 but with a full-screen interface instead of Worms 2’s basic Windows menus and a few new items. Oh, and it saves your progress in the single player with save files instead of having to write down passwords as Worms 2 did for some stupid reason. Armageddon is just a level and item pack expansion for Worms 2, all of the core gameplay and graphics are identical. They even tried to lie about Armageddon being special for its online play, but Worms 2 had online play also, with lobbies and everything, built in to the game! I played it. Worms 2 is the game that defined what a Worms game looks and plays like. I think it is by far the most important release in the series. As for the others, TOAOW is one of the few older wargames that genre fans might put on a top games list. The game has a large scope within its time period, there are 15 scenarios (battles) you can fight included, and powerful editing tools for people to make their own as well. Earlier hit wargames like Panzer General or Steel Panthers are much more mass market focused, but TOAOW tries to be both semi-approachable and a serious title, and succeeds at it. Learning the interface will take a while, there are 28 buttons in the upper right for example, but it really isn’t impenitrably complex. This is the iconic classic wargame. The graphics are a nice map with digital versions of cardboard counters on the spaces, which really are all you need.
There are basically three major things which differentiate strategy games: whether they are real-time or turn-based, whether they have base building or exclusively have unit tactics, and the level of complexity of the game, simpler or more complicated. Turn-based games without base building can be either simpler tactical strategy games like Shining Force, or complex wargames like TOAW. Wargames are dense unit control games, and in the 20th century were hugely popular. Commandos, MechCommander, and Myth, however, are games with only unit control during battles and with small to moderate numbers of units, also known as tactical strategy games. Of them I picked MechCommander for the top spot because I had the most fun with it and it has a deeper strategic base layer than the others; you can customize your mechs in between missions, which is great fun. Next is Commandos, a small unit tactical strategy game which was a massive breakout hit for its Spanish developer. The game combines stealth and strategic combat in a brilliant way. As for Myth II: Soulblighter, it might have a slightly higher review average than Commandos, but for long-term industry impact, when comparing these two units-only, no-building tactical strategy games, there is no question which is more important: Commandos. Commandos created a subgenre somewhat popular to this day with titles such as Shadow Tactics. Myth didn’t. Also, Myth is a good game but I just don’t like it as much as those other games myself, it feels like a classic RTS but you can’t build units, instead of something else like a wargame or Commandos do. And in an RTS, I like base building.
Also of note, though below the top tier greats of the above category: West Front (Wargame) (PC), People’s General (Wargame) (PC), Police Quest: SWAT 2 (Real-Time Tactics) (PC), Dune 2000 (RTS) (PC), M.A.X. 2 (RTS/TBS hybrid) (PC), KKND 2 (PC), CyberStorm 2: Corporate Wars (PC), Battlezone (FPS-strategy) (PC), Star Wars: Rebellion (4X) (PC), Uprising 2 (FPS-strategy) (PC), Urban Assault (FPS-strategy) (PC), Dominion: Storm over Gift 3 (RTS) (PC), Liberation Day (TBS) (PC), 101st Airborne in Normandy (Wargame) (PC), Jeff Wayne’s The War of the Worlds (PC). Also remember that building sims are a separate genre on this list, which is why they are not here — Anno 1602, The Settlers III, and such, are in Simulation.
Of these games, the first two, the turn-based wargames West Front and People’s General, are the best for sure. Both are high quality titles that don’t quite match up to The Operational Art of War but are certainly good games from popular series of the day. People’s General particularly is much more approachable than the others as well; the General series was designed for the mass market and not only hardcore wargaming fans. It models a near-future war between China and NATO. The rest of these games are all fine to good, but mostly aren’t all-timers for most. War of the Worlds is an interesting game with both a strategic map layer and battles, but it’s unbalanced. The original Dune 2 is noteworthy for being the game that created the RTS genre as we know it, but its modernized remake here is more like, oh yeah, in between Command & Conquer games they did that thing, a remake of Dune 2 but even more like C&C now. It’s alright but did not match the C&C games in popularity. It’s probably the best traditional RTS in this group, though, as it’s solidly made, though it was considered disappointing at the time. People expected more than just a faithful remake with enhanced graphics.
Beyond that, the three RTS/FPS hybrid titles are pretty interesting. All three have you commanding some kind of craft, with which you both fight directly and build and command a base. The best of them is Battlezone, an acclaimed title which won awards for its high quality. This game is far more than just some classic game remake; it is surprisingly good. Uprising 2 and Urban Assault are like it but not as good, though one little otherwise obscure subgenre getting three games in one year is pretty interesting. That would not happen again; after Battlezone 2 (2000) this subgenre died off.
The other standard RTSes are the generic Command & Conquer clone KKND 2, which is a lot like the first one (PC, 1997), and Dominion, which at the time was known for all the wrong reasons. Dominion was somewhat infamous because of its publisher, Ion Storm, which was working on a certain FPS by John Romero you have surely heard of. This very average game was its first release. Dominion focuses heavily on combat over base or resource management, as you have no workers at all and mines mine out quickly, while units all have a whole menu full of tactical options such as Crouch and Prone. Also realtime is CyberStorm 2, which is a bit like MechCommander but with a straight overhead view and less ambitious design. Last is the pretty flawed RTS/FPS hybrid M.A.X. 2. As I said in the 4X category, Star Wars: Rebellion is also considered disappointing and flawed. It is a very micromanagement-heavy game.
What about real-time tactical strategy games? This subgenre was rare at the time, but did exist. The best has to be Dragon Force 2 (SAT; JP only). The Saturn had an exceptional strategy lineup in ’98, it’s too bad most of it did not continue onto the Dreamcast, Sakura Wars aside. Dragon Force is an interesting unit tactics game with groups of soldiers. The best known Western tactical strategy game this year is probably Police Quest: SWAT 2. It got mixed reviews, but its small unit police simulation tactics allow for good control of the situation as you try to capture or kill the criminals in each area. There are also a handful of PC games I know little about such as War Along the Mohawk (PC) and Metalizer (PC, EU only).
On the turn-based front, People’s General is a good wargame. It is the final 2d game in SSI’s series of casual wargames that started with 1993’s Panzer General. 101st Airborne in Normandy is a love-or-hate game with a low review average but a few very high scores and some ‘best wargame of the year’ nominations. Liberation Day is an interesting game. It looks a bit like an RTS in design, except it isn’t, it’s turn-based. It has nice visuals. M.A.X.2 also has a turn-based mode if you really want to play that game.
Other noteworthy Japanese turn-based tactical strategy (aka Strategy-RPG) games of 1998 [Other than Shining Force III Scenarios II and III, that is]: Black/Matrix (PS1/SAT, JP only), Kartia: The Word of Fate (PS1; JP ’98, US ’99); Langrisser V: The End of Legend (SAT, JP only), Sakura Taisen 2: Kimi, Shiitamou koto Nakare (SAT, JP only), Wachenroder (SAT, JP only).
These games are all good to great. All of these games have battles with grid-based, turn-based battles between small teams of units, as is common in the tactics genre. Shining Force III Scenarios II and III are beloved classics, and many series fans insist that no Shining game released after these two matter. Of the games in this category though my favorite is Wachenroder, which has nice graphics and some great art design. Sakura Taisen 2 is surely the most popular, however. It was one of the Saturn’s best-selling games, after all. It has visual novel sections in between the battles. Langrisser V is also sadly notable for being the end of its series. Yes, it’s yet another noteworthy, long-running series that ended in ’98. The first Langrisser released in the US as Warsong for Sega Genesis, if that rings a bell. The original five titles are all very good tactical strategy games with a few series-unique twists, such as that each character has a bunch of follower soldiers.
Looking back, the best game ever (StarCraft) aside, honestly while there were a lot of RTSes in ’98, ’97 has more top tier RTSes. ’94: WarCraft I. ’95: Command & Conquer, WarCraft II. ’96: Command & Conquer: Red Alert. ’97: NetStorm: Islands At War, Age of Empires, Total Annihilation, Myth, Star Command. ’98: StarCraft, Myth II. ’99: Age of Empires II, Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun, Total Annihilation: Kingdoms. ’00: Command & Conquer: Red Alert 2. ’01: Conquest: Frontier Wars. ’02: WarCraft III. ’03 to ’10: Age of Empires III, Rise of Nations, Warhammer 40k: Dawn of War (series), Rise of Nations 2, Supreme Commander, Supreme Commander 2. 2011: Starcraft II. After that: Beyond All Reason (freeware), Age of Empires IV, Tempest Rising, and of course the Starcraft, Age of Empires II, and Age of Empires III remasters. AoE II and III both have new official content additions as well, exclusively for the remasters. Starcraft Remastered, Age of Empires II Remaster, Tempest Rising, Warcraft III, Age of Empires IV, and Beyond All Reason still have active multiplayer communities. You can find a match in NetStorm or Warcraft II with patience as well.
Strategy – 4X or Grand Strategy
Top List: Star Wars: Rebellion (PC), Deadlock II: Shrine Wars (PC).
Noteworthy Enhancements of Older Titles: Civilization II: Multiplayer Gold Edition (PC; enhanced collection release of the original game from 1996 and its expansions), Lords of Magic: Special Edition (PC; enchanced release of 1997’s original game with an exclusive new expansion).
The Only Other 4X Games This Year: Two very obscure Europe-only titles not released in English – Galax Empires (PC; EU only, German, Spanish, a few other languages), Remember Tomorrow (PC; Russia only, in Russian)
This category combines two types of strategy games that now are often considered types of 4X games but have significant differences. Grand Strategy games have a larger scope than just a single small map. Generally there is a world map and also some kind of zoomed-in view of cities and perhaps also some kind of strategic battles. This term seems to be rarely used now, though I am glad to say that it is still a tag on Steam, but was a common one in the ’90s and is still how I refer to this kind of game, titles like Heroes of Might & Magic or Total War. “4X” is a reference from Master of Orion, a beloved grand strategy game of the mid ’90s, and refers to titles like Civilization, where your main focus is on controlling an empire. I would say 4X games are a subset of grand strategy, but either way on that one, I call this category 4X Grand Strategy to say that this category covers both 4X games and Grand Strategy. As a note, some of these are turn-based while others are real-time, but battles aside that difference isn’t as important as it sounds in this genre, gameplay is similar either way. Anyway, this genre was in the Weak Genres category in article one for a reason. There were two somewhat noteworthy 4X games released in 1998, but both are flawed. I went back and forth on whether they were weak enough to put this genre in the ‘relatively weak’ category or the one above it, as both have their fans and do some things right, but when the only two fully new games have such low review averages, I’m sorry but I think it is deserved. Both are somewhat niche titles that general audiences, even general audiences of people who like 4X games, mostly rejected.
Those games are Deadlock II: Shrine Wars and Star Wars: Rebellion. Deadlock and Rebellion are both very dense, menu-heavy titles. Star Wars: Rebellion is a very menu-dense 4X space empire game. The battle system allows for interesting strategic fights, but most people rapidly lost interest in its seas of menus and it was regarded as one of the more disappointing games of ’98, though it has some fans. Deadlock 2 is more in the economic strategy genre, with a heavy focus on base creation and management of your base and the resources it generates. There are battles, fought turn-based style, but they are a clear sideline to the economics. You could put this in the same category as titles like Anno 1602 or The Settlers, though Deadlock is American instead of European so it has a bit of a different style. It is a part of a then-popular subgenre of sci-fi space strategy economic management focused titles. Some people like these kinds of games, but I am not one of them. It got mediocre reviews.
The other “new” 4X games of ’98 are better games, but weren’t entirely new. The highlight is the best version of my favorite 4X game ever, the incomparably great Civilization II. Civilization II: Multiplayer Gold Edition includes the original game, both expansions, and new multiplayer features and 32-bit Windows 9x support; the original game is for 16-bit Windows 3.1. This sounds great, but the one downside is that most of the music is missing; this disc oddly only has the music from the second expansion, Forgotten Worlds. All music tracks from the original game and first expansion are absent. So, the best way to play Civ II is with a MGE install, but played with the Forgotten Worlds CD, since that has all the music. Regardless, this is a quite noteworthy release.
The other game is Lords of Magic: Special Edition, a slightly improved version of Lords of Magic (PC, 1997), from Sierra. I was a big fan of Lords of the Realm II (PC, 1996), but found this one disappointing at the time; it goes for more of a Heroes of Might & Magic approach than Lords of the Realm, but even more restrictive. You only control your heroes and their armies instead of fully managing your empire. In the original game you can’t even build units without going back to a city! This release does improve on elements like that, and LoM has good turn-based strategic battles, but it’s mostly the same game with a few more features, and people who bought the original had to buy this version too to get the new content, the expansion wasn’t sold on its own. Sierra did something similar with Red Baron 3D (PC), an enhancement of Red Baron II (PC, 1997). In both cases there was a discount for buyers of the original game, but still, why was LoM: Legend of Urak, the expansion, not also sold on its own?
Overall, ’98 is an okay year for 4X games, but certainly isn’t one of the better ones. However, people wanting the greatest of 4X games wouldn’t have long to wait; early 1999’s Alpha Centauri is that. Alternately you could continue to play older classics like Master of Orion II or Civilization II. Subsequently, Europa Universalis (PC, 2000) finally showed that a dense, systems and menu-heavy strategy game could also be a big hit.that managed to succeed at interesting the kind of audience that Rebellion mostly failed to win over. Europa Universalis’ European developer Paradox still dominates that subgenre today. If you look online though you will find a few Rebellion fans out there. The other major advance in the genre also happened in 2000, when Shogun: Total War (PC, 2000) released. Total War’s fomula of a simple 4X strategic layer combined with quite good strategic real-time wargame combat was an instant hit, building off of Lords of the Realm II but with fully 3d battles. The Total War series is also still around.
As a final strategy games aside, as exceptional as 1998 is, it does have my favorite game ever after all in StarCraft, perhaps it is nostalgia but the year between the end of 1995 and the end of 1996 is, I think, overall strategy gaming’s best year. In particular this was the year of 2’s, games that are all number two in their series and all-time greats: WarCraft II: Tides of Darkness (PC, 1995), Civilization II (PC, 1996), Caesar II (PC, 1996), Lords of the Realm II (PC, 1996), Master of Orion II (PC, 1996), Command & Conquer: Red Alert (PC, 1996; this is the second C&C game)… it’s crazy how many unbelievable sequels that year had. Most of those games had sequels that released between ’97 and ’99, some better than their predecessors and some not as good, but Starcraft aside I think the rest of the ’96 games are more special.
Strategy – best games by each GameFAQs subgenre
- General – The usual n/a category.
- Management – Separated into two subcategories:
- Business/Tycoon – This is in Simulation. Railroad Tycoon II (PC) is the clear leader.
- Government – This is in Simulation. I chose Anno 1602 (PC).
- Real-Time – Separated into five subcategories:
- Command – Starcraft (PC)
- Defense – Starcraft (PC) – The tower defense genre was invented in Starcraft, created by users as user-made custom Starcraft maps, so this is a very easy choice.
- General – the usual N/A category.
- MOBA – The MOBA genre didn’t exist yet. Play a real RTS like Starcraft… heh.
- Tactics – Dragon Force II (Saturn, JP only) or SWAT 2 (PC).
- Turn-Based – Also separated into five subcategories:
- 4X – Star Wars: Rebellion is probably the best of a small bunch, if we don’t count Civilization II: Multiplayer Gold Edition since it is an enhanced re-release.
- Artillery – Worms 2 has artillery game roots, so that.
- Card Battle – Pokemon Trading Card Game (GB; JP release, US later).
- General – Norm Koger’s The Operational Art of War, because Wargames don’t have a separate subgenre on GameFAQs, though they probably should have one.
- Tactics – Shining Force III: Scenario 2 and Shining Force III: Scenario 3, for sure. Following them, Sakura Wars 2.
And with that this list is finally complete, apart from whatever I add to it in the future that is, and I am sure I will add to it. Next time: a section on open-world games in 1998, some lists of the best games of the year and of all time from various publications and websites, my gaming year in 1998, and concluding thoughts. It will be a much shorter article than this one.















